2 ms·
Out of order: To your second point (people understand repetition): The difference is in the name, repetition is well-understood but spacing is the key distinct
by Jtsummers 5y ago
Out of order:
To your second point (people understand repetition): The difference is in the name, repetition is well-understood but spacing is the key distinction. Daily reviews of the entire deck? Useful, bordering on cramming, but no spacing. Weekly reviews? Still not spacing (in the SRS sense). Split a deck into new and easy cards, with easy reviewed less often? Pushing towards spacing, but probably still on a regular interval (to the extent any student can maintain a consistent study schedule).
Spaced repetition works by (as I said in another comment) roughly doubling the interval between studying the easy cards. Eventually you'll have delayed too long on some cards and forgotten them, they get restarted, if totally forgotten, or studied with a reduced interval if it was hard but not totally forgotten. The interest in optimality is, for me, uninteresting. When I used it by hand (with flashcards) I just wanted something better than studying a whole deck daily or forgetting large chunks of it by waiting too long. It worked, it wasn't "optimal" (Anki and others gets closer to that) but it was much better than previous efforts.
To your first point: I think I agree with you. The complaints about rote learning are grossly exaggerated in many cases. I know it happens, and often in early subjects like arithmetic (it's hard to get a 4- or 5-year-old student to understand 2 + 2, but you can certainly get them to correctly compute it). But it's not the typical treatment if your teachers are at least half-decent. Part of the issue is that rote learning has become a pejorative, equated with learning without understanding. The reality is that it's a tool. Drills reinforce the information so that you can recall and apply it later. SRS fits into this by being (at least for many, if not most cases) a more efficient approach. But even Dr. Wozniak doesn't encourage SRS en lieu of other approaches: http://super-memory.com/articles/20rules.htm http://super-memory.com/articles/20rules.htm. SRS is an alternative to heavier drills, but it's not a replacement on its own for developing understanding.