6 ms·
Interesting that AA frames it as TPG's app stealing confidential customer data, while it is the customer who set up the app and willingly provided their credent
by paxys 5y ago
Interesting that AA frames it as TPG's app stealing confidential customer data, while it is the customer who set up the app and willingly provided their credentials in the first place.
Will AA be able to find a single customer who has a problem with what TPG does? What is their case then exactly? Would they similarly sue the app if customers were copy pasting data into it, rather than accessing it programmatically?
FYI the title is editorialized. This suit has nothing to do with screen scraping, but just data access in general. Services like these nowadays almost always use private APIs (built for mobile clients and SPAs) rather than parse HTML.
- nwiswell 5y ago> What is their case then exactly? That they're stealing AA's opportunity for, ahem, "customer engagement". They may have a case for tortious interference, I think? It does seem like an uphill climb. The strategy might just be to punish TPG with attorneys' fees and discourage this practice in the future.
- paxys 5y agoEvery similar case that has been litigated has been about wholesale copying of a large amount of content (e.g. millions of LinkedIn profiles, Craigslist listings, flight prices). In this case an individual customer authorized the access and only their data was affected. This is a pretty common use case for a large category of apps – think Mint, Plaid, all wallet apps which organize and track different accounts.
- sithadmin 5y agoAA and all other US airlines argue that information about your customer account is part of a data set that belongs to them, so they set the terms by which the data may be accessed. It's in their terms of service. This isn't particularly unique to airlines either.
- paxys 5y agoCan a company write "Chrome is not allowed to access this website" in their terms of service and then sue Google when customers still use it?
- pishpash 5y agoThey could (conceivably) if Google touted using their browser to access said website despite all this, especially if Google derived some benefit from it. It may well not come down to making available a tool, but to knowingly encouraging the breaking of ToS (assuming it's valid in the first place).
- tiahura 5y agoSomeone else gave a decent answer to your question, but I’m not sure that’s this situation. TPG is scraping AA and then displaying the results in TPG’s app. There’s an http request being sent by a TPG computer and IP address to AA. I think that’s a relevant distinction. I also think that’s relevant to whether TPG is a party to the AA TOS.
- paxys 5y agoI don't think that's an important distinction. TPG could be doing everything locally on the user's device (maybe they are?) and AA's complaint would be no different.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- martimarkov 5y agoWhat about ICloud plus Prody then? It comes from Apple’s servers. Add Safari reader on top of it and I think it becomes similar. Move Reader to iCloud proxy and I think it becomes almost identical?
- Tostino 5y agoThat should simply not be enforceable, period. If we had any consumer advocacy in government in the US, this BS would have never even come up.
- tiahura 5y agoThe US was formed under the premises that adults have the right to make their own decisions - good and bad, and that adults are the masters of their own property. I think these principles have served us pretty well despite the violations of human dignity like not being able to check your AA points from the TPG app.
- dylan604 5y agoAt the same time, doesn't AA have the right to protect themselves from potential abuse? I don't have a problem at all saying that I'm not supposed to share my credentials with 3rd parties. The user has no control over what the 3rd party might do, and can only make that decision based on what they think they are going to be doing.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The US was formed under the premises that adults have the right to make their own decisions - good and bad, and that adults are the masters of their own property. Yes, and AA servers, copyrights, and trademarks are all, under the law, it's property, of which it is master. That's kind of the whole basis of the lawsuit.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI don’t this matters, from a legal standpoint. The issue isn’t whether or not it’s what the customers wanted. The issue is that TPG wasn’t the party that entered into the agreement with AA when creating the account. I’m not suggesting it’s right or wrong, but that’s the issue.
- Glyptodon 5y agoIf I authorize an agent to act on my behalf in a particular way wouldn't they be considered and authorized as me? If I make a contract with Bob to mow my lawn, it's not like Bob's workers or employees have to sign the contract too. TPG shouldn't need to be party to the contract to be an agent of one of the contracted parties.
- backtoyoujim 5y agoHow does that logic apply to people that sublet rental spaces ?
- alexpotato 5y agoSome leases specify that sub letting is not allowed and doing some would put the original tenant in breach of the lease agreement.
- dylan604 5y agoI'd even say most leases vs some, especially regarding residential. Buying a house for the purposes of renting requires different financing (although most are being bought for cash) than a typical homeowner's financing which has clauses that says the person receiving the financing will use the address as their primary residence. These things get ridiculously specific.
- adrianba 5y agoSubletting isn't an agency relationship. It's not like tenants provide a service to landlords by occupying the property as well as paying rent. Also, the law around real property including leases is different and more involved than straightforward contractual relationships.
- nybble41 5y ago> What is their case then exactly? Speculating, but TOS generally say that you're not allowed to share your password with anyone. Assuming that's true for the AA site, AA might argue that TPG is encouraging users to break their TOS ("tortious interference"). Though if app doesn't actually share the password with TPG and just uses it locally there may well be a question of whether entering your password into a third-party app actually counts as sharing it with that party. How exactly would this be different logging in from a web browser? It's just a different kind of user agent. Are Google, Mozilla, Microsoft, and Apple guilty of tortious interference simply because the software they release has access to your passwords on your own machine and could report them back? (For that matter, they even store the synced passwords on their servers, though in principle those are supposed to be private.) Of course there could also be specific terms in the TOS against accessing the service with unapproved user agents, independent of any prohibition on sharing credentials.
- staticassertion 5y agoI doubt that part of a TOS is enforceable as it restricts speech. edit: No it doesn't, brain fart.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I doubt that part of a TOS is enforceable as it restricts speech. Contractual restrictions on speech are enforceable.
- xmprt 5y agoFor a simpler example, think of NDAs
- iso1631 5y agoWhat law says someone can't restrict free speech?
- paxys 5y agoRIP password managers then, I guess
- endofreach 5y agoSo basically corporations don‘t even pretend like they grasp the idea, that you pwn your data. It is theirs. You can use it, give it to companies, to the government, but you are not allowed to destroy it (just like currencies in many countries). LOL. Edit: typo. I wrote „pwn“ instead of „own“. But then I thought about it and somehow it feels appropriate.
- hunter2_ 5y agoTangent: pwn is always a misspelling of own. Granted, intentional meme usage is almost entirely limited to the "conquer" metaphor, but unintentional usage wouldn't have that same restriction/implication.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Interesting that AA frames it as TPG's app stealing confidential customer data, while it is the customer who set up the app and willingly provided their credentials in the first place. They think the data belongs to them. They think they own the consumers and all the data they generate. To them, it's their consumer data, something they abuse to get consumers to log in and look at ads, and they'll be damned if they let some random software have access to it no matter what the user wants. GDPR makes it clear that personal data belongs to the person, these companies are just middle men who are temporarily processing it. Cases like this perfectly illustrate why such a change in perspective is necessary. Access to this data is a privilege and it can be revoked.
- moralestapia 5y ago>We already make $1,000s per customer on a business model that we have developed and refined for decades. >Let's create a crappy experience that the user has to put up with, to squeeze a few extra cents per year.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoNever underestimate the greed of these people. They'd literally put ads under our eyelids if they could. They'd put ads in our dreams. They see our moments of peace as an opportunity to get richer.