2 ms·
I've got severe problems with this posting on multiple levels. First, the Twitter thread is, as Twitter threads are, entirely insufficient to express nuance or
by dredmorbius 5y ago
I've got severe problems with this posting on multiple levels.
First, the Twitter thread is, as Twitter threads are, entirely insufficient to express nuance or comprehensiveness. The linked slide deck (in Danish) is similarly quite short on details. Its references are also largely unsatisfactory.
The whole presentation reads as if it's by someone who derived their conclusions, then plotted their research. Phrasing and framing ignores obvious evidence of real-world problems. If Petersen were a doctor, he'd be the type to whom a patient clearly suffering, or dying from, some unknown malady might present, to which Petersen would run a standard battery of tests, all inconclusive, and declare: "There's nothing wrong with you, all the lab results are negative."
If there are real-world problems --- disinformation dominatiting truth, spreading and persisting far more readily, political and genocidal disruptions occurring around the world, mental health epidemics coinciding with the adoption of social media amongst populations, and similar such issues --- then at best we can show that the specific research was either focused on the wrong elements, or performed inadequately.
The fact that changes in media profoundly change societies is well established, and dates back within historical records to the emergence of writing and mathematics. It all but certainly extends to narrative and language as well. Printing, literacy, mass-media, advertising-funded serials, telegraph and telephone, radio, mass recorded media, television, cable distribution, Internet, and mobile algorithmic social media have all left their imprints, quite often in war and genocide.
See Marshall McLuhan, The Gutenberg Galaxy and Elizabeth Eisenstein The Printing Press as an Agent of Change, for an overview of that thesis.
How, and why, Petersern comes to his conclusions concerns me greatly.