3 ms·
Something I have noticed. Consider the following trolley problem: - The switch operator is on a bathroom break - The trolley is headed for a dead-end where i
by aidenn0 5y ago
Something I have noticed. Consider the following trolley problem:
- The switch operator is on a bathroom break
- The trolley is headed for a dead-end where it will crash and cause $100k in damages.
- Pushing the button will divert the trolley to an empty track where it will safely halt, doing no damage.
- A bystander who is not employed by the trolley company happens to observe all of this
For more people than I would have previously expected believe that the bystander has little-to-no moral obligation to push the button (and a frighteningly large number persist even when you change the scenario to the trolley hitting someone) . Someone who does push the button has gone above and beyond, as pushing the button wasn't their job after all.
I have seen a lesser version of this in some of the discussion over the past few days; plenty of commenters basically saying that it's not the job of people not involved in ASDF to lift a single finger to help the ASDF maintainers, and that it is fundamentally impossible for someone to be wrong to ever refuse to merge a patch.
I suppose if we continue this analogy the argument that Stas is making is roughly "I've had to push this button like 3 times now, this is getting ridiculous, maybe if I let it crash this one time, the trolley company will stop sending trains down this track"
- reikonomusha 5y agoStas is more like, "I have pushed this button in the past for this very project, and it caused my downstream users to blame me for their software breaking, and so I don't feel compelled to continue doing so." On the whole though, making a comparison to trolleys crashing or $100k being wasted is a poor analogy. So there's no uncertainty, we are talking about a project maintainer refusing to remove a warning that he thinks shouldn't have been there in the first place. It's not like there's in-fighting on the same project. It's that one independent project can't convince another independent project to make a change materially inconsequential to either.
- BeetleB 5y agoThe key words in your comment are "moral" and "obligation". And yes, vastly differing standards on both exist. There are plenty[1] of people who will normally do something in a situation, but will utterly refuse to if they feel someone else is trying to morally obligate them into doing it. Wise people know to avoid using those words when they want to convince someone to do something. Appealing to morality is often a good way to polarize people. It tends to work only if the parties come from a fairly common value system. [1] Actually, I'd wager almost everyone is like this for something - that thing varying from person to person.
- User23 5y agoIn today's world, a rational bystander would consider the possible legal implications of getting involved and decide no thanks, not my circus, not my monkeys.