4 ms·
> Windows will happily run GUI apps written 20 years ago. Don't think this is true anymore. Old software on Windows just isn't guaranteed to work anymore. Last
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> Windows will happily run GUI apps written 20 years ago.
Don't think this is true anymore. Old software on Windows just isn't guaranteed to work anymore. Last time I tried to play an old game on newer Windows versions, it didn't even start up despite automatic and manual installation of a ton of dependencies. I suppose the Raymond Chen stories about heroic bug fixing in third party code is a thing of the past.
- badsectoracula 5y agoYou need workarounds but you can make it work. Though you can say the same thing for Linux too, it is just that Windows coming out of the box with a much richer API (e.g. for GUI functionality) makes things easier.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoGames are an especially difficult case as they have a habit of bypassing higher level APIs and abusing undocumented behavior for performance reasons. Still, a shockingly high number of games from 20+ years ago work out of the box on the latest Windows despite things like the shift from 32 bit to 64, all without recompilation. Linux Desktop's compatibility story is laughable by comparison unless you count WINE, which works so well in part because Windows APIs are so stable.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoMicrosoft also used to have a history of maintaining bug compatibility with applications, including use of undocumented data structures and functions. I've read the stories: once they tried to change some data structure only to revert the change when some proprietary software broke because it did insane things like put data into unused bits of some internal data structure. At some point all this must have been lost because I don't see Microsoft going out of its way to fix memory allocation bugs in games for our benefit anymore. I did try playing the game on Wine and it worked, ironically. Wouldn't be surprised if it eventually became the best way to run older Windows software. The ABI compatibility situation of Linux user space sucks. Apparently the kernel itself can run binaries from the 90s with no problem. The more dependencies you have, the worse the situation gets because in the free software world people seem to make it a point to avoid caring about binary compatibility since everyone is supposed to have the source code to everything in order to recompile software as needed. Because of this I've personally resolved to eliminate all dependencies in my own code by using Linux system calls directly.
- ModernMech 5y agoI can't find it now, but I remember there was a video of someone upgrading windows from like Windows 3 all the way to the latest Windows... maybe it was 7? I forget how long ago this was. But each time they upgraded Windows, they showed that the programs installed in the original OS still worked. I think they did it with Doom installed in 3, and showed that it still worked after 20 years of upgrades. That's some impressive backwards compatibility. Does anyone know the video I'm thinking of? I'd love to watch it again.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI remember there were several games in my Steam library that didn't survive any upgrades past 7.
- int_19h 5y agoThere's many such videos on YouTube these days, but I believe the most famous one is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WP7AkJo3OE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WP7AkJo3OE