3 ms·
The way the regulatory environment works in the US is something like this. Something bad happens, so new regulations are imposed. The regulators don't always k
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
The way the regulatory environment works in the US is something like this.
Something bad happens, so new regulations are imposed. The regulators don't always know what they're doing and frequently make poor cost benefit decisions. Meanwhile, the existing regulations usually already prohibited whatever the offender did, and the bad thing happened because they were breaking existing law, so they also get sued or prosecuted etc. under existing law anyway.
Despite this being completely nuts, it kind of works to deter pollution. The new regulations are like extra punishment for screwing up. The company, and the entire industry, has to pay more in regulatory compliance forever because they did a bad thing. So they really don't want to do that.
The problem is that the effect is cumulative and doesn't just impact the offender. Every time someone breaks the law in a high profile way, the compliance costs go up. They never go down. The new laws are useless because the bad thing has been prohibited for decades and the actual cause was companies violating existing laws. So the more time passes, the more regulations we get and the less competitive the US becomes.
Somebody who knows what they're doing needs to go through the existing regulations and strip out the ones that are wasteful and redundant while leaving the ones that efficiently prohibit bad acts.
But the political process is terrible at handling details like that. If someone proposes getting rid of an environmental regulation, it doesn't matter what it says. You can predict who will support it and who will oppose it. And it's the same people in support and opposition whether it's an actually necessary regulation with a moderate burden and a very large important reason for existing, or a useless web of red tape which is fully redundant with existing prohibitions but makes everything cost more for no benefit.