4 ms·
The US seems to be the most lawless of the places that have functioning rule of law. Highest murder rate, for instance. What are you going to do with that? F
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
The US seems to be the most lawless of the places that have functioning rule of law. Highest murder rate, for instance.
What are you going to do with that? Fix the society? Well, yes, that would be ideal, but we haven't found a workable plan so far, despite lots of trying.
Failing that, what are you going to do? Let murderers go free? That actually can work, for those who just had a lapse of judgment. For those who are likely to try to do it again, though, that seems like a very shortsighted solution. Fewer people in prison, but more dead bodies on the street? That's not a good trade for society as a whole.
So, given the lawlessness in society, given the visible problems of not punishing crime, less punishment seems unwise.
Actually, less/more is not the correct axis. What we really need is more certain punishment. I don't care how many people that puts away, put away everybody who commits a felony.
But even that's not the whole answer, because we need to revisit things like decriminalizing certain drugs. Would society as a whole be better off, or worse?
The real answer is that we need a society where people restrain themselves, so that the law doesn't have to do the restraining. Lose that, and the only options left are anarchy and oppressive enforcement.
- rdtsc 5y ago> The real answer is that we need a society where people restrain themselves, so that the law doesn't have to do the restraining. Fundamentally I agree. Once we stop relying on people’s self regulation and basic decency we have already failed. Overflowing prisons is a telling sign of that failure. I guess one benefit of US being so large and states and municipalities having the ability to create their own laws, is that eventually we might learn what works best after observing results. How did the reforms in San Francisco or LA work? If they worked well, other states might rush to copy. If if didn’t, at least it’s isolated to a few areas.