2 ms·
>Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. That's an a priori assumption though. Who arrived at the conclusion it was "extraordinary" and with what
by coldtea 5y ago
>Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
That's an a priori assumption though. Who arrived at the conclusion it was "extraordinary" and with what scientific methods? Not based on research, for one, because that's what we're evaluating here: research results positive to that claim. We could say: "We have a bias against it being true", but the "extraordinary claim" part is BS within the context of the scientific method.
As for applying Bayes, the "prior" (in fields where it's not mathematically determined, like e.g. judging whether a coin is fair), is just another name for "at will bias".