2 ms·
> "Consider chemical engineering. Chemical engineering is unlike mechanical, civil, or electrical engineering. Chemical engineers create processes to manufactur
by photochemsyn 5y ago
> "Consider chemical engineering. Chemical engineering is unlike mechanical, civil, or electrical engineering. Chemical engineers create processes to manufacture products at scale, often using experimentation and iteration. But nobody would disagree that it is engineering. Chemical engineering started in the late 1800s, before states licensed engineers. If chemical engineering started now, people would refuse to call it engineering. And they’d be wrong to refuse."
This induced a little painful wincing. Chemical engineering relies heavily on detailed knowledge of fluid mechanics, because industrial chemical processes generally take place in liquid or gas phase, often under conditions of high pressure and temperature, and so you do indeed need the same kind of general approach that the other listed fields of engineering apply. They rely on mathematical models, to ensure that you don't get explosions (ideally anyway), etc. They need to be able to calculate things like the pressure at the bottom of an oil storage tank and so on. Look at any textbook on fluid mechanics for chemical engineers, it's the same kind of thing.
The author may be thinking of something like organic chemists who work in tamer lab settings, devising new reactions at benchtop scale, but organic chemists generally aren't going to be able to scale up a promising benchtop process without the input of a chemical engineer who has a detailed knowledge of fluid mechanics. Nobody refers to such organic chemists as 'engineers' in my experience, I think the more generally accepted terms are 'researcher' or 'scientist'.
- chiyc 5y agoYou and the article are both right. Chemical engineering does rely on that knowledge, but plenty of it is done via experimentation. Process controls are largely developed through a lot of experimentation and data collection to understand how a process responds to various inputs. There was a great comment elsewhere about how engineering is about dealing with the unknowns and noise of the real world, which is why engineering requires empirical evidence to further refine or create those models. Engineers may use models to calculate estimates but it all needs to be backed up by data.