4 ms·
That NFT hype makes it look like yet another get-rich-quick pyramid scheme to me. Can you please clearly explain exactly what you're using NFTs for that you cou
by DonHopkins 5y ago
That NFT hype makes it look like yet another get-rich-quick pyramid scheme to me. Can you please clearly explain exactly what you're using NFTs for that you couldn't easily and less destructively implement some better way, without burning so much coal, causing cancer, and destroying the environment?
If your business can't grow and succeed without shilling NFTs, then you don't have anything of actual value. NFTs aren't magic pixie dust that make everyone rich. Unless you're running a money laundering operation.
- ahelwer 5y agoNot an NFT guy but according to https://papyrusnft.io/ https://papyrusnft.io/ they're enabling non-Ethereum chains which will address the environmental concerns.
- meowface 5y ago>https://papyrusnft.io https://papyrusnft.io It's good they're trying to find less environmentally-costly alternatives, but the mere existence of this domain makes the whole enterprise feel much more sketchy and greasy to me, honestly. Not to mention the content on it.
- DonHopkins 5y agoWhat makes it even sketchier and greasier is ahelwer's spurious claim that PapyrusNFT made any claims on that site that they're "enabling non-Ethereum chains which will address the environmental concerns". And the bizarre, unfocused little Japanese company I found at the "Company" link at the bottom of the page doesn't inspire any confidence either. Scammers assume that if they just toss out a URL and say it proves something, most people won't even bother to check, and just believe them. And unfortunately that trick usually works. Even if the site actually did claim what ahelwer falsely claimed it claims, the claim that all the environmental problems will be solved "real soon now" is such a painfully tired cliché that shills and apologists make all the time, but never deliver on. It worked for Trump shilling his "incredible" health care plan that he'd reveal "real soon now", so why not apply it to shilling NFTs to the same gullible suckers? Incredible, indeed. If that's true, then why doesn't everybody just immediately stop minting NFTs and mining Proof of Work cryptocurrency and wasting so much energy and burning so much coal right now, and simply wait until the problem's solved, since the shills always claim that it will be solved "real soon now"? Can't those money-laundering pump-and-dumping spoiled brats with $300,000 to burn wait another two weeks for the bragging rights to yet another computer generated monkey cartoon?
- DonHopkins 5y agoPlease provide links showing where exactly on https://papyrusnft.io/ https://papyrusnft.io/ it says anything at all about "enabling non-Ethereum chains" or "the environmental concerns". I clicked on every link to see if there was anything about what you claim, and I can find absolutely no useful information about anything at all on that site, and certainly not the words you quoted. I performed google searches for "site:papyrusnft.io ethereum" and "site:papyrusnft.io environmental" and that also turned up absolutely nothing (although the site is indexed by google). I even used the tab key to enumerate through every link on the web site to make sure I was not missing any due to the manifestly horrendous web page design. The ridiculous clip-art icons over the bullshitty captions "What you feel", "Your decision", "Words for posterity", "Future projections" aren't even links, they're just decorations, like lipstick on a pig. And the only actual link with any more information that I found was to their twitter feed, which was mostly in Japanese, but made some typically scammy claims in English like: https://twitter.com/PapyrusNFT https://twitter.com/PapyrusNFT >You can also use Papyrus to make your words NFTs, and then sell those NFTs on Opensea. >"I can't make art" "I'm not interested in art" so "I can't be an NFT creator.", Is that true? Why not write your thoughts on a blockchain and make it an NFT? >NFT can make any digital data unique, and NFT art is only a small part of it. Can anybody please explain exactly how NFT can make any digital data unique? What does that even mean? There's also a link to some shady little Japanese "Lifestyle Change" / "Blockchain Technology" / "Creative Solution" / "System Development" / "Ethereum staking agency business" company called Moblo. Who are they, anyway, and what is their actual focus, credentials, reputation, and qualification to be in this business? https://moblo.jp/company/ https://moblo.jp/company/ Those silly tweets, plus that shallow landing page of glossy hype devoid of meaningful content, not to mention that bizarrely unfocused and unqualified "Lifestyle Changing" Japanese company, all make it pretty obvious this is a scam that is targeting gullible suckers, and they have no idea what they're talking about. Your unsubstantiated claim that PapyrusNFT is making an also unsubstantiated claim that "they're enabling non-Ethereum chains which will address the environmental concerns" sounds about as believable as Trump's repeatedly broken promises to roll out his wonderful health care plan any day now, which he never did. So I'm simply asking you to prove what you claimed, and if you can't, then explain why you claimed it. Why are you making false excuses for these scammers by quoting words that aren't even on the web page, if you're not an NFT guy? What kind of guy are you then?
- meowface 5y agoIt's odd to me that people focus so much on Ethereum NFTs' environmental impact. It's certainly not good, but it's currently nowhere close to Bitcoin's consumption, and within 1 - 3 years will likely be reduced to the cost of running something like the Tor network: https://ethereum.org/static/6b5219d652112f88202e9768e27f5db1/77672/energy_use_per_transaction.png https://ethereum.org/static/6b5219d652112f88202e9768e27f5db1.... (Especially since there's no specific marginal energy cost to minting or trading an NFT, so it can't be compared to something like choosing whether or not to drive a combustion engine car.) To me the massive concern is all the financial fuckery. Anyone trying to shoehorn tokens (fungible, non-fungible, or semi-fungible) into something is almost always the reddest of flags. For one, the proposed "token-gating" makes no sense. What's to prevent someone from buying one token and then sharing the private key with a million people? You can try to create a sophisticated token-sharing detection system with invasive fingerprinting and tracking and proxy/VPN detection and such, but it's endless whack-a-mole and it's barely feasible for the world's top companies, on top of being the antithesis of what cryptocurrency people stand for. This is why consensus algorithms like proof of work exist in the first place: you can never ensure one identifier (a private key, an IP, whatever) = one person. They have to sacrifice something fungible and scarce. And "Your super-fans can collect NFTs of your published content." Just... what? Why? This strikes me as ridiculous and, frankly, cringe-inducing. It makes the whole thing feel gross.
- Ensorceled 5y ago> It's odd to me that people focus so much on Ethereum NFTs' environmental impact. It's certainly not good, but it's currently nowhere close to Bitcoin's consumption ... In a conversation about NFTs why is it odd to focus on NFT's environmental impact? Most people who hate NFTs also hate bitcoin, I assume they also hate racism, child labour, and COVID. Do you also find it odd that people don't mention their feelings about those issues when talking about NFTs?
- meowface 5y agoSorry, maybe I worded my comment poorly. I'm not trying to say "why are you talking about Ethereum and not Bitcoin instead?", or something like that. Here, it's a tiny bit like trying to link NFTs to racism because there's a certain subset of cryptocurrency enthusiasts who are Nazis. (And some do say this.) Not the best analogy, I know, but in this case Ethereum is commonly thought of as environmentally unfriendly basically due to guilt by association with Bitcoin. Ethereum does have an excessive environmental impact, because proof of work is fundamentally environmentally unfriendly. But the point is it isn't a very big impact right now and probably won't ever be an impact because before it can reach that point there'll probably be a shift to an algorithm that reduces the energy cost to that of any other ordinary software. And even if it did pose such an impact right now, NFTs pose no direct marginal energy cost (though they do so indirectly by encouraging more use of the network, which raises the incentive to mine). In my opinion, there are so many other good arguments against (most/nearly all) NFTs that when you pull this one out, it instantly causes the opposition to flag you as someone not worth listening to. Especially when it's couched in dramatic language, like that NFTs are "burning so much coal, causing cancer, and destroying the environment", as the previous commenter wrote.