3 ms·
Are you sure about that? Because people often come up with theories about how the capitalists are about to abandon everyone to their fate and then it turns out
by roenxi 5y ago
Are you sure about that? Because people often come up with theories about how the capitalists are about to abandon everyone to their fate and then it turns out capitalism leads to Waffle House [0]. It makes capitalist sense to do disaster planning.
There needs to be evidence that the incentives point to scrimping on maintenance. Usually the incentives for capitalists is to preserve their capital and keep it is great repair. The is a strong, rational incentive to solve problems like winterisation because the revenue is higher than normal if someone can (and potential profits are much higher). Capitalism will just try to do it cheaply and to a standard that customers are happy with rather than in a politically showy fashion with gold plated "see I've thrown the kitchen sink at this!" style. But it will nevertheless do it if there is any money at all to be had.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waffle_House#Disaster_recovery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waffle_House#Disaster_recovery
- mjburgess 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_action_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_action_problem
- roenxi 5y agoYou're going to need to spell your point out a little more than just a link. If I manage to get in a position where I'm the only person in Texas selling power in a snowstorm I'm going to die filthy rich. That is the opposite of the collective action problem. There are enormous rewards for an actor the less other people act. Which is one of the reasons bigger corporations do disaster planning, it lets them scoop up profits when prices are higher. Capitalists don't give up easily if there is a person willing to spend money on something. They have flaws, but motivation to provide goods and services isn't one of them.
- mjburgess 5y agoMy point was that simple a-priori logic of the kind you offered regularly fails. A fast-food restaurant who wants to keeps its machines running has profit-driven feedback loops of a radically different nature than those of an energy market (esp. when such a market has natural monopolies). And likewise, markets are amoral. If the "market" opts for a failure every decade over a higher-priced day-to-day run... this isnt "rational" or "correct" or "ethical" or whatever. The way a market happens to function is amoral. You can make the argument that over fairly short time horizons in non-critical areas "meeting consumer demand" in most cases has a certain consequentialist justification. This doesnt carry over, a-priori to all possible cases. Ie., it is quite reasonable for a society via a democratic expression of ethical judgement to say "the market is not here considering the long-term impact in the right ethical manner"... ie., that being without power when it's -20 outside & affecting the whole population in ways not priced in by the market is a *moral failure*. It is the prerogative of the collective to say at once "here's how it should be", rather than via iterated interactions "here's how its happened to be".
- fsagx 5y agoNo one gets a bonus because no disaster has happened in decades. Squeezing a percent or two out of a maintenance budget is exactly the kind of behavior that regularly is incentivized.
- roenxi 5y ago> Squeezing a percent or two out of a maintenance budget is exactly the kind of behavior that regularly is incentivized. We're not talking a percent or two here. We've got people claiming that a company whose sole tactical purpose is to get energy to consumers failed sorta-on-purpose. That claim is more wild than some people in this thread realise. It amounts to giving up free money. If they'd charged outrageous prices that would be one thing. But failure to supply power, by a company that makes money supplying power? This isn't an incentives problem, they were genuinely caught by surprise. Arguing incompetence is one thing, but people are calling out incentives here without having good evidence of an incentives problem.
- thrwyoilarticle 5y ago>It makes capitalist sense to do disaster planning. Until a yet another black swan event happens that requires the government to step in and help them with the eventuality they didn't plan for. Like COVID. If there are two companies competing and only one of them pays to be resilient against disaster, they won't be able to compete on price and will lose market share.
- revolvingocelot 5y agoSerious question, did you read any of the above comments, or TFA? My immediate reactions are "restaurants and power companies are sliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiightly different in their ownership, provision of services, capital costs, financing, profit-margins, regulatory structure, and whether-they're-a-natural-monopoly" and, perhaps more importantly, "we're in a comment section about utility-company capitalists abandoning everyone to their fates, and making billions doing it". We're not in a comments section about a theorycrafted threat of that happening, or a comments section about twiddling incentives to encourage WH-like behaviour, we're in a comments section discussing the consequences of capitalist abandonment: namely, they made billions doing it.
- roenxi 5y ago> officials decided to bypass the market and, on Monday evening, manually set prices at the maximum of $9,000 per megawatt hour You're trying to argue that this quote + greedy heartless capitalism -> give up and let the energy grid go dark. That needs strong evidence. Occam's razor suggests they were genuinely caught off guard and they'll be better prepared next time. $9k/MWh is a very tempting price for someone who can have a generator set up on standby. Some people like making insane revenue. Possibly even some Texans. The price of electricity was basically infinity here.
- revolvingocelot 5y ago>strong evidence What actually happened is insufficient for you? Let me know when sweeping changes are made to prepare the gri-- >$9k/MWh is a very tempting price for someone who can have a generator set up on standby Oh, I see -- the solution is to let the market "solve" it. The physical-world issues that led to that tempting price will wreak their havoc on the physical-world infrastructure the next time that tempting price is set, but the kind of physical-world prophylactics that could have prevented that tempting price are "too expensive" to implement. Rather than prevent the catastrophe, instead ensure that someone is poised to swoop in and profit from stabilizing some preventable chaos. >Some people like making insane revenue If the grid didn't go down, why, no one would be able to make $9k/MWh!
- specialist 5y ago> It makes capitalist sense to do disaster planning. Then explain the recurring failure of the Texas energy sector to do so.