2 ms·
Interestingly, the Anglo-Saxon fyrd and huscarls, a mounted infantry but infantry nonetheless, were crushed at Hastings (1066) by proper Norman cavalry, even th
by inglor_cz 5y ago
Interestingly, the Anglo-Saxon fyrd and huscarls, a mounted infantry but infantry nonetheless, were crushed at Hastings (1066) by proper Norman cavalry, even though the same troops under the same commander Harold Godwinson had won a very significant battle (Stamford Bridge) against the (unhorsed) Vikings just a few weeks before that.
They put up a great fight and the initial Norman attempts were unsuccessful, but at the end, the cavalry prevailed.
- appleflaxen 5y agoWhat's the difference between mounted infantry and cavalry? I thought the mounting of soldiers on horses made it a cavalry automatically...
- trzy 5y agoMounted infantry did not fight on horseback but rather traveled by horse and dismounted to fight on foot. They had access to horses but did not develop coordinated horse-mounted combat tactics or armament. Edit: Wikipedia has a good overview if you Google the term. My guess is that proper horse mounted combat requires far more intensive and consistent training that could typically only be undertaken by a noble or knightly class with no other real responsibilities. Whereas anyone with access to a horse could fulfill their (rarely exercised) martial duties as infantry.
- greiskul 5y agoI think it might depend on the period, but mounted infantry uses horses for travel but fights on foot, while cavalry fights mounted.
- QuercusMax 5y agoIn modern terms, mounted infantry typically are in Humvee-type vehicles, whereas cavalry are in things more like tanks.
- ThrustVectoring 5y agoIMO the attack helicopter is a better modern equivalent to cavalry than the tank. Hard to make a direct comparison since increased firepower and command-and-control have made military forces incredibly dispersed.
- inglor_cz 5y agoBasically the same as between parachutists and pilots. They both use a plane to get to the battlefield, but only one of those stays in.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoI've often wondered how much the journey to Hastings in such a rapid fashion wore out Godwinson's troops prior to that battle.
- inglor_cz 5y agoOh, it definitely did, but worse problem was the undisciplined fyrd that was fresher but fell for the Normans' feint. (They pretended to be retreating and the fyrd broke their ranks in pursuit.)
- gumby 5y agoWe’re they indeed crushed? I thought the Anglo-Saxons had the upper hand until Harold caught an arrow in his eye, which may have distracted and disheartened his soldiers. I’m also not sure there were many horses involved, though tbh it’s been a couple of decades since I cared about this battle and my memory may be poor. Harold Godwinson was an extraordinary commander. To permanently throw the Vikings out of Britain and then march and almost repel the Normans (though basically also Vikings) shows terrific determination. And he chose his territory well: he had the upland position boxed in at the sides and with the Normans having only the sea at their back — he should have won. His troops were incredibly tough guys. Had he carried the day I think he would have been a good leader. His case was stronger than subsequent propaganda has portrayed.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI admire Harold as well. Too bad that his brothers insisted on taking part in the battle and fell too. Either of them could have become a new king of England, continuing the hostilities against the Normans. IIRC the Norman cavalry played a decisive role in routing the fyrd at least, but it has been some years since I looked into that as well, so my memory may be faulty. Harold might or might not have caught an arrow in his eye. There is a great deal of symbolism in that narrative, because an arrow in an eye would be a divine punishment for oathbreakers, and William insisted that Harold previously took an oath on holy relics to be his liege. So it is not impossible that the detail about the arrow in eye is a latter embellishment to make the story more righteous from the Norman side.
- gumby 5y agoYears ago the alarm code at my office was set to 1066 and for some reason I needed to tell my then 10 yo the code. He immediately said “arrow to the eye”! So for his sake at least I hope the story is true.