3 ms·
It was mostly Christopher, Tolkien's literary executor, who was absolutely opposed. He passed away a few years ago. This project was announced about the same ti
by jfengel 5y ago
It was mostly Christopher, Tolkien's literary executor, who was absolutely opposed. He passed away a few years ago. This project was announced about the same time that he retired from being executor.
They appear to have the rights to the Silmarillion material, which provides most of what is known about the Second Age (when this series is set). That material isn't very long, only a few dozen pages; it's more an outline than an actual story.
So it would absolutely have to be "in the spirit of Tolkien" rather than an actual story. But they appear to have access to the "canonical" material, which is enough to craft a story that would be satisfyingly consistent.
This appears to also draw on the other chapter, "Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age", which is mostly about the material covered in Lord of the Rings, but provides important detail about what Sauron was doing at the time of Numenor. It could help inform a story about how Sauron led to [spoiler alert] the destruction of Numenor.