3 ms·
Understanding and sympathising with this viewpoint, the issue is far more one of urban planning and transit than it is of structure height per se. San Francisc
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Understanding and sympathising with this viewpoint, the issue is far more one of urban planning and transit than it is of structure height per se.
San Francisco hasn't been known for its soaring towers (though recently the leaning sort are making headlines), but it is centralised and well-served by transit both within the city and from surrounding communities. To this extent, it resembles Chicago.
At the same time, the Bay Area as a whole strongly resembles Los Angeles, with various tech hubs ranging from San Jose to San Francisco, and including Sunnyvale, Fremont, Mountain View, Palo Alto, Menlo Park Redwood City, and Oakland. If you find yourself job hopping between these spots, commutes get long fast, and there's no one best place to live.
Chicago was built around rail with both the urban CTA and regional Metra rail service. Suburbs first emerged as points on spokes radiating out from downtown. Those have since filled in considerably, and inter-suburban commutes are both real and every much as horrible a mess as you'd imagine them to be.
Los Angeles grew up as an automobile city with boulevards and freeways, and looks it. Absent the constraints of terrain, what defines Los Angeles is a grid-pattern of both streets and freeways. Whilst Chicago does have a street grid, that grid does not define the city in the same way Los Angeles does.
If LA had instead opted to build distributed clusters of both high-rise (office/commercial) and low-rise (residential) towers, on a hub-and-spoke transit system, it might offer a far more reasonable set of commute and living options. There's no strict need for towers, so much as there is for connections between them.
Arguably, another element that defines much of Chicago is its greystone and bungalow residential styles. These don't reach the density of 5--6 story apartment construction typical of Europe, but are far denser than the predominantly single-story fully-separated housing of the Los Angeles area. As with elsewhere, density makes transit service, whether bus or rail, far more viable.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoLos Angeles grew up as an automobile city with boulevards and freeways, and looks it. LA is the way it is due to the history of how it was developed. It's a desert city and they had to develop large tracts at one time to finance the water infrastructure to bring water in from elsewhere. LA was spread out like it is before it became the poster child for the cult of the car. It was like that when it was served by trolleys and foot traffic. I don't know what the solution is going forward, but planning around cars is not how that got started in the case of LA.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWater absolutely shaped Los Angeles's development, and also explains why there are few similarly-scaled cities anywhere near it (San Diego being the principle exception). Los Angeles's watershed extends 1,500 miles eastward, to the front-range of the Rocky Mountains and the Colorado River. That said, Chicago formed as a transportation hub, first based on the Great Lakes and rivers (the Des Plaines connects to the Mississipi), providing a transit point between the middle of the US, from Minneapolis to New Orleans and via the Missouri and Ohio river systems about 2/3 of the continent, to the East Coast via the St. Lawrence Seaway and Erie Canal. Railroads were built to outlying suburbs by 1850, at which time there were no automobiles at all. Chicago's population as of 1900 exceeded 1 million. Remember that mass adoption of the automobile in the US only began in 1901 with Ford's Model T, and wasn't substantial for another two to three decades. Los Angeles by contrast had no natural harbour (the San Pedro breakwater was completed in 1910), was largely a ranching and orchard region through the early 20th century, and was by far secondary to San Francisco in importance to California until 1906, the year of the Great Earthquake and Fire. Following that event, with increased oil exploration in Los Angeles (there remain many operating wells within the city itself), and especially growth during WWII, Los Angeles eventually grew. But it had only 100,000 souls in 1900, surpassing 1 million in 1930, at which point automobile use was strongly established. The General Motors Streetcar Conspiracy put an end to what public transit remained from 1938--1950. Chicago's suburban commuter rail was spared by virtue of the fact that it uses freight rail rights-of-way, which couldn't be dismantled (though some lines did fold, especially after the Interstate Highway System was built). Chicago's El similarly survived though I'm not familiar with the specific history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Los_Angeles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Los_Angeles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp... Chicago 1906 map showing well-developed rail trasnportation network. https://www.davidrumsey.com/luna/servlet/workspace/handleMediaPlayer?qvq=&trs=&mi=&lunaMediaId=RUMSEY~8~1~34147~1170881 https://www.davidrumsey.com/luna/servlet/workspace/handleMed... By contrast, Los Angeles at about the same time, dominated by streets: https://slippyjenkins.com/four-ridiculously-hi-res-maps-of-los-angeles-in-the-early-1900s/ https://slippyjenkins.com/four-ridiculously-hi-res-maps-of-l...
- kuang_eleven 5y agoLos Angeles practically already is distributed clusters! That's what makes is unusual compared to most cities, that there is a Downtown LA, but it is merely one of many clusters of economic activity, each with their own downtown area. And they are reasonably well-connected, certainly by freeways (which are not grid-based), but increasingly so by mass transit; LA had a deservingly bad reputation for mass transit in the past, but it has made unimaginably large strides forward. On top of that, the bus system is vast and fills in the gaps where rail does not go.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've seen it said (Robert A. Heinline mentions this amongst others, I believe in Expanded Universe) that the LA basin was considered a sufficiently distributed population in the event of a nuclear war. How much such considerations weighed in to Cold War urban planning in the US I'm not sure.
- refurb 5y agoAs the prior reply mentions, much of LA was already established - at least as small towns - prior to 1930. I can’t see how nuclear war could have influenced it. What is unique about LA is the water rights. To get access, those small towns had to agree to get incorporated within greater LA.
- dredmorbius 5y agoRight. Point being that other developing new cities (particularly in the south/sunbelt, think, say, Phoenix, DFW, and Atlanta, which grew tremendously from the 1960s to the present (air conditioning had a huge effect). Or any attempts to make LA more centralised or rationalised in terms of transporation.
- Talanes 5y agoMy last experience with LA transit was finding a very convenient train to go over and hang out in Santa Monica for a day of that trip, and then having to spend way too much on an Uber back because the trains stopped surprisingly early.