3 ms·
No, it was that the government accurately estimated ridership, then unrealistically lowered that estimate later. The government was incentivized to lower this e
by pessimizer 5y ago
No, it was that the government accurately estimated ridership, then unrealistically lowered that estimate later. The government was incentivized to lower this estimate because it lowered the amount of revenue that had to be guaranteed, and the builders were happy to use those estimates to cut costs and lower capacity. The case for privatization is partially built on avoiding state liability and accused inefficiency, and that very mindset motivated the lowered estimates that destined the entire project to failure.
So people got a incapable subway line when it could have been (and was) foreseen by everyone. The "solution" of raising prices to lower usage is not a good outcome for people whose taxes are guaranteeing revenue, and additionally, if raising prices didn't manage to lower ridership, it would be a reward.
In the end the government is liable for massive expenditures to fix or cover the problems of the "private" line. What was gained by privatization in this case, rather than just directly building the line, other than the guaranteed loss of any profit from it? It's another case of privatized profits and socialized losses.