7 ms·
Tonga volcano eruption created ripples in Earth’s atmosphere
- teeray 5y agoIt was fascinating to watch tweets of people seeing the anomalous barometric pressure spikes pass through as the shockwave circled the earth.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoWonder if this had an impact on altimeters in aircraft, especially older ones that aren't augmented with radar/lidar or GPS.
- numpad0 5y agoAirplane altimeters are adjusted according to a radio announced local pressure or a default(29.92 inHg). That make altitudes inaccurate but ensure separation between planes flying directly above and below. So shouldn't matter as long as pressure changes are nonapocalyptic.
- dredmorbius 5y agoProbably only as a transient. Though it's a reminder that what your instruments report is always only a proxy for the quantity being measured.
- awb 5y agoI heard that the waves were going to converge at the antipode of the explosion which was supposed to be in Algeria I think. Any interesting data or observations from that incident?
- mrb 5y agoHere is a neat animation based on METEOSAT-11 data: https://twitter.com/weather_models/status/1483006436750028801 https://twitter.com/weather_models/status/148300643675002880... Translation: «Antipodes are also animated with METEOSAT-11. The propagation speed seems to be different depending on the route, and the timing of coming to the antipodes is slightly different»
- wrath224 5y agoI’m a private pilot. I was taking off when it happened and the tower radioed me to check my altimeter once more because they weren’t sure if they were having an equipment malfunction. I looked back and it was the exact time of the expected pressure wave picked up by the official readings at the time. So I definitely noticed but figured it was just a general error, it was only after I checked the history did I realize it was probably the volcano !
- acidburnNSA 5y agoI counted 6 passes of the wave(s) on my home sensor, and maybe 7, but I have to go check neighboring sensors in the next state over to verify that the bump really is from the eruption. https://partofthething.com/thoughts/measuring-the-tonga-eruption-pressure-wave-with-a-home-weather-station/ https://partofthething.com/thoughts/measuring-the-tonga-erup...
- dwighttk 5y agoAKA sound?
- dredmorbius 5y agoNo. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30017321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30017321
- dvtrn 5y agoGravity waves? The way you described this in your other post as "in which the air column itself is transported vertically", did you mean pressure waves, as in a change in air pressure? I'm not a geologist, so don't take my incredulity for anything suggesting scientific fact, here.
- cjensen 5y agoWikipedia has the 'splainer for you[1]. There are good satellite examples online[2] But basically it has to do with buoyancy. A cloud or other layering of the atmosphere has a stable place in the vertical column. If the atmosphere passes over a mountain range that displaces the column vertically, the column returns to its normal position. In returning, the atmosphere overcorrects repeatedly and "bounces" back into position much like a single jump onto a mattress. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_wave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_wave [2] https://twitter.com/ggweather/status/1427061411604099077 https://twitter.com/ggweather/status/1427061411604099077
- dvtrn 5y agoThe mattress analogy was perfect and brought about the “aha” realization, so thanks for that!
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm not a geologist (or meteorologist) either, so salt accordingly. One 'splainer I've seen[1] described the volcanic erruption as the result of seawater infiltrating a magma chamber or vent, flash-vaporising, and basically blowing straight up to a height of about 30km (roughly 100,000 ft). Think of this not simply as a pressure wave blasting upwards, but as a bolus of air (and steam / water vapour) punching up through the atmosphere. It's analogous to a water wave spiking up out of fluid --- after it rises up, it will collapse back down, then rebound up, repeating this several times. The spike also both propogates out and creates a gravity-wave front which propagates outward, again creating a vertical wave across the top of the atmosphere. We're used to gravity waves in water largely because water isn't compressible. Sound travels through water, but shock waves tend to have limited reach since water itself doesn't compress --- a water shock is rapidly transformed into a water gravity wave, with a surge and collapse. (How much energy is transmitted through either wave mode I don't know, though someone versed in fluid dynamics could probably say.) Air is compressible, so a major part of the effect of an explosion is shock. That said, you can get gravity waves in air as well, and the Tonga erruption is apparently a demonstration of this. ________________________________ Notes: 1. Possibly GeologyHub on YT: https://yewtu.be/channel/UCYeGh5VML5XPr5jYnzh3J6g https://yewtu.be/channel/UCYeGh5VML5XPr5jYnzh3J6g Though I've been viewing / reading many sources. Update: found it here: https://yewtu.be/watch?v=YcCkQaLkfxA https://yewtu.be/watch?v=YcCkQaLkfxA
- IAmGraydon 5y agoWhy are these being called “gravity waves”? They’re nothing of the sort.
