3 ms·
>Now the procedure is: roll both dice. To find the total, choose whichever of the two uppermost faces shows more dots. To find the red number, take the red numb
by thfuran 5y ago
>Now the procedure is: roll both dice. To find the total, choose whichever of the two uppermost faces shows more dots. To find the red number, take the red number shown on the even (R) die, and modify it by the amount shown on the odd (C) die if any. If an addition takes you above 6, subtract 6 from the result; if a subtraction takes you below 1, add 6. [...] The mechanism I've described above works nicely on paper, but unfortunately it has a practical disadvantage, which is that it's unusually sensitive to imperfections in the dice.
While this is interesting, it hardly seems like potential nonuniformity due to unbalanced dice is the big issue here. I'd consider this an unusually complicated and awkward dice counting mechanic in a ttrpg. For a casual boardgame, it is beyond the pale.
- riversflow 5y agoI agree, cool problem solving, but ultimately a contrived solution. I found the next bit after your quote quite funny after thinking of this solution right away while reading. >A really obvious alternative approach would have been to roll a d6 (labelled 1-6 as usual) and a d5 (also labelled 1-5 in the obvious way), add the results, and then add one if it was 7 or more. . . I initially discarded this approach because it felt inelegant; I wanted my dice to roll (say) a 9 by producing something which was obviously a 9, rather than producing something that looked like an 8 and requiring you to remember to convert it into a 9. Because one simple rule is so inelegant compared to dice with numbers, dots and sometimes a second number, riiight.
- alar44 5y agoYeah I mean if you want elegant just reroll the fuckin dice. The solution is kind of interesting I guess, but it's so impractical I don't think you can even call it a solution.
- halfsquatch 5y agoIt's a colloid.
- kleiba 5y agoGeez, what happened to the hacker spirit? The guy saw a specific problem and thought it an interesting challenge to tackle. He showed that it's -- in theory -- possible to do it. And that's an obvious results, given that (a) he still wanted it to be two dice, like in the original; and (b) the relative probabilities of the other outcomes should remain unchanged. I think it's cool.