4 ms·
Question one: what is the world heart federation? I have never heard of it before today. Two: > The evidence is clear: any level of alcohol consumption can l
by colechristensen 5y ago
Question one: what is the world heart federation? I have never heard of it before today.
Two:
> The evidence is clear: any level of alcohol consumption can lead to loss of healthy life.
The evidence is not clear. There are plenty of studies showing benefits. “Any level” “can” makes the statement technically true but meaningless, you could replace alcohol with anything and that would also be true. If you want to back up the statement, do a meta analysis study and publish that instead of pretending you’re the authority and giving vague statements.
This reads like somebody with a prejudged conclusion announcing that instead of actual scientific openmindedness. Plenty of people in the comments who already agreed are eating it up.
How could anybody who didn’t already agree with this be convinced, their argument boils down to “we say the studies conclude this” which is trivial to refute.
- nabla9 5y ago> There are plenty of studies showing benefits. Yes. And these studies are being exposed as the product of alcohol lobby. https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/3/21/17139036/health-effects-alcohol-moderate-drinking-nih https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/3/21/17139036/he... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6055701/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6055701/
- colechristensen 5y agoI am perfectly aware of p-hackng. I still don’t believe it without actual evidence, I get strong vibes of people wanting this to be true which would take more than a little evidence to overcome.
- nabla9 5y agoThe alcohol industry gave the government money to prove moderate drinking is safe https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/3/21/17139036/health-effects-alcohol-moderate-drinking-nih https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/3/21/17139036/he... Alcohol industry involvement in science: A systematic review of the perspectives of the alcohol research community https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6055701/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6055701/
- tdeck 5y agoMany of these studies purporting to show a benefit from drinking included a sizable sample of people in the non-drinking group who had stopped for health reasons. In other words, they were probably told at some time in the past that they'd destroy their liver if they kept it up, indicating some level of damage to the body. In a society where some level of drinking alcohol is the norm, the non-drinking group has an overrepresentation of these people which skews the results.
- dionidium 5y agoIt's funny hearing this, because it's so clear to me that the opposite is the case. If you were an alien and you observed alcohol use on Earth for a few years you'd have no trouble concluding that it's almost certainly harmful even in small doses. But humans like alcohol, so they do not want this to be true.
- colechristensen 5y agoI mean we evolved consuming alcohol and are way better at metabolizing it than some of our primate relatives, some creatures thrive on it.
- Swenrekcah 5y agoLet me offer some food for thought: How many athletes report drinking a bit before competing? The answer is none because it negatively affects all physical ability. So would you say it’s likely that in aggregate drinking would be healthy? Edit: Wow, I guess people really don't like to think about this. To respond to both comments below, yes sure, sometimes it helps to relax just a bit and alcohol can help with that, but obviously you could also just drink some tea or actually train yourself to command better control over your state of relaxation. Alcohol is a shortcut that comes with some penalties, but personal ability might overcome those penalties. That doesn't mean that person couldn't have performed even better without drinking. And regarding lists of athletes that have been known to drink, well of course a counterexample to any absolute statement can be found, I'll grant that. But in the overwhelming majority you won't find top level athletes at the bar the night before the big event and there's a reason for that.
- stronglikedan 5y agoI used to have a beer before the gym, so I could get my heart rate up faster (thinner blood), and lift more (less pain response). If I were competing with an otherwise equally matched opponent at the gym, a beer would give me an edge.
- colechristensen 5y agoRefuting your “none” https://whyy.org/segments/when-a-bit-of-booze-is-just-the-boost-you-need/ https://whyy.org/segments/when-a-bit-of-booze-is-just-the-bo...
- penjelly 5y ago> The answer is none because it negatively affects all physical ability. Wrong. I can think of a few off the top of my mind who still have alcohol in their system while competing/training. - Arnold Schwartzenegger - Jon Jones and various other ufc fighters - olympic athletes in the olympic village according to news sources more here.. https://firstwefeast.com/drink/2015/08/athletes-drinking-habits https://firstwefeast.com/drink/2015/08/athletes-drinking-hab... Also note, physical ability isnt the only thing involved in high level performance. Ive had a couple beers before doing gymnastics before, and while it made me more disoriented i was less inhibited and actually performed better that day.
- tomtheelder 5y agoI think you've got the politics of this backwards. There is overwhelming cultural pressure to support some level of alcohol consumption. A host of shoddy (and largely alcohol industry funded) studies tried to demonstrate that it was beneficial. It's not. It's harmful no matter the quantity. Study after study demonstrates this now. I say this as someone who drinks regularly, by the way. I have no desire for it to be demonstrated that alcohol is harmful; it's a part of my life and has been for decades. If you want evidence, go open the actual brief and check out the dozens of references, including multiple meta analyses.