6 ms·
The point is to authenticate residency, and while it’s not a great system, there also isn’t any better alternatives.
by kube-system 5y ago
The point is to authenticate residency, and while it’s not a great system, there also isn’t any better alternatives.
- ginko 5y ago>there also isn’t any better alternatives. Of course there is. It's having a central resident registry like is common in most countries other than the US.
- kube-system 5y agoThat is not an alternative for the DMV. There is no central registry and they can't create one.
- JadeNB 5y ago> The point is to authenticate residency, and while it’s not a great system, there also isn’t any better alternatives. "No-one important enough is bothered, so we haven't had to try to fix it" is a far cry from "there [aren't] any better alternatives". We're HN; that's not the hacker ethos.
- kube-system 5y agoRealID requirements were written in the past and exist in the present. While it would be great to have another solution, one doesn’t exist. Happy to hear a proposal, however. I, personally, haven’t been able to come up with a more equitable idea.
- yason 5y agoWhen you move to a new state, I suppose you don't fill in a bunch of forms to register yourself as a resident in the state then? So that when DMV and other institutions ask for residency they could just check back in the states records (or have you bring a copy of the state's residency certificate) ? The state surely must know how to tax you, and thus they need to know who you are and that you're a resident in the state... It seems the information inevitably must be there already so why try to imitate that with a bunch of random tokens such as bills sent to an address where they could go straight to the source? Just curious.
- cdcarter 5y agoIn the US, no, you don't need to fill out any forms to register yourself as a resident. The closest is probably moving your drivers license registration, which many people wait years to do after moving. Other than that, you generally prove residency by showing (as GP mentioned) bills mailed to you, or a copy of your lease. You're responsible for filing your own state taxes based on when/how/where you worked.
- kube-system 5y ago> The closest is probably moving your drivers license registration, which many people wait years to do after moving. Most states do require by law that you do this in a very short period of time after moving. (Although yes, it is not uncommon for people to violate this)
- SamBam 5y agoOnly if you have a driving license and plan on driving. I agree, it's quite odd that you never officially register as a resident of the state, but I guess it's part of the US's aversion to "papers please."
- loeg 5y agoOr voting. You typically register with the secretary of state to vote.
- kube-system 5y agoIt’s also that there are different standards of requirements across the thousands of different government entities that care about residency. And there’s not much chance they’d agree. My municipal tax authority and the US State department may have very different standards for validating “residency” and very different reasons for doing so.
- monocasa 5y agoThere's also the state v. federal political issue of the interstate commerce clause. Some municipalities in the pretty far past have tried to restrict people moving there by creating onerous registration barriers that were then struck down by the feds. They're allowed some leeway there, but there's a limit that they don't want to push and the feds are more than happy to enforce their power. My state (CO) semi recently hit a morph of this concern because they had "pioneer" license plates that cost an extra $100 or so and were only available to people who could prove N generations of ancestry in CO. The feds struck that down as .gov services provided being dependent on state origin and therefore against the interstate commerce clause.
- Nextgrid 5y agoBut given how easy it is to foil, I don't understand what it "authenticates". If you wanted to truly authenticate residency or at the very least prove that someone has access to the mailbox, sending them a one-time auth code per mail would be a better idea rather than relying on third-party services where people may use paperless billing for convenience.
- kube-system 5y agoI explicitly said it was not good authentication. :) Mailing someone a code would be more secure but, to the parents point, would be even more onerous of a process for people to comply with. Some comments above suggested above that this is an intentionally burdensome process, but to the contrary, bringing in a bill is one of the least burdensome ways to authenticate residency.
- Nextgrid 5y ago> bringing in a bill is one of the least burdensome ways to authenticate residency My problem with this is how is the recipient supposed to authenticate said bill. Now we're talking about bringing a paper bill vs a printed one (or "faking" a paper bill by creasing/folding the printed one), but the real threat is fraudsters completely making up a fake bill to begin with. Unless the recipient has a relationship with the company that issues the bills, there is no way for them to verify whether the bill is real in the first place, making the whole endeavor pointless and only inconveniencing legitimate users.
- kube-system 5y agoYes. There’s no question that a bill is a weak piece of evidence for residency. I am sure it only prevents low-effort or low-skill fraudsters, or casual fibs. The latter is probably where they get the most utility out of these requirements.
- TameAntelope 5y agoWhy do you need to authenticate it in the first place? If people are discovered lying somehow, send them to jail. Otherwise, trust that people will be honest. Fraud is not nearly the problem people think it is...
- devwastaken 5y agoIf all this was for is to ensure you live at an address then the local government can offer a number of solutions to that. If they want mail, they can simply mail you a unique qr code which you could then scan and complete the process entirely online. Or at a minimum bring physically to an office. A utility bill doesn't require proof of residency to get. Neither does a credit card statement. Infact if I were creative I could say I live anywhere and provide false documents of that. It is the legitimate use of this system that is difficult, not illigitimate use. The system is not designed to be secure or to ensure residency, that's not it's purpose. Its purpose is to create further government control to suppress citizens rights to operate freeley in their own country. Specifically, to target low income individuals. These people creating the policies are not the same people whom are affected by them. If I am U.S. born I have a right to operate in certain capacities as a citizen. Voting, owning land, and working are all rights unalienable. The fact this is not currently true is proof of the federal fascism we live in.
- jbaber 5y agoI agree with everything you're saying, but disagree with the reason. The US federal government has to be too loose about keeping track of citizens specifically to avoid looking too fascist. One of your many American rights is to have no ID at all. Protecting that right for two dozen people makes everything extremely complicated for the rest of us.
- devwastaken 5y agoThe federal government is not too loose in tracking citizens, and you cannot effectively operate in the U.S. without I.D of some form. Birth certificates and tax ID's are necessary for everything from school to work. Infact those that forgo it originally struggle as adults heavily to get those documents later, if at all.
- Jolter 5y agoIt’s probably true that you can’t operate properly without an ID, and yet the US government is specifically avoiding the one necessary prerequisite to having reliable and convenient IDs: a complete list of its citizens, with place of residence and a mandatory assigned unique identifier. It fuck people coming and going. You can’t get an ID if you don’t have a place of residence, and yet you can’t just go about your business without an ID.
- queuebert 5y agoThey could pay Google and Apple to tell them where you sleep, based on your phone GPS anyway.
- yhd8i3q7686i 5y agoRequiring people to print out a paper and fold it as if it had been in an envelope doesn't authenticate anything but access to a printer and some imagination. Just removing the requirement would be a better alternative.
- kube-system 5y agoI am referring to the requirement to produce a utility bill. Not the silly front-line bureaucratic interpretative variations thereof.
- sneak 5y agoThat's false. Many other countries have implemented simpler, more accurate, and less discriminatory systems.