8 ms·
>This sort of began when we all got the impression that software should be free, or that we pay a low price once and get indefinite free upgrades. Blame the vi
by coldtea 5y ago
>This sort of began when we all got the impression that software should be free, or that we pay a low price once and get indefinite free upgrades.
Blame the victim?
We din't get any impression, as we don't set the prices. The companies set those prices.
For example Adobe customers never got or set any impression that "software should be free/low price". They paid 100s to 1000s of dollars for each update or package respectively, and they still got the mandatory subscription (and were some of the first users to be hit with one).
>How do you achieve super cheap products made by people making super high pay? Money doesn’t just materialize out of thin air to make that work.
We don't want "super cheap products", we want reasonably priced products we own after we buy.
- Hnrobert42 5y agoThis is not blaming the victim as there are no victims. OP’s is wrong that SaaS is rent sending. Software should not be free (in cost), yet always receive new features and updates. Indeed, the alternative is the ad-tech surveillance state.
- coldtea 5y agoThat's a strawman. Who exactly demanded "free in cost" plus "always receive new features and updates"? If the software companies (in mobile in particular) had a race to the bottom, it's on them - and on those (hobbyists etc) that undercutted them (though, if hobbyists can undercut your prices, is your product really worth that much, or could it just as well be replaced with a hobbyist-made app?). Users have since forever paid top dollar for shrink wrapped and then downloaded software like MS Office or Abobe Creative Suite and co, that now is nonetheless "subscription based".
- Hnrobert42 5y agoWell if this isn’t the pot calling the kettle black. You raise the statesman that I said people claim software should be both free and maintained indefinitely. I did no such thing. I merely asserted that it should not be.
- cinntaile 5y agoIsn't a big reason for this development precisely that many didn't pay top dollar? There used to be a lot of Photoshop, Windows and Office warez floating around.
- Zak 5y agoI suspect most of the piracy in those apps was among people who were never the target market. Someone who wants to make funny cat pictures, or even edit photos they took with their $300 point-and-shoot camera isn't going to pay $400 for Photoshop. Professionals who make their living using Photoshop usually don't have much trouble with the cost, whether paid monthly, or occasionally when a new version has a feature they care about. Being able to bring in some more casual customers with a lower initial cost is just a bonus.
- coldtea 5y agoNo, since that's orthogonal. You can pirate with or without a subscription.
- rglullis 5y agoOne could argue that MS Office and Adobe products were always "subscription-based", if companies and professionals never left the update treadmill. After all, if all you need is MS-Office 2000 or Adobe Photoshop 6, no subscription is needed and you can still find licenses around.
- coldtea 5y agoOne could argue it. But they would then have to answer why would non-business buyers, that is, users who did "leave the update treadmill" and bought new updates (or skipped them) at their convenience, suffer the subscription model too?
- rglullis 5y agoBecause they are such an irrelevant part of the market that they basically could disappear and no one would care, and the hobbyist/non-professional people who don't mind using years-old software could as well just use Free/Open alternatives? There is nothing stopping Joe-who-only-pays-full-licences to continue using his MS 2007 Office suite, is there?
- skydhash 5y agoOs support, especially in the Apple world.
- rglullis 5y agoRight, which is yet another explanation of why companies moved into subscription-based models: unless you are willing to be frozen in time with all your software tools, you will be in the update treadmill one way or another. Bitrot exists, and someone needs to pay for it. A license you paid 15 years ago does not (and should not) cover that.
- warrenm 5y agoIt's not merely "especially in the Apple world" - very little in the way of older Windows/DOS software still works today (unless you're also running old/unsupported hardware (subject to its own foibles) and operating systems Products get deprecated/go out of support all the bloody time - there is nothing wrong with that: should Ford have to "support" the Edsel or Model T today "for free"? Why?
- claaams 5y agoIn the case of Adobe you are paying for near malware Levels of surveillance on your device to use their products.
- Hnrobert42 5y agoLike what?
- tempodox 5y agoNot true. I prefer paying for upgrades on my own schedule to a subscription any day.
- gefhfffh 5y agoIncluding skipping upgrades?
- aceazzameen 5y agoYes. I don't need every upgrade, especially when 9/10 it includes new bugs on essential productivity software.
- coldtea 5y agoPlus today it's easier than ever to make updates (or bunches of related updates) selectable and installable on demand. So you could skip 90% of the BS updates you don't care for and get the 10% you do, as opposed to pay the full update price or maintain a subscription... In other words, you could get a base product, they keep maintaining, and even release new versions you can update to for free/cheap, but with features you haven't paid for locked. Then, if you paid for a feature, you get to enjoy it for all free/cheap updates of the program.
