8 ms·
Thomas Hobbes’s Leviathan shaped modern politics
- antishatter 5y agoI mean did his work shape politics or did politics shape his work.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoIs there a version of this book that is a modern translation of sorts of the old English the book is written in? It has been on the list of books I wanted to read for a long time but picking it up has always felt more like labor due to having to work through the prose and style.
- stillbourne 5y agoReally though? Because the last five years have seemed more like Dante's Devine Comedy.
- int_19h 5y agoIMO the fact that it's impossible to have a state without "doubleness" and professional politicians is not an argument that idealistic approach to politics is wrong per se, but rather the argument that all states are fundamentally broken systems that have to be dismantled in the long term for us to make further meaningful progress in politics.
- curiousllama 5y agoHobbes’ state of nature (definitionally, the absence of a state) is definitely a lot worse
- jdgoesmarching 5y agoWell yes, Hobbes’ hypothetical very bad society would be very bad. The point is questioning whether we have any evidence to suggest this hypothetical society has any grounding in reality or, as Graeber suggests, has just been convenient to liberal ideology for a couple centuries and thus accepted as fact.
- RapperWhoMadeIt 5y agoGoing even further, Graeber also tries to dismantle the "counter-thesis" to Hobbes', Rousseau's primitive egalitarian harmonic societies. He shows lots of archaeological evidence suggesting that "primitive" pre-historic societies were probably not that simplistic in terms of social relationships, and some were most likely not egalitarian, since, for instance they would present different displays of wealth in how different people were buried. In summary, his new book 'The Dawn of Everything' tries to present evidence in a more scientific way in order to destroy these inaccurate portrayals of primitive societies. I even tried to start a thread and discuss the book in this HN post, feel free to participate. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30002793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30002793
- hilbert42 5y ago"...He [Graeber] shows lots of archaeological evidence suggesting that "primitive" pre-historic societies were probably not that simplistic in terms of social relationships, and some were most likely not egalitarian, since, for instance they would present different displays of wealth in how different people were buried." No doubt that's likely very true (as archeological evidence now suggests it is). However, it seems to me that Rousseau took his more simplistic view as a hypothetical starting point to argue his main one - that of the Social Contract. He probably reached a larger audience with his small book than grinding it fine by including unnecessary details - just guesswork on his part - about archeological prehistory, of which hardly anything was known in the 1760s. As it was, Rousseau was influential as witnessed by events in 1789. Some would even argue that he was too influential.
- huetius 5y agoI am interested in this book, and will probably get it. It seems to come at a time when the Western governments, despite their gargantuan size, seem totally incapable of resolving their innumerable, largely self-inflicted crises. Plagued precisely by the questions of meaning which Hobbes ejected from politics, the West seems to be demonstrating that one can have both the Leviathan, and the State of Nature at once. I’ve changed my views about a lot of things in the last decade or so, but seeing Hobbes as something of a villain has been constant. As a secular progressive, it seemed an overly pessimistic take on the possibility of political change. Today, as a (Catholic) Christian, and also a big David Graeber fanboi (these are not as radically incompatible as they may seem), I think that the State of Nature postulate, which forms the basis of Hobbesian thought, is not justified by actual human experience.
- slibhb 5y ago> I think that the State of Nature postulate, which forms the basis of Hobbesian thought, is not justified by actual human experience. Hobbes didn't think that humans had ever actually lived in a state of nature. It's a hypothetical, a thought experiment not unlike Rawls' veil of ignorance.
- huetius 5y agoYes! I reject both of those for exactly the reason I said above.
- ptsneves 5y agoIt does not need to be true to provide a good model. This happens in most concrete sciences so why not in humanistics? Actually when contrasted with the noble savage of Rousseau, the human as a bestial savage provides a great ground level from human behavior. From that model you can then have a model for the worst case scenarios of behavior and form governance from that. Probably not the optimum or most efficient but probably the model with the broadest applicability. This is what captivated me in Hobbes. Lot's of unanswered needs, but a very stable base for survival and improvements. I think it is also the model most people could understand at a basic level: Do not do that otherwise <the sovereign> will punish you. Even a child understand this with the parents being the sovereign.
- quotemstr 5y agoEven if you disagree with Hobbes's thesis, his book is worth reading for its own sake: the prose is beautiful, and Hobbes's step by step description of how people form a personal, and then a political consciousness, is exquisite.
- hilbert42 5y agoYes, I would strongly agree that Hobbes' Leviathan is worth reading for its own sake but also it's an aboulte must if one is interested in or studying Western philosophy as it holds a key place in the canon of philosophical works. In my view the Leviathan is an accessible work even for those who've never previously studied other philosophical works, and as you say, its prose is beautiful. Also, I find the way Hobbes lays out his thinking quite logical and the order of his chapters reflect that. As others have mentioned, the Leviathan was written at the height of the English Civil War. The state of unrest no doubt forced Hobbes to examine a broader more expansive view of the world - of law, politics and affairs of state than he may otherwise would have in more peaceful times. It seems to me that one should be familiar with the Leviathan before moving onto say John Locke and other Enlightenment thinkers.
- akimball 5y agoLeviathan is the most frequently read book in the ivy league, and this is why the American establishment is a wretched hive of villiany and scum.
- Herodotus38 5y agoCould you expand more on why that is? I have tried to read it but found it dry and stopped. Are there themes in it that you feel have created problems, what are they?
