4 ms·
For what it's worth, the usual "high school jobs" are not a problem when done by actual high schoolers as side gig to fund phone, beer, weed and gas. They don't
by mschuster91 5y ago
For what it's worth, the usual "high school jobs" are not a problem when done by actual high schoolers as side gig to fund phone, beer, weed and gas. They don't need to pay rent, food or health insurance so what would be a non-living wage for an adult is luxury money for high schoolers.
The problem is when actual adults who have to take care of adult things (rent, food, health insurance, car payments, ...) have to resort to entry-level jobs as a result of economy crunches or various forms of discrimination. For a long time employers took advantage of such employees and ran them to the ground... but now that retirees follow the "societal contract" and actually go and retire instead of blocking places for the young to rise, employers are in a bad crunch.
- MattRix 5y agoThat is true for some high schoolers but many others are making meaningful contributions to their family’s income and/or saving for college. There’s really no excuse to not pay them a living wage as well.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> The problem is when actual adults who have to take care of adult things (rent, food, health insurance, car payments, ...) have to resort to entry-level jobs as a result of economy crunches or various forms of discrimination. No, the problem is labor supply and demand curves have shifted, hence prices have shifted. People do not make business plans and budgets based on the number of high schoolers are available to hire. They make budgets based on the price at which they expect to be able to purchase labor. In this business’s case, they seem to have made some erroneous assumptions, which is the cause of the problem.
- ajmurmann 5y agoAnd when you ask for a pay increase because cost of living has gone up or complain that someone in another town that's similarly expensive earns more than you for the same role at the same company, you'll quickly hear that comp is based on cost of labor and not cost of living.
- acdha 5y agoI knew multiple classmates who were working substantial hours because their families needed the extra income, and that was when wages were better than they are now. Anything close to real work should pay real wages because otherwise you’re screwing the most desperate at the expense of the more affluent kids who can afford to walk away.
- vorpalhex 5y ago> Anything close to real work should pay real wages because otherwise you’re screwing the most desperate at the expense of the more affluent kids who can afford to walk away. That isn't how wages work. If someone can do the same job for less, they will and you will not get paid. You can raise the minimum but then you make everything more expensive (the people who build the tractors get more, the guy driving the tractor gets more, the person picking the lettuce gets paid more, the lady trimming and repackaging the lettuce gets more, the truck driver delivering the lettuce gets more, the high schooler throwing the lettuce on your burger gets more...) That "make everything more expensive" is inflation. Inflation hurts the poor the most. The lady making $400k/year doesn't care if ground beef is 10% more expensive.
- acdha 5y ago> That isn't how wages work. If someone can do the same job for less, they will and you will not get paid. Sure, but recognizing that is what happens is important for both not patronizing businesses which give their workers the worst deal allowed by law and support for increasing minimum wages to match inflation. > You can raise the minimum but then you make everything more expensive (the people who build the tractors get more, the guy driving the tractor gets more, the person picking the lettuce gets paid more, the lady trimming and repackaging the lettuce gets more, the truck driver delivering the lettuce gets more, the high schooler throwing the lettuce on your burger gets more...) You're leaving out a key part: prices only go up for the fraction of those costs which are due to wages. For things like fast food, that's not a large component which is why, for example, a McDonald's worker in Denmark has a much better quality of life while the average Big Mac buyer is paying the same or less than their American counterpart: https://www.economist.com/big-mac-index https://www.economist.com/big-mac-index Another big factor to consider is the cost of poverty. The working poor have less ability to participate in the economy so a certain amount of local economic growth never happens, and they're often worse off because they're forced to do things like buy inefficiently because they don't have the reserves to optimize. Paying people at the level minimum wage used to mean would allow a significant number of people to participate in the economy more effectively and we've never regretted growing the pie.
- dls2016 5y agoWhat are you talking about? Have you ever been to a restaurant during the day or counted the employees over-50 at Walmart? There always have been adults working these jobs.
- soco 5y agoI'm not sure how being served in a restaurant (restaurant, not fast food joint) by a high schooler can make an experience I'd wish to repeat. Or having my chateaubriand cooked by one.
- watwut 5y ago> retirees follow the "societal contract" and actually go and retire instead of blocking places for the young to rise, Hard no here. If retirees feel strong enough to work, they are 100% entitled to improve their incomes. Especially when they don't have super generous pensions. Retiree struggling to pay pills and doctors is not something super exceptional. There is no social contract for them to stop working.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Hard no here. If retirees feel strong enough to work, they are 100% entitled to improve their incomes. Assuming a finite number of places of employment in an economy, when old people cannot ever reasonably retire because multiple governments have either outright stolen from the pension funds or otherwise fucked up the pension system, there is an imbalance: young people are forced to be either unemployed or massively under-employed (i.e. stuck in low-paid, entry level positions), instead of being able to rise through the ranks based on the work they put in.
- ajmurmann 5y agoAlso echoes a scarcity mindset whereas more market participants usually increase the pie.