2 ms·
The article was good in the first half, but then steadily goes downhill in the second half. >The letter also attempted further to politicize L.A.’s no-cash bai
by gruez 5y ago
The article was good in the first half, but then steadily goes downhill in the second half.
>The letter also attempted further to politicize L.A.’s no-cash bail policy / Special Directive 20-07
Is this supposed to be bad? It seems to be bad faith to accuse someone of "politicizing" something when it's plausibly related to the topic being discussed.
>(“Studies show that prosecution of the offenses driving the bulk of misdemeanor cases have minimal, or even negative, long-term impacts on public safety.”)
...with no sources provided.
>Even though, according to LAPD data, property crime is down.
That's not really as slam dunk as it suggests. If the government openly states that they're not going to bother prosecuting minor property crime, it seems reasonable that a fair chunk of the victims will be dissuaded from reporting the crime, driving property crime statistics down.
>“These individuals are generally caught and released back onto the streets in less than 24 hours. Even with all the arrests made, the no-cash bail policy and extended timeframe for suspects to appear in court is causing re-victimization to Union Pacific by these same criminals.” Community activists think otherwise, supporting the DA’s no-cash bail policy
this... doesn't say much. I'm sure for any topic you can find "community activists" for your preferred side.
>stressing that further criminalizing people of lower socioeconomic status for non-violent crimes isn’t a real solution.
The criminals criminalized themselves when they committed the crime, not when the law decided to prosecute them.
>A connection worth questioning can be found with the controversy surrounding Emanuel Padilla.
No, I actually don't see the connection here. Are they accusing UP of falsely accusing/prosecuting people? Are they just saying the previous DA sucks and the current DA is good? Are they just bringing it up because the case has something to do with trains?
- vkou 5y ago> That's not really as slam dunk as it suggests. If the government openly states that they're not going to bother prosecuting minor property crime, it seems reasonable that a fair chunk of the victims will be dissuaded from reporting the crime, driving property crime statistics down. The main reason people report property crime is because insurance requires a police report. If you were a victim of property crime, your odds of ever seeing your stuff back a decade ago, and today aren't meaningfully different.
- gruez 5y agoI'm not a home insurance expert but I suspect most peoples' deductibles for theft is around or above $950. Therefore from an insurance point of view it doesn't really make sense to make a claim, at least for the amounts that we're talking about.
- ryan_lane 5y agoIt's unlikely that if your house is broken into that you have less than $950 worth of loss, because usually you'll have broken doors and windows, along with a large amount of missing stuff. Also, you realize that in general police rarely investigated burglaries, and even in the case of serial burglaries, few are solved. Arrests are rare. It has absolutely nothing to do with lack of prosecution. I've been a victim of burglary in the past, and when the cops came, they walked around, and took some pictures. They questioned us, because we were young and our place didn't have a lot of valuables, and they suspected us to be drug dealers. I asked them when we could expect any followup, and they literally laughed, then said "we're probably not going to bother investigating because the investigations rarely find the perpetrators. we're here so that you can file an insurance claim." We had more quite a bit more than $1000 of stolen goods and damage, and we were poor at the time.
- scythe 5y ago>>(“Studies show that prosecution of the offenses driving the bulk of misdemeanor cases have minimal, or even negative, long-term impacts on public safety.”) >...with no sources provided. In the original directive, "the offenses" in this quoted sentence refers to a basket of crimes including "unlicensed driving, sex work, drug possession, drinking in public, and trespassing" -- it does not mention theft explicitly: https://da.lacounty.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/SPECIAL-DIRECTIVE-20-07.pdf https://da.lacounty.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/SPECIAL-DIRE... Considering that it is questionable whether sex work, drug possession, and drinking in public should even be criminalized at all, this seems like a fallacy of composition. >>Even though, according to LAPD data, property crime is down. >That's not really as slam dunk as it suggests. If the government openly states that they're not going to bother prosecuting minor property crime, it seems reasonable that a fair chunk of the victims will be dissuaded from reporting the crime, driving property crime statistics down. Special Directive 20-07 went into effect on December 8, about six weeks ago. I'd be surprised if there are even reliable data available, especially since the on/off lockdowns act as a large confounder.