6 ms·
Since it is a common usenet/forum/flame warrior method, I have a strong opinion about: Address multi-faceted comments by breaking them down and using points, n
by brudgers 5y ago
Since it is a common usenet/forum/flame warrior method, I have a strong opinion about:
Address multi-faceted comments by breaking them down and using points, numbering and quoting.
Except when the facets are purely technical, this approach trends toward full defensive point by point rebuttal.
Once the points counting starts, the logic of points-counting becomes part of the public performance.
In general, people don’t like to have their comments picked apart in public because it doesn’t solve their problem. And because it is an aggressive response to what is usually just wanting to have ones say.
It is a tactic better suited to the context of private communications and with the appearance of having given the matter a few hours thoughts. Otherwise it tends to “broaden the front” when done in public performance.
It’s not likely to make HN better. YMMV
- stonegray 5y agoI do like that it provides certain guarantees that the post was read fully, and that each question/issue was addressed and not missed, sort of like a Shisa Kanko (Point and Call) for online replies.
- brudgers 5y agoCopying and pasting and adding numbers is violent editorial surgery and allows the respondent to cherry pick quotes and remove them from context. In a public discussion, it provides a public performance that might lead spectators to imagine the respondent read everything. As a general form, it implies that the first comment wasn't very clear and/or it's thinking not well organized...while of course showing that the response is well structured thought. On the other hand, all stakeholders consent to Shisa Kanko in the context where it is used, and the communication channel is strongly bounded. The channel excludes opinions, expressions of deep feeling, and open ended questions. There's no circumspection.
- Taywee 5y agoI think it's quite situational, but I quite agree. I also find that when you do this and get into a conversation with somebody who does this, the back-and-forth also just bloats up and gets bigger and more multi-faceted as the conversation progresses. I find that it's much better to just address the general argument and maybe the very major points specifically if necessary. I think bad-faith arguments on the internet have made a lot of people really defensive and aggressive, though. I've seen a lot of people smugly arguing past each other about how they aren't discussing things properly ("you didn't even address all of my points"), and the discussion always devolves to just arguing about arguing.