3 ms·
I don't think there's any supposition of this sort in my comment: I haven't committed to any particular opinion on how we would (or whether it's politically fea
by woodruffw 5y ago
I don't think there's any supposition of this sort in my comment: I haven't committed to any particular opinion on how we would (or whether it's politically feasible to) distribute the agricultural products that normally go into animal feed. Contemporary economic pressures, as you've correctly noted, don't help!
All I've observed is that the GP's conclusion doesn't necessarily extend from the data they've presented: it's just not the case that 3.5 billion humans would have to die if we didn't use as much synthetic fertilizer as we do. We can feed the entire world with much less indirection than we currently go through.
- noduerme 5y agoFair enough, but we could only do that if there were some master plan to reallocate the land used for animal feed, the processing, the innumerable distribution systems that get food to people. Saying this is like saying there's enough energy from the sun, wind and hydro to let us go off fossil fuels. It would be true if you could wave a wand and redesign the whole system from scratch. But that observation doesn't make it any less of a crisis if the system as-is begins to break down. The trouble with a lot of these idealistic proclamations that "we have the ability ...if" is that they don't take into account the messy realities, and so the only purpose they serve is virtue-signaling. Tl;dr the only useful solutions in this will involve ways to produce or more efficiently distribute more fertilizer, not to say that we could or should get along without it.