I fail to see how this is not a perfect example of the above. Just because he supposedly did it "calmly"? How did he "eviscerate" it? Did he have an objective

I fail to see how this is not a perfect example of the above. Just because he supposedly did it "calmly"? How did he "eviscerate" it? Did he have an objective metric where it scored low despite promises? Did he show it kills babies? No. He just wrote a different one which in his opinion was better. The author is simply exaggerating for effect.