4 ms·
That vastly underestimates the size of the modern problem. I posted previously of the adage "Modern agriculture is about turning energy in fossil fuels into foo
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
That vastly underestimates the size of the modern problem. I posted previously of the adage "Modern agriculture is about turning energy in fossil fuels into food we can eat." While not entirely accurate (yes, most of the energy in plants comes from the sun, but it is fossil fuels that power most of the nitrogen fixation needed to unlock that photosynthesis), it does emphasize how so much of modern agriculture is dependent on extractive mining.
Saying "modern agriculture can switch to just planting legumes for nitrogen fixation" is like saying "modern transportation can switch to just using solar power." Of course, modern transportation can switch to using solar power, but most people understand how it will be a gargantuan, multi-decade, multi-trillion dollar process. Switching modern agriculture off its dependence on fossil fuels will be in the same order-of-magnitude difficulty level.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThey only use fossil fuels to make the hydrogen. Which can be made more efficiently with electricity. So it's not really a problem. We only do it now because the costs are hidden. The transition is almost entirely political in nature, since not using fossil fuels for this is the better option, and it's already started.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> They only use fossil fuels to make the hydrogen. Which can be made more efficiently with electricity. Are we really in disagreement then? Where pray tell do you think electricity comes from? In the US, 60% comes from fossil fuels, about 20% from nuclear. Solar, wind, biomass and geothermal combined is < 12% My point is that most folks understand that moving our electric infrastructure to renewables is an enormous, long term, extremely expensive undertaking. Whether the hydrogen used in nitrogen fixation comes from natural gas directly, or from electrolysis, it's at its core an energy problem, and transitioning our energy use needed for nitrogen fixation on a global scale is a lot more expensive/complicated than planting some alfalfa.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoWell, similar to the "EVs just burn coal" thing, it seems likely that burning the gas to make electricity and then using that electricity to make hydrogen would be more efficient, so doing it that way would reduce demand, save money, and just generally be better than what we do now. And then you've a) freed up lots of a storable fuel that you can use to supplement renewables if you really need it (and can be kept and used as a chemical feedstock otherwise), b) created a whole new market for responsively using all the cheap new renewables that we need to build. So, yeah, I think we still disagree. Fossil fuels are not particularly necessary, useful or cheap, not for transport and not for fertilizer. They have some uses, but they generally get given way more credit than they deserve for political reasons. Generally the faster we replace them, the better off we will all be in many ways. It's "expensive" to do this in the same way that moving to socialized health is "expensive", it'll costs billions, but it'll also save billions, because the alternative costs even more.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> it seems likely that burning the gas to make electricity and then using that electricity to make hydrogen would be more efficient I'm not sure why one would think that, the exact opposite is true. Going to electrolysis is only desirable if the energy source is a renewable. This article has a very good overview of the challenges with moving ammonia production to sustainable energy sources: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2021.580808/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2021.5808...
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago"challenges" and yet it reports the results of multiple studies saying our current options for green hydrogen are better than what we do now with fossil fuels, on multiple metrics and overall. And like the "EVs burn coal" analogy, I'm suggesting we shift to renewables as quickly as we can, and there's no need to wait for the grid to be 100% renewable before electrifying as much as we can. The union of concerned scientists has a map that compares the efficiency of an EV to ICE. It's lower in fossil fuel powered areas, but It's better than ICE everywhere today, even if you ignore the future greening of the grid. If you include that it completely demolishes the alternative. So your document appears to support my point, why do you think it doesn't?
- smallerfish 5y ago> most of the energy in plants comes from the sun, but it is fossil fuels that power most of the nitrogen fixation needed to unlock that photosynthesis Just to build on this, we expend (at least) 7.3 calories of energy to produce 1 calorie of food (https://sustainability.emory.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/InfoSheet-Energy26FoodProduction.pdf https://sustainability.emory.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/...).