2 ms·
These kinds of ostensibly progressive arguments come very close to crossing the line into fascist eugenics, even if they're made with the greenest of intentions
by noduerme 5y ago
These kinds of ostensibly progressive arguments come very close to crossing the line into fascist eugenics, even if they're made with the greenest of intentions.
Malthusian fears and Luddite patterns are not designed to improve the lot of humanity, only those who can afford luxuries. Deep down, they're rooted in the notion that the world would be better off without undesirable surplus humans.
More sustainable methods do exist to grow crops, and much of what the rich West eats are sustainably grown "organic" vegetables and free range meat. But the bulk of humanity lives on industrial-scale agriculture. Industrial ag is actually why there are so many people. Removing it is unnecessarily cruel. The way it shakes out when there are food shortages is not that suddenly the rich stop eating free-range chicken. It's that the poor starve. You can't expect that inequality to change just by restricting food production across the board. If a Big Mac doubles in price in America, it's still well within the reach of most Americans. If my grass-fed rib eye triples in price, I might go down from 2 to 1 a week. But if grain prices go up by 30% in Africa, there's civil war and starvation. The imbalance actually becomes more extreme as access to protein is always curtailed first in the poorest areas. The assumption that demand for animal protein would go down faster in rich nations, given a price spike in grain, is wishful thinking to say the least.
There is no real solution to the ecological damage done by industrial agriculture unless you want to kill off a lot of the people who were born and live as a direct result of industrial food production.