6 ms·
> because their internal systems were designed to delay, deny and deprive, I say. Definitely. I know someone in NJ who has not received unemployed benefits fo
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> because their internal systems were designed to delay, deny and deprive, I say.
Definitely. I know someone in NJ who has not received unemployed benefits for 14 months. They call every month, and are told to keep waiting. No one returns their calls, snail mail, or emails.
There is zero justification the government cannot respond via email, or give you a call back, other than they would like you to waste so much of your time and effort on hold that you give up.
- exhilaration 5y agoYou should let them know to contact their state legislator. From what I read on various state subreddits that's the only way to get a response from your overwhelmed state unemployment office. This is the equivalent to escalating your issue to a manager.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> You should let them know to contact their state legislator. [...] This is the equivalent to escalating your issue to a manager. No, it's the equivalent of escalating it to a member of the Board of Directors.
- giantg2 5y agoAKA don't expect any response because "the board" is too high up to deal with a nobody like you or me.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> AKA don't expect any response because "the board" is too high up to deal with a nobody like you or me. Well, maybe. Legislators are really variable on constitutent service, but many will (or rather, will allow their office staff to; direct, even by something going out under their name rather than a staff contact, is less common) at least gently probe on behalf of constituents on state service issues, and if a high enough volume is involved are more likely to get personally involved. But any response that does happen is likely to involve butt covering and blame redirection from virtually every step of the management chain, just like when an issue hits the news media, so on issues where you haven't exhausted other avenues short of lawsuits, it's probably not the step to reach for the way escalating to a manager would be. I’ve definitely been involved in issues where premature escalation to a legislator delayed and/or made the resolution less favorable than it probably otherwise would have been because of the degree of attention from management, legal, public and legislative affairs, etc., that the escalation triggered. It makes sense in the particular circumstances described, though, it's just the analogy that was flawed in a way which might be misleading as to how that generalizes to other situations.
- giantg2 5y agoI got no response at all from multiple letters to multiple reps/senators on an issue I had.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey have, the legislator also has a canned response. And the pandemic started Mar 2020, it is now 22 months later. That is far sufficient time to get a response, even if they were initially overwhelmed. Families and businesses get overwhelmed too, but they are expected to file NJ tax returns on time. Try not responding to NJ for 14 months after NJ is owed money and see what happens. Rules for thee but not for me is the motto of many governments.
- rhizome 5y agoEach person in the US is a constituent of multiple regional legislators, from city council (or local versions) to Representatives and Senators (and President, sure). I've found luck in starting with emailing the office of my lowest (closest) representative at the smallest unit of government, telling them my problem, and asking them who I can talk to about it. "Who's responsible for pothole repairs on (street that might be state or county controlled instead of the city)?" This puts the ambitions of the office to work. Oftentimes they will rather get credit for solving your problem and do work for you than just give you a phone number or email address, and in the event of a roadblock you can go back to them for more help. "Hey, I tried X but Y happened, got any other ideas?" Your state rep's communications intern doesn't just sit back alphabetizing checks from Walmart executives and police unions.
- giantg2 5y agoHa. I'm my case my representatives completely ignored my letters about