- akimball 5y agoOne problem is that Leviathan teaches that coordination problems must be solved by centralized force. Another problem is that it views society as competition for resources. The extremes of its rhetoric are a memetically potent drug, and turn exceptions into rules, which then become axioms in the minds of the susceptible privileged undergraduate population - axioms which then rationalize sociopathic patterns of abusive control perpetuated by the ruling elites. The populist reactions to these abuses are perhaps the most damaging aspect of the whole scenario as it is playing out today.
- Herodotus38 5y agoThanks! I might try to read it again and appreciate your thoughts.
- hilbert42 5y agoDoes that translate into 'Hobbes was a very bright bastard, so if you want get the 'good oil' on the matter then read him first' ? Reckon he's widely read elsewhere too - I'm definitely not one of them - so with others also in the 'know' then they may not have had such an advantage. Perhaps it was something else, something in their drinking water perhaps? ;-)
- mdp2021 5y agoIf reading X meant "being indoctrinated by X", humanity would have vanished early in history under tearing cognitive burden.
- chmod600 5y agoI view philosophies as necessary stepping stones for better civilization. Just because we have already progressed beyond a given philosophy doesn't mean it wasn't a critical step on the path to where we are today. And such philosophies are still important in areas that are less advanced or regress. Hobbes gets a bad rap because it sounds pretty horrible sitting in the peace and comfort of the 21st century. But we have to remember that the general attitude of "I better kill him before he kills me" (a kind of fear) has been the dominant cause of violence for most of human history. And there was an awful lot of that violence (read The Better Angels of our Nature by Pinker). Even violence that seems gratuitous is often driven by this fear. A gang leader is essentially riding a tiger he can't let go of, and must constantly generate fear to stay alive. Hobbes identified this trap, and found an ingenious way out of it: redirect the fear to a third party. If I am less afraid of my neighbor than what the government will do to me if I kill my neighbor, then I won't kill my neighbor. And if the government is vastly stronger than individuals, it will fear neither my neighbor nor I, so doesn't need to constantly terrorize everyone going about their daily lives. Then, violence drops low enough that people can think about things like voting or free speech. But voting and free speech make no sense in a world of violence and fear.
- mdp2021 5y ago> Hobbes gets a bad rap because it sounds pretty horrible sitting in the peace and comfort of the 21st century Hobbes was viewed as an enemy of humanity by many of his contemporaries. > [H]is writings are very bold. He published views that he knew would be strongly disliked by both parties to the English Civil War. He supported the king over Parliament, which earned him the enmity of those supporting Parliament, but he not only denied the divine right of the king, he said that democracy was an equally legitimate form of government, which earned him the enmity of many royalists, though not of the king. He also put forward views concerning God and religion that he knew would cause those who held traditional religious views to regard him as dangerous. The Roman Catholic Church put his books on the Index, and _Oxford University dismissed faculty for being Hobbists. Some people recommended burning not only his books but Hobbes himself_ (From "Hobbes", in The Oxford Companion to Philosophy) > Unused to having their own ideas taken seriously, philosophers today may be surprised to learn that the Parliament of the time regarded the doctrines of Thomas Hobbes (1588–1679) as a probable cause of the Great Fire of 1666. Safely dead, Hobbes is the greatest of British philosophers; alive and kicking, he was dangerous to know, and those in charge of the universities were not distracted by the notion of academic freedom from persecuting anyone who sympathized with his ‘lewd, scandalous and immoral doctrine’. In 1668 Daniel Scargill was deprived of a fellowship at Corpus Christi College and expelled from Cambridge for being ‘an Hobbist and an Atheist’. Scargill was promised in 1669 that he could return if he delivered a public recantation: two drafts of this were rejected; in the third, the unfortunate Scargill confessed to having been an agent of the Devil, but he was never restored to his fellowship and was obliged to live in extreme poverty. // The hostility of more orthodox thinkers was aroused above all by the intellectual ruthlessness with which Hobbes insisted that all divine authority must reflect earthly power. Nothing is more binding than the word of God: this Hobbes would be the first to allow. But, he argued, the word of God, like all words, may be interpreted in rival ways. What counts as an authoritative interpretation must therefore depend on the power of those capable of enforcing it (From "Persecution of Philosophers", in The Oxford Companion to Philosophy)
- jelicicm 5y agoHappy to see that community here mainly considers Hobbes to be "a villain". I'd like to point to the very enjoyable book by Rutger Bregman - Humankind[0]. In it, the writer discusses the differences between two important philosophers - Hobbes on one side and Rousseau on the other. First one has a general idea that "people are bad and need to be contained", while the latter is opposite. [0]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/52879286-humankind https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/52879286-humankind
- harryvederci 5y agoYes! This book really messed with my head in a good way. I don't know if I ever read a book before that taught me I had assumptions, and immediately tossed those assumptions in the trash can by showing solid evidence of the contrary. Highly recommended read! (For Dutch people: the Dutch title is "De meeste mensen deugen".)
- doe88 5y agoBellum omnium contra omnes. Davis Runciman has a very good associated limited podcast series [1] itself spinoff of his excellent recurring podcast [2] co-hosted with Helen Thompston. [1] https://www.talkingpoliticspodcast.com/history-of-ideas https://www.talkingpoliticspodcast.com/history-of-ideas [2] https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/talking-politics https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/talking-p...
- ofrzeta 5y ago> The idea that “Man is a wolf to man” sums up many of Hobbes’ theories in a single phrase. However, it should be noted that the sentence so often quoted as summarising Hobbes’ theories continues, “Man is an arrant wolf to man, and man to man is a God.” < https://www.grin.com/document/127218 https://www.grin.com/document/127218
- dr_dshiv 5y agoIt is still the coolest book cover in history.