3 ms·
This comes up every month or so. If you'd like to get rid of software patents, the lawyers, company management, and professional societies are not going to hel
by AlbertCory 5y ago
This comes up every month or so.
If you'd like to get rid of software patents, the lawyers, company management, and professional societies are not going to help. Band together, get a Congressman to introduce a bill, and then start pressuring candidates to support it.
If you write an op-ed about this, your opponents will cite medical and biological patents to defend "patents as an abstract idea." They will muddy the issue. The only way to defeat that is to separate out "software patents as a bad idea" from "worthwhile inventions that deserve patenting." You, yourself, might want to abolish all patents, but that proposal will face a blizzard of opposition.
The court has demanded that patent examiners who make a finding of obviousness cite documentary evidence for each feature in a claim, no matter how mundane or obvious the feature is. But what if the feature is so mundane no one would write about it? The paradoxical result is that the more obvious a feature, the harder it can be to prove obvious.
This is nonsense. Things are "generally known to ones ordinarily skilled in the art" can be ruled obvious and are all the time.
One researcher estimated that, for software-related inventions, about 50 percent of patents are likely invalid, even under the existing permissive standards for validity.
It's more like 90%, and I've read hundreds of them.