3 ms·

Let me quote the text for what I consider "judging" (in the sense of making a presumptuous claim about or characterization of a person or group): > What is eve

Let me quote the text for what I consider "judging" (in the sense of making a presumptuous claim about or characterization of a person or group): > What is even worse is that the CL community tacitly accepts [the behavior of the person I am arguing with] as normal behavior. This is making a judgment about what behavior "the CL community" accepts. (Unless you believe "tacit" includes anybody in the world who doesn't participate, in which case it's a vacuous statement.) Let me quote the text for what I consider "chastising" (in the sense of "rebuking"): > [In light of the tacit acceptance of said behavior,] I would like to see the CL open source community pause and consider what constitutes a healthy community. He believes the community had not acted properly or communally, and would like everybody to stop and think about that, almost as a parent might admonish a child for his or her behavior.

robertlagrant 5y ago
> I would like to see the CL open source community pause and consider what constitutes a healthy community. This is in no-one's dictionary "chastising" (random dictionary plucked from search): > chastising (Entry 1 of 2) inflicting, involving, or serving as punishment As for "judging" - this seems proportionate. E.g. while I think your judgment is poor when you use these words, I don't think a valid criticism of your comment is that you are "judging" anything. By this definition, almost everything anyone says is "judging".
- reikonomusha 5y ago
  Interesting, my dictionary says: > chas·tise > /ˈCHasˌtīz,ˌCHaˈstīz/ > verb > rebuke or reprimand severely. > "he chastised his colleagues for their laziness" I disagree with what you said about "judging" as it pertains to how you interpret what I said, but I don't have anything to further clarify for you. In any case, I hope you can now agree these claims weren't inventions.

robertlagrant 5y ago

> I would like to see the CL open source community pause and consider what constitutes a healthy community. This is in no-one's dictionary "chastising" (random dictionary plucked from search): > chastising (Entry 1 of 2) inflicting, involving, or serving as punishment As for "judging" - this seems proportionate. E.g. while I think your judgment is poor when you use these words, I don't think a valid criticism of your comment is that you are "judging" anything. By this definition, almost everything anyone says is "judging".

reikonomusha 5y ago
Interesting, my dictionary says: > chas·tise > /ˈCHasˌtīz,ˌCHaˈstīz/ > verb > rebuke or reprimand severely. > "he chastised his colleagues for their laziness" I disagree with what you said about "judging" as it pertains to how you interpret what I said, but I don't have anything to further clarify for you. In any case, I hope you can now agree these claims weren't inventions.