2 ms·
Well, at some point people have to trust someone other than themselves to tell them how complicated things work because there is just too much complexity and la
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
Well, at some point people have to trust someone other than themselves to tell them how complicated things work because there is just too much complexity and layering of knowledge in our modern world for one person to be an expert in everything.
So, I have accepted this natural propaganda as you call it because it seemed to be said by lots of people who were experts, I mean it's not just like I heard it from Milton Friedman and went with that. It's a pretty wide range of people I've heard this from. If it is a propaganda campaign it is a wide ranging one with lots of people involved some of whom you would think would have had the clout to make different arguments but didn't. In the many times I've encountered the argument there tends to be statistics and graphs involved, sure, not in my specialty but at any rate things looked reasonable on the surface and so over the years I accepted an argument that did not necessarily follow common sense when first encountered.
Your argument against it sounds totally reasonable and sensible. But you do not bring any evidence to bear, just your argument. Admittedly the argument is based on logic, but sometimes the things that seem logically sound can be shown to not work because of some deeper underlying logic to it. Is this your own idea, or did you encounter it somewhere and think that sounds much more reasonable than the other stuff I've been told? If so can you give me a guide to where I can read about the idea myself. What leads you to call the opposing argument propaganda, is there any research you can point to about this?