3 ms·
My current question about black holes is: It is usually reported that the electron is a dimensionless point, with no extent. But it has mass. Why is it not, th
by ncmncm 5y ago
My current question about black holes is:
It is usually reported that the electron is a dimensionless point, with no extent. But it has mass. Why is it not, then, a black hole? A black hole with the mass of an electron would have an event horizon, which is not a dimensionless point. If it is a black hole, how does the charge "get out" to affect the outside world? If a black hole were given a charge, e.g. by injecting a stock of electrons, would it respond to magnetic fields, as an electron does, without being able to exchange photons with anything?
Or, if the electron is not a black hole, why isn't it?
An electron and positron annihilate on contact producing a pair of photons, which seems incompatible with their being black holes, unless maybe anti-particles have negative gravitational mass, so that contact gives the pair zero gravitation. Does it make sense to have positive inertial mass, but negative gravitational mass? I don't think that other particles (e.g. neutral, or positively-charged) smashed into electrons are known ever to get absorbed, as we might expect if it were a black hole.
If the electron and positron are both dimensionless points, yet somehow not black holes, how do their paths ever succeed in intersecting? If there is some minimum distance where they annihilate, why isn't that the size of the particle?
- alsonote 5y agoElectrons' mass is a little strange, in my (limited) understanding. The Standard Model predicts that electrons should be massless, but they gain mass (or maybe easier to say, "massiness") through interactions with the Higgs field. This effectively creates a constant "drag" on electrons, giving them a kind of inertia or "mass". I think this video does a good job explaining it, much better than I could: https://youtu.be/kixAljyfdqU https://youtu.be/kixAljyfdqU
- karlicoss 5y agoCool question, never thought about it! I'm not a physicist, but hopefully will be able to point at the right direction. Guess the short and boring answer is that we don't really know if GR applies at the scales of electrons (or to be more specific, how to apply it), so perhaps the notion of black hole doesn't even make sense, at least conventional sense. If you try speculating about it, there are some interesting points to ponder: 1. We know that black holes should evaporate via Hawking radiation. If you substitute electron's mass in the formula here [1], you get that electron mass black hole should evaporate in 6 * 10^-107 seconds. Clearly we don't see electrons doing that :) (however note that this formula assumes Schwarzschild solution, more about it further) 2. When you reason that if you narrow down electron's radius sufficiently, at some point is has to become a black hole, you kind of implicitly assume that it behaves according to the Schwarzschild metric [2]. This minimum radius at which you'd reason it's a black hole, would be the Schwarzschild radius. However, electron also has charge and angular momentum. Spin is quite different from a bunch of stellar stuff rotating around its axis, and I don't remember the derivation of GR solutions for spinning matter, but if we do speculate here anyway, still feels like we'd need to use the Kerr-Newman metric, which takes charge and angular momentum into the account [3]. If you use that metric, it's not the case anymore that any object with sufficiently small radius could form an event horizon -- if it has enough charge or angular momentum, it won't, so the electron won't be a black hole! However in a sense it only makes things works -- it exposes a naked singularity which we also don't seem to observe. P.S. the article also references "black hole electron" [4], didn't know it was a thing! 3. P.S. I also found this [5], which argues that even if you assume Schwarzschild radius for an electron, at this scale it's possible that the electroweak symmetry is restored, and the electron starts appearing massless. Can't say I'm fully able to follow this argument, so will just leave it here [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation#Black_hole_evaporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation#Black_hole_e... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarzschild_metric [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr%E2%80%93Newman_metric#Overview_of_the_solution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr%E2%80%93Newman_metric#Ove... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_electron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_electron [5] https://www.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/7fd7pg/if_an_electron_is_a_point_particle_and_a_black/dqb45lo/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/7fd7pg/if_an_elect...
- Ygg2 5y ago> dimensionless point According to QM. Electrons/positrons aren't a particle but much closer to a probability cloud. Black holes are fundamentally modified space time. So much, much different than particles. > A black hole with the mass of an electron would have an event horizon, which is not a dimensionless point. If it is a black hole, how does the charge "get out" to affect the outside world? Charge is one of few properties that black holes preserve. > If the electron and positron are both dimensionless points, yet somehow not black holes, how do their paths ever succeed in intersecting? Same way two clouds interact. No black holes necessary. Analogy isn't perfect. Two interacting clouds don't obliterate instantly to produce different clouds.
- ianai 5y agoThink of a black hole as [edit] a region of [/edit] the entire universe curling 'up' to an edge. Nothing within the universe escapes the edge, but the curl of spacetime has a way of pulling additional matter-energy into it.