2 ms·
I don't think it would take a case as exotic as that to put voters off voting reform. The odds are that any election is still going to result in one of the two
by jfengel 5y ago
I don't think it would take a case as exotic as that to put voters off voting reform.
The odds are that any election is still going to result in one of the two main parties winning. There may be occasional exceptions, just as there occasional upsets in FPTP, but for the most part there isn't any single Third Party that has the quiet approval of a huge range of voters. Rather, there will be many other parties, and the voters' second choices are likely to be either one main party, or blank.
Even if they check "everybody but the main party candidates", it's unlikely to produce a non-main-party winner.
I have a feeling that after voting reform, the strongest advocates will take note that nothing actually changed. They might declare fraud, or demand more reforms, but I don't see them accepting "Well, turns out that the people who compromise hardest assemble the biggest tent" as the answer.
Maybe I'm wrong, and I don't think it would do much harm to try. Sure, some voters will be confused, but they're already confused so that's just a drop in the bucket. But I don't believe it will make anybody happy, either.
- dane-pgp 5y agoI admit that most modest (and thus politically achievable) voting reforms would be unlikely to result in immediate wins for small parties, but that sort of stability is probably a desirable property of any electoral system. The main benefit in the short term would likely be that large parties (which are themselves coalitions of various factions, with internal dynamics that play out behind the scenes and usually without popular support) would split into smaller, more representative units. For example, if the Democrats split into a Hillary party and a Bernie party, the Bernie party might never have one of their members become the Speaker of the House, and two parties would formally or informally act as a coalition, introducing and passing pretty much the same bills as the (combined) Democrats do today, at least initially. Rather than advocates complaining that "nothing actually changed", though, I think they'd notice that the supporters of these new separate parties were reinvigorated, enjoying the ability to have a party that truly speaks for them and doesn't have to compromise at the stage of choosing its leader and identity. These new parties would allow the political discourse to change, and shift the Overton window, while also allowing parties to appeal to non-voters who had previously been faced with a choice of two evils, or uncompetitive districts.