3 ms·
I have no opinion on NFTs. They are not my bailiwick. I don't plan on getting involved, so I am not spending much bandwidth on the matter. However, as a former
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I have no opinion on NFTs. They are not my bailiwick. I don't plan on getting involved, so I am not spending much bandwidth on the matter.
However, as a former artist, that has sold a few works, the concept of "original art" is important. That's how we can sell photographs, made with film, as the actual film is an "original." I know that when I sold my works, I did not explicitly sell the rights to reproduce. I was young and naive, but I think that the law was already sort of on my side. That meant that the buyers couldn't make money by selling prints of the paintings that I sold them.
Digital work kind of blows a hole under the waterline of "original art." Digicams are now prevalent. I think a few pro photographers use film cameras, but they are quite rare. Even Annie Liebovitz uses digicams. I know that camera companies have tried in-camera digital watermarking, but I also know that these have all been successfully hacked.
And then, we have 3D/pure digital art, which can be awesome, and can take as long as any master oil painting. One example that I use, is Worth Enough, by Radoxist[0]. He spent over a year on it (It's a 3D rendering). I think that Floating Bazar, by Emilis Baltrusaitis, took a lot less time[1] (I think it is a 2D work), but is still an impressive work. There's a lot more stuff out there. Those who sniff at digital media, are probably short-changing their worldview (of course, a huge market for 3D models, are "undressable" male and female mannikins).
I'm not sure that NFTs are the solution to establishing "originals." They just seem to be a way of proving that something was paid for. The artist and the customer need to word the contract carefully; just like they have had to do, for decades. I seem to remember reading about students of great masters, making copies and paintings in the style of their mentor, and selling it as the main artist's work, and we always know about unscrupulous art dealers, selling copies.
Note that Radoxist also sells "other views" of Worth Enough[2]-[5]
[0] https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/Worth-enough-73247873 https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/Worth-enough-7324787...
[1] https://www.artstation.com/artwork/QYdK3 https://www.artstation.com/artwork/QYdK3
[2] https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-shot01-141738236 https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-sho...
[3] https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-shot02-141738854 https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-sho...
[4] https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-shot04-141739215 https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-sho...
[5] https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-shot05-141739359 https://www.deviantart.com/radoxist/art/worth-enough-add-sho...