- aceazzameen 5y agoThat's how software used to be before they went SaaS.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ballenf 5y ago> Software should not be free (in cost), yet always receive new features and updates. That sounds like an extension of "you wouldn't download a car".
- Hnrobert42 5y agoHow so?
- AlexandrB 5y ago> Indeed, the alternative is the ad-tech surveillance state. One way to increase recurring revenue when you have a captive audience (i.e. they can't refuse an update) is by adding adware to your software. I think SaaS is the driving force behind the ad-tech surveillance state, not the thing that will save us from it.
- Hnrobert42 5y agoCan you give me some examples of SaaS that has ads? Cable TV, Hulu, newspapers. They all do it, but I can’t think of any SaaS providers that also push ads. I suppose cross-promoting s/w from the same vendor is an ad, but those kinds of ads don’t require intrusive surveillance.
- azalemeth 5y agoThe other model that works well is the open source one, with the maintainer having "another job"; e.g. academics doing scientific research (CERN!) or corporations who use the project internally. Unfortunately, the fact that the latter vastly outnumber the former means that the largest open-source projects are arguably corporate middleware or those of benefit to large corporations rather than users per se. People like me who use linux a lot are free software zealots. I wish Apple was more open on this -- they could quite easily be a hardware company and charge for services and yet make the code free -- but for whatever reason they've always kept the code close to their chest. Subscriptions may make more sense as B2B software where the needs change over time, businesses tend to like having a two-way conversation more and a well-defined bill at the end of each year isn't necessarily a bad thing. As a private consumer though, selling a subscription is a surefire way to make me say no -- I'm not doing it.
- eaplmx 5y agoA problem with open and free projects (to oversimplify the ideological differences) is the source of time and purpose. The production cost is subsidized as a Hobbie not as a profession, so it's hard to expect a 'consumer product'. When you put external money and corporate interest in your hobbies, something breaks. Not saying open products don't have to exist, we all love them. They cover different creative needs, and usually are a gift for the community. https://apenwarr.ca/log/20211229 https://apenwarr.ca/log/20211229 - The Gift of It's your problem now
- warrenm 5y agoThat's a FANTASTIC blog post!
- rglullis 5y agoIf Apple open sourced their software, they'd go back to the same spot they were when they allowed other companies to produce Mac clones[0]. It's not going to happen. [0]: https://everymac.com/systems/mac-clones/index-mac-clones.html https://everymac.com/systems/mac-clones/index-mac-clones.htm...
- toyg 5y agoYeah, it's not really about free software; it's about paying salaries. Recurring expenses inevitably result in business models optimized for recurring revenues. That was always the case; it just so happened that the expansion of industrial production of goods was so vast for so long, that this was kinda hidden (and it was hard to justify - there are only so many widgets you can continuously supply to customers). Now that the internet has removed any friction between business and customer, business is reaching its ideal state: one where the customer pays as long as the business has recurring expenses, where production never stops, and where productivity of labor approaches infinity.
- tjoff 5y agoRecurring expenses very often isn't necessary though. For software the initial costs are big, but after that it can be pretty low maintenance or at least costing much less to develop new features when the foundation is set. When you start to think about recurring expenses that's when you have to find a way to justify those expenses. And that is usually by adding bloat and unnecessary features that those that already bought it might not even want. So now you have to pay for features that you don't want to keep using the features that you've already bought? Tough sell...
- rodet 5y agoIn the case of local software, I agree. But most users expect connected services nowadays, which mean recurring costs for the developers as well in many cases.
- jtbayly 5y agoWhat do you mean by “connected services”? If that’s just a code word for cloud storage, then no, thank you. I’ve got cloud storage, and I don’t need yours. You’re just trying to justify charging me every month.
- falcolas 5y agoOnly if companies force their users onto “their cloud”. There are plenty of remote storage services; why can’t we use those? The answer is that it makes it harder to justify perpetual revenue streams then.
- MobileVet 5y ago> We don't want "super cheap products", we want reasonably priced products we own after we buy. I am afraid the ‘we’ here isn’t nearly as large a demographic as you think it is. If it was, we wouldn’t see the mass of advertising supported products we see. Mainstream consumers do want free / cheap products, despite the many caveats associated with them and the market has adjusted to give them that. The other follow up is, as a consumer, how do you determine what is a reasonable price for something. You have no visibility into the COGS other than your own experiences which may or may not apply. Similar to the OP, I am not advocating for high subscriptions with no value or horrible dark patterns around unsubscribing…
- uoaei 5y agoSometimes people think they want things a certain way because 1. They have no idea it can be different 2. They wouldn't know what it would look like if it were different 3. They don't understand, or they resign to accept, the ethical implications of the status quo
- willis936 5y agoNobody asked for subscriptions. Nobody likes them. People prefer free and second to that a one-time payment model. Maybe that payment only includes a year of patches, but people still prefer it. Companies prefer subscriptions because it maximizes revenue. It's as simple as that. Zero sum game between company and consumer.
