3 ms·
There's a great 2004 documentary called Kill Yer Idols that explains it all. It follows the bands that inherited the mantle of seminal New York bands such as S
by wolverine876 5y ago
There's a great 2004 documentary called Kill Yer Idols that explains it all.
It follows the bands that inherited the mantle of seminal New York bands such as Sonic Youth. For the most part it's what you expect, with some great historical cuts, interviews, the new bands reflecting on and praising their predecessors, etc.
*SPOILER*
But it has a surprise ending. Suddenly there's a different tone from the old bands. They disparage the newcomers: The older bands completely rejected what their predecessors did; they destroyed it. The new bands that copy their music completely miss the point; what they are doing is antithetical to the art.
And I agree: We still have people playing rock'n'roll and hip-hop generations later. Are you kidding me? How shameful! How boring! Heck, someone play big band at least. Rock and hip-hop were revolutionary artforms; they didn't try to sound like Frank Sinatra or (for hip-hop) the Beatles - in fact, they tried to sound completely different, to demonstrate their rejection of the prior generation, to throw it in everyone's faces. Until I hear someone completely reject rock and hip-hop, burn them down to ashes (artistically), and piss me off, it's all bullsh-t. (And I mean it; I haven't listed to this crap in years.)
- listenallyall 5y ago> Until I hear someone completely reject rock and hip-hop Isn't that electronic music? No recognizable instruments, often no lyrics or song structure.
- BeFlatXIII 5y ago> no song structure Just because there are no lyrics and it is no longer technically a song does not mean that the music has no structure. Saying so is needlessly pedantic.
- TomSwirly 5y ago"Song structure" has a very specific meaning in music that has nothing to do with lyrics or lack thereof. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Song_structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Song_structure
- wolverine876 5y agoSome electronic music fits the bill, to a degree, and there is plenty of niche stuff - New Music (i.e., contemporary classical), for example - but the OP is about broadly popular music.
- throw_m239339 5y agoElectronic music has become heavily derivative of itself since the current "techno revival". newer artists are literally copying 90's techno artists, instead of inventing something fresh. There has been zero innovation or new genre in Electronic music in the last 7 years. the 90's popularized techno, house, trance, abstract hiphop and drum'n'bass. 2000 popularized minimal techno and dubstep. Since then? Nothing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]