4 ms·
Part of the problem is how people learn what science is. Science, despite the name, is really all about doubt. Unfortunately in school it’s taught as certaint
by gumby 5y ago
Part of the problem is how people learn what science is. Science, despite the name, is really all about doubt. Unfortunately in school it’s taught as certainty.
In school you do “experiments” and if the answer doesn’t match what is in the book you are marked down. Often you have to memorize a bunch of assertions or even simply names, without any epistemic context.
Then in the real world you discover that scientists contradict each other or even themselves. They don’t say things straight out but are always hedging (“high probability”) or even admitting they don’t know!
- krapp 5y ago>In school you do “experiments” and if the answer doesn’t match what is in the book you are marked down. Often you have to memorize a bunch of assertions or even simply names, without any epistemic context. I don't know what school you went to, but this doesn't match my experience.
- MathMonkeyMan 5y agoThere's the desire to teach the scientific method, and also the desire to convey the established literature in preparation for the (standardized) exams. So, you design "labs" where the students "experiment." This is my experience at a high school in Florida.
- neutronicus 5y agoIt might behoove you to think of these as exercises in "measurement" rather than "experiment"
- gumby 5y agoThe point is that’s now how it is framed by the school. So people grow up thinking there’s an absolute, precise, and “correct” answer and anything else is “wrong”
- t0bia_s 5y agoAgree. Saying "I dont know" at school is persecuted. And here we are. Everybody have opinions on everything and it is hard to hear "I don't know." in public space. Imagine that politicans would say that they don't know anything. A lot of people think that they know everything, but only few really know something.
- iszomer 5y agoIt matches mine: A general chemistry lab where we were tasked to grow crystals and attempt to write formal reports of our scientific experiences. If experiences didn't match with current expected outcomes, we still recorded our observational data and tried hypothesizing on conditions of reason for divergent results.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoIt seems to depend very much on when and where you went to school. I did Nuffield chemistry for A-Level, '72-'74. It was very much about learning experimental methods and how to analyse the results. Physics was similar with great emphasis on analysis. But in conversations with others at university afterward (Exeter uni, Physics) I discovered that many of my fellow students had endured exactly the situation that your quote mentions.
- SantalBlush 5y ago>Science, despite the name, is really all about doubt. This is a popular misconception on HN, and it's why so many here think they're being scientific by dismissing every journal article on the front page. Doubt plays a crucial role in science, but it's not what science is "really all about." You can doubt every single data point and sensory impression. There is no empirical way to "prove" a single thing if one is determined to doubt it. Not one.
- headsoup 5y agoThat is the default position in science. An encouragement to never be absolutely certain, because you never know what may turn out to be 'wrong.' Doubt is the wrong word, but 'question everything' is I think a perfect statement for science.
- tpoacher 5y agoI doubt it.
- gumby 5y agoFair enough. Perhaps I should have said “uncertainty”, but I judged it scientific jargon with respect to the people I was talking about.
- mannschott 5y ago> In school you do “experiments” and if the answer doesn’t match what is in the book you are marked down. This is unsurprising and probably obvious. The purpose of the exercise is learning how to do experiments reliably so that at some later point when doing experiments to test a hypothesis you can have some confidence that the results you produce are actual data and not just noise. When doing science class "experiments" of this sort perhaps it would illuminate things to students better by going up one level: the hypothesis under test is "student can perform experiment reliably". The putative subject of the "experiment" isn't the actual subject in inquiry: you are. On the other hand maybe this would just confuse students. (I've observed wildly varying capacity for abstraction and meta-cognition among the people I work with as a software developer so I suppose this is something that varies among individuals generally.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]