4 ms·
It is. Free markets do not preclude social safety nets, or things like universal basic income.
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
It is. Free markets do not preclude social safety nets, or things like universal basic income.
- sudosysgen 5y agoIt's all a question of degree. A market with fewer taxes and less redistribution is freer.
- AlexandrB 5y agoThis is only true if you're looking at the capital market. If you consider the labor market, I would argue it's freer if employees have more freedom to change jobs (i.e. there is some redistribution and social safety net). Edit: Also, a market with redistribution is more democratic. More actors have money to provide market input (demand or investment) when resources are not highly concentrated.
- sudosysgen 5y agoFree market doesn't mean that actors can do whatever they want. It means that the market has the power to allocate resources. In the labor market, the labor market allocated that employee to a job, and allocated a penalty to changing jobs, that the government in then changing. Also, even in the labor market, the scenario you're describing is punishing the labor buyer but rewarding the labor provider, so it's not just the capital market that's less free, it's the labor market too. More actors being able to provide input is restricting the markets. The market allocated who gets to provide input in itself. All I'm saying is, don't fetishize the market being free.
- dlp211 5y agoFree markets are not about just the power to allocate, but also transparent knowledge in a decision. The labor purchaser almost always has an advantage over the labor provider in their transaction and don't actually represent a free market. Even in the tech industry this is true. People were shocked the other day when they found out that their income data was being reported and sold by the big credit companies in America. Google, Microsoft, Amazon, they all share their employees income data with one another through 3rd parties. They have so much more knowledge than you or I and it represents a huge advantage for them when hiring.
- sudosysgen 5y agoFree markets are supposed to transmit information as prices. Access to information has nothing to do with a market being free or not, and the fact that participants with an information advantage have an advantage is a big part of why people think markets should be free.
- DarylZero 5y agoInformation about prices is what they were talking about.
- mcv 5y agoIn fact, if you want the labour market to be a free market, universal basic income will help; then you've got a market where people can always say no to a deal they don't like. When the choice becomes: take the shitty deal or starve, it's not really a free market anymore.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoWhat stops sellers from raising prices to the point that any meaningful gain in UBI is effectively zero?
- brimble 5y agoIf they could do that, why haven't they already?
- claudiulodro 5y agoWhy don't landlords currently figure out a tenant's salary and charge exactly that amount in rent? Competition will still exist in a UBI society.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoIn any transaction, there is no distinction between money obtained as UBI and money earned as salary. A landlord is will set his price to what he can obtain from the highest bidder regardless of source. UBI does not generate competition. It's a supplement. All it does is translate the supply curve rightwards. While UBI might stimulate demand in the short term, it doesn't fundamentally change the relationship. The eventual outcome of sustained UBI is an inflationary spiral.
- mcv 5y agoTo be truly effective, UBI needs to be directly linked to the basic costs of living, like food and rent. If those go up, so should UBI. Or as long as there is no UBI, minimum wage should follow those costs.
- 5y ago