4 ms·
> No, the figures flanking Roosevelt are not meant to represent his guides on an Amazon expedition. What is your basis for saying this? q1w2 gave their basis
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> No, the figures flanking Roosevelt are not meant to represent his guides on an Amazon expedition.
What is your basis for saying this? q1w2 gave their basis for saying that it was about the Amazon expedition; what is your basis for saying that it isn't? Just "no it's not" doesn't work well as a refutation of an argument that had more than that.
- tptacek 5y agoI cited downthread what the figures were intended to mean, along with a source. The Amazon expedition thing seems like a weird just-so story. The real answer doesn't seem as lurid as some of the statue's critics want it to be, but it's still a problematic way to honor Roosevelt. Later Someone even replied to that comment with a cite directly from Fraser. I don't think this is so much in contention. The figures are not Roosevelt's helpers on the Amazon expedition.
- kcplate 5y agoSo do you feel the sculptor was lying when he said who/what those figures represent? That seems to be a bit of an assumption without much evidence. Perhaps you (and others) just disagree with the artist’s interpretation or find meaning where the artist intended something different. That happens a lot in works of art. I guess my perspective is that if the actual guide’s names and likeness that Roosevelt used were lost to history but as a sculptor but you still wanted to honor them…why wouldn’t you generically represent the cultures and races of those that helped him if they were important to the expeditions? That somehow seems less offensive to me than representing them as culturally generic…or not at all.
- tptacek 5y agoI take the sculptor at their word that the figures represent the American frontier and the continent of Africa.