- afarrell 5y ago> Nobody likes them. If that was true, financing wouldn't exist for consumer products. In practice, people pay extra to turn a one-time payment into a subscription.
- willis936 5y agoExcept with financing you own the product and one day the payments end. You're saying that home ownership is the same as renting if you don't buy upfront? That's simply not true. Also, the vast majority of people would prefer to live in a home they own than burn money renting.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> Blame the victim? I don't think it makes sense to call anyone making an informed decision to overpay for a service a victim. If you don't think the deal is reasonable, then don't accept the deal and use something else. The exception being profiteering in the case of a shortage, but I don't think this is the case. There is no software shortage being taken advantage of.
- coldtea 5y ago>I don't think it makes sense to call anyone making an informed decision to overpay for a service a victim. No, those I'm calling victims are people like me, who would like to buy the update and own it, but are instead forced in a subscription - which if they ever have to stop paying for whatever reason (e.g. out of a job, medical bills, etc) they lose their access to the programs they've been paying for month over month for years. A music program called Reason is a good example of the scumbuggery involved. It used to have $129 annual updates - which were already overpriced, as they had minimal changes, and more professional competitors like Steinberg with much bigger update deltas (new features, work involved, etc) charged much less for their annual updates. Now, they switched to subscription, for $20/month ($240/year) where they give access to some extra plugins to entice you. But to force the user's hands (since they still offer the paid annual updates), they also bumped the annual update price to $200/year (without the extra plugins, the regular, already-overpriced-at-129 update).
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI don't think you are a victim because you don't agree with the the terms of an offer. As you said, the actual changes are minimal. You can just reject the deal and stick to your old version, if you don't think it's worth it.
- coldtea 5y ago>You can just reject the deal and stick to your old version, if you don't think it's worth it. Which gets incompatible and can't run with changes to OS, plugin SDKs, and so on. Victim here doesn't mean "they put a gun on your head". It means they removed a specific update model and replaced with a shitty one, while doubling the prices, and fucking you over if you want to continue using the platform.
- bestnameever 5y ago> We don't want "super cheap products", we want reasonably priced products we own after we buy. I'd fully expect someone to provide this if there is a market for it.
- falcolas 5y agoThe problem is that the money and safety (which investors love) provided by “recurring sources of revenue” are too strong to counter with market forces alone. Kinda like how the money and safety provided by monopolies can’t be corrected by market forces either.
- AlexandrB 5y ago> The problem is that the money and safety (which investors love) provided by “recurring sources of revenue” are too strong to counter with market forces alone. There are two markets: the market of customers who might buy your product and the market of VCs who might want to fund your startup. Lately the latter has been making most of the decisions. It's nearly impossible for a bootstrapped startup to compete against products sold at a loss with VC backing.
- coldtea 5y agoThat's so quaint, it's like it's 1950s, and people still believe there's a free market and open competition...
- warrenm 5y ago>we want reasonably priced products we own after we buy That has [effectively] never been the case You don't "own" software once you buy it You own a license to use it (with some level of constraints around how/when/where you use it) Even if that license happens to let you use it as much as you want anywhere you want, that doesn't mean it will continue to work "forever" So many people don't understand that digital products are nothing at all like physical ones (except that you pay for both) - you own a paper book (albeit with restrictions on what you can do with it (can't make infinite/excessive copies of parts or all of it, etc), you have a license to an ebook; you don't own a copy of Microsoft Office - you have purchased permission to use it on X-many devices running Y operating system(s) Even if you "own" some copy of a public domain or freeware tool, it's still constrained by the system(s) it will run on
- coldtea 5y ago>You own a license to use it (with some level of constraints around how/when/where you use it) That's neither here, nor there. I didn't argue we buy and then own software like a shoe or a tire. People bought software before and we know the semantic and legal differences between it and buying physical products. But that's irrelevant, the discussion is about software-bought (with the license and all it entails) vs software subscription -- not about the semantics of bought software vs bought physical stuff.
- drewcoo 5y agoI, mostly, don't want products. I want to be able to communicate or veg out with a movie or have CI run. I generally don't care about the how. I just want the results. And I want to not think about it much beyond that. I, like everyone else, assume that's what everyone wants. My scribble on the HN wall that you're reading right now involved thinking about something more than I thought it deserved.
- coldtea 5y ago>My scribble on the HN wall that you're reading right now involved thinking about something more than I thought it deserved. Well, you might not care or what to think about the market, but the market cares and thinks about you. And if you don't pay attention, you can easily get taken for a sucker, overcharged, forced in abusive rent-seeking relationships and so on...