- nusq 5y agoThey are not gravitational waves but are gravity waves https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_wave https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_wave
- Taniwha 5y agoThey are waves in a density gradient caused by gravity - it's unfortunate, but essentially there are two things with the same name - English is like that some times
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere are numerous forms of wave phenomena. In water, surface waves operate principally under the effects of surface tension (small waves such as you'd find in a ripple tank, to about 0.1s period), or gravity, where the mass and inertia of the water moving up and down dominante. There are also pressure waves, which are the result of compression and expansion of a medium. Water compresses poorly, whilst air compresses quite well and elastically. Sound is largely a phenomenon of pressure waves. With the development of very sensitive instruments, gravitational waves in which the geometryof space-time itself is altered can now be detected. Despite the similarity in terms, "gravity waves" and "gravitational waves" are very different phenomena, and we'd need events at the scale of neutron star collisions to be ablet to create readily-detectable gravitational waves. Tonga Hunga was somewhat below this threshold. There are also electromagnetic waves, experienced as EMR (including visible light), AC electric power transmission, and magnetic waves. Again, different phenomena, though the same underlying wave equations describe this behaviour.
- mjevans 5y agoMaterial Wave might be a less confusing term than 'Gravity Wave' which at least outside of this field sounds like what someone in the field might call a 'gravitational wave'. Though that too should be subject to re-definition if a better and more easily communicated understanding of the density of space / time / gravity (as we know it today) makes the term outdated.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe waves observed being not merely compression (sound) waves, but gravity waves, in which the air column itself is transported vertically. Implications and impacts of this are as yet unknown, but the results might include mixing between atmospheric regions, impacts on satellites (increased drag for very-low-orbiting craft), the speed at which the waves propagate (atmospheric gravity waves should be slower than compression blast waves), cloud patterns (lifted humid air would tend to condense out, then re-vaporise, at it is lifted and lowered). What's changed in particular is our ability to observe, from multiple instruments and points of view, events of this magnitude. New sensors -> new observable phenomena.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFor more on the distinction and different wave types: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30018660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30018660
- 7373737373 5y agoPerhaps changed radio wave propagation too? https://dr2w.de/dx-propagation/ https://dr2w.de/dx-propagation/
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm not sure what that link is showing. And what mechanism would you propose?
- 7373737373 5y agoIn long distance rf communication, radio waves are bounced (sometimes several times) off different regions in the ionosphere (https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/antennas-propagation/ionospheric/hf-propagation-basics.php https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/antennas-propagat...). Since the waves caused by the eruption apparently reached the ionosphere, (some) radio bands may be affected.
- 5y ago
- walrus01 5y agoI saw sensor records from Oregon that clearly picked up the pressure wave.
- jcims 5y agoI wonder if they can estimate how much water was converted to steam in the explosion. I just read today that the power of this was equivalent to Pinatubo at its peak, the big difference is that it just lasted 10-20 minutes where Pinatubo ran for a week or more.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf GNU units isn't lying to me: The blast yield has been given as equivalent to 6 MT TNT,[1] equivalent to a large nuclear weapon. This estimate itself is probably based on shockwave, ejecta volume and velocity, or similar effects,[2] so I'm somewhat working backwards to the estimation basis, but let's roll with that. 6 megaton TNT is about 11,100 billion * 2260 J 2260 J is the latent heat of vaporisation of water (the energy required to turn 1g of 100C water to steam). If the ocean water were at 100C before vapourisation, that works out to about 11 million m^3 (or 11 million tonnes) of seawater vapourised, about 0.011 km^3. The actual amount would be less than this, as the seawater would have been heated from below 100C (at 4.18 joules/(g*degreeC)), and some of the heat would likely have been dissipated in other modes (e.g., kinetic energy). But that's an upper bound. Since steam occupies about 1,000 the volume of liquid water, that 11 million tonnes would have displaced 11 km^3 of atmosphere, or a cube 2.2 km on a side, or a sphere with a radius of about 1.37 km. Which makes me wonder what the specific blast geometry would have been, and how that might have affected blast and gravity wave generation. A narrow column jetting straight up might have a much more pronounced gravity-wave effect than a generalised, say, hemispheric, blast. As before: not a geologist. Edit: It's also helpful to remember that that volume of steam has mass and momentum. Once it starts moving, it's going to take some resistive force to stop it, and atmospheric resistance and gravity are pretty much all we've got to work with. But 11 million tonnes moving at a good clip (up to around 600--1,100 kph, based on other estimates of the shockwave) has a significant stopping distance. ________________________________ Notes: 1. Initial estimates were 10 MT, but revised downward. https://www.npr.org/2022/01/18/1073800454/nasa-scientists-estimate-tonga-blast-at-10-megatons https://www.npr.org/2022/01/18/1073800454/nasa-scientists-es... 2. Acoustic / shockwave methods are described here by Arrowsmith & Bowman, further methods are listed among references: https://asa.scitation.org/doi/10.1121/1.4984121# https://asa.scitation.org/doi/10.1121/1.4984121#
- tkgally 5y agoOn the morning of January 17 Japan time, my daughter and grandson were in a park near our home in Yokohama when she noticed that the clouds looked very unusual. She took some photos [1]. We speculated that the clouds might have been affected by the shockwave from the Tonga eruption. Other people in Yokohama posted similar photos to Twitter [2, 3, 4]. [1] http://gally.net/miscellaneous/20220117_Yokohama_clouds/index.html http://gally.net/miscellaneous/20220117_Yokohama_clouds/inde... [2] https://twitter.com/hiboshi045/status/1482884882837966853 https://twitter.com/hiboshi045/status/1482884882837966853 [3] https://twitter.com/mimikaki75/status/1483037087213375488 https://twitter.com/mimikaki75/status/1483037087213375488 [4] https://twitter.com/YasuA_Yokohama/status/1482878942176747523 https://twitter.com/YasuA_Yokohama/status/148287894217674752...
- awb 5y agoWere these clouds formed before or after the tsunami hit Japan?
- tkgally 5y agoAfter. The tsunami had arrived in several waves over about a twelve-hour period a day and a half earlier. A page in Japanese with the arrival times and peak wave heights at various locations is here: https://typhoon.yahoo.co.jp/weather/jp/tsunami/20220115131000.html https://typhoon.yahoo.co.jp/weather/jp/tsunami/2022011513100...
- Rastonbury 5y agoNot sure if the article is referring to this but you can see the shockwave from the blast move the clouds before the plume of ask appears here: https://youtu.be/zoMRwyNhqJ4?t=6 https://youtu.be/zoMRwyNhqJ4?t=6
- ginko 5y ago[1] looks like pretty typical altocumulus clouds to me.
- markdown 5y agoHere's a shock-wave/ripple from the eruption over South America https://streamable.com/35ip5k https://streamable.com/35ip5k
- alex_duf 5y agoWhat's the white dot going right to left at the bottom of the video? glare?
- markdown 5y agoHmmm... I never noticed that before. No idea.
- yucky 5y agoSeen from another view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDCMjmQr4Eo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDCMjmQr4Eo I saw this one first and dismissed it as trolling, until seeing the other view. Now I don't know what to think, but it is quite a coincidence..
- diggernet 5y agoMy guess: It's a reflection of the sun. Notice that when it moves off the west coast and over the ocean, it turns into a large specular reflection.
- WalterBright 5y agoWhen were were learning Bessel functions in college, the prof told us Bessel discovered them when trying to figure out why buildings in England fell down when Krakatoa blew up on the other side of the world. (Bessel functions tell you what happens when you hit a sphere with a hammer.)
- lostlogin 5y agoHave you a link to anything about this? That’s incredible.
- t9989789283 5y agoBessel died in 1846, long before the big Krakatoa eruption.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt appears I may be wrong about this. Wikipedia says otherwise. But I clearly recall being told that by my math prof. Oh well. Sorry.
- t9989789283 5y agoHe might have meant the 1815 eruption of Mount Tambora
- t9989789283 5y agoThis is very likely: 'It was not until October that the first plausible explanation for “The Year without a Summer” was suggested. Friedrich Bessel, a German astronomer, reported seeing thick clouds of dust in the upper atmosphere. He theorized that these dust particles screened portions of Earth from the warming rays of the sun. It was discovered that in April 1815, Mount Tambora, an Indonesian volcano, had erupted with such force that it had sent an estimated 100 cubic miles of fine dust into the atmosphere. Witnesses to the eruption reported that the sky remained dark for two days. The dust then rose high into the stratosphere, where it encircled the world for several years to come.' 'Skeptics in 1816 doubted that a faraway volcano could steal their summer. However, most present-day researchers believe Bessel’s explanation to be generally correct, demonstrating the global nature of weather. The dust in the atmosphere eventually settled, and the spring of 1817 was back to normal.' From https://shsatsunset.org/answers/q55-the-year-without-a-summer/ https://shsatsunset.org/answers/q55-the-year-without-a-summe... (I don't know the original source.) Bessel could quite easily have used his math skills to try to explain a local earthquake as a consequence of this eruption.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoSo, we still don't know everything and there are still new things to discover. It will be interesting to see what impact this has on the climate.
- mulmen 5y agoIt's amazing to me all the data we have collected on this. Academically I know we have satellites, sensors, cameras, models, effectively infinite storage, and mind boggling compute resources. But this event specifically it has really clicked for me how much we actually know now, and our capacity to learn. It's the first time I have been excited by technology in a long time.
- physicsguy 5y agoIn my old University, there was a barometer measurement sheet showing the pressure wave from the Krakatoa eruption. Was very cool!
- paunthony 5y agoThe eruption is compared to 500x atomic bombs
- Maursault 5y agoClimate change implications are interesting, I think a net negative in the long-term for all the greenhouse gases released, but an unknown short-term global cooling trend expected. Was the recent snow storm in Eastern US affected by the Tonga eruption?