2 ms·
Yes. Tesla cars are not self-driving cars, despite their marketing. They probably won't be for years to come. I don't think anyone who has read up on the curren
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Yes. Tesla cars are not self-driving cars, despite their marketing. They probably won't be for years to come. I don't think anyone who has read up on the current state of self driving would come to any other conclusion.
At best the convicted drivers could sue Tesla for damages because of their advertising after conviction, because Tesla puts a lot of effort into their marketing materials to convince people that the car drives for you, but on the paperwork you sign you're reminded that it doesn't, and the software features that force you to keep your hands on the wheel at all times are a constant reminder of that.
- juanani 5y ago
- bluGill 5y agoTesla's marketing is admissible in court as evidence, and probably will carry more weight than any warnings. Marketing is designed to be clear and easy to understand, so courts tend to assume that people understand the marketing intent more than the letter of the legalese warnings. I have no idea what courts will do. It tends to take a lot of cases going opposite ways in slightly different situations before they settle down to something where anyone will attempt a prediction. We are still in the early days of this.
- jeroenhd 5y agoYou have to put in a conscious effort to stop the car from telling you to hold on to the damn steering wheel. People install mods to their cars to disable these features, but that too requires conscious effort to do. Tesla owners might sue Tesla for not fulfilling their promises, but I don't think they'll get out of the responsibility for autopilot accidents so easily. Unless the court rules that Tesla's cars don't pass the minimum road safety tests and are immediately banned from accessing the public road, I don't think any court will accept "the ads told me it was fine" as an excuse for killing two people. You're expected to know the law, and the law says you're responsible for your car while you're on the road. The subject of who's responsible for self driving cars is an interesting one, and it'll take years for real, clear decisions will be made, but that's completely irrelevant here.
- bluGill 5y agoThat is admissable in court too. I did not claim to have any insight into how courts will rule. They could decide given the marketing the effort to prove you are in control is obviously a bug. They could decide that the effort to prove you are in control is enough to mean you are in control. Until dozens of these cases have gone to court I won't guess.