But you've not answered my question. What portion of all work in the economy do you think is motivated by the lowest needs on the ladder, the ones that we are e

But you've not answered my question. What portion of all work in the economy do you think is motivated by the lowest needs on the ladder, the ones that we are endeavouring to provide with a UBI? How do you think that work is distributed across industries? > very few kids say they want to stay at home and sit on the couch all day You will notice however that, in absence of intervention, most kids do sit on the couch all day, especially in the digital age. We also observe that this behavior continues as long as it is materially supported. Countless articles have been written about the increasing numbers of seemingly-functional adults who live under the care of their parents and don't do very much at all. UBI will enable more people to adopt this lifestyle, to become starving (read: non-productive) artists, man-children or hikikomori. Why don't you think they'll take the opportunity? > people would only have boolean motivation I agree that it's not a binary motivation. In aggregate however the point stands, removing x% of motivation for work will inevitably result in x% less work being done. Furthermore, any decrease in x represents wealth transfer from those who are motivated to work by higher values to those who are motivated to work by lower ones (in Maslow's hierarchy). All of this raises many moral questions, and I think these are fundamentally worth discussing. Note: I do appreciate your continued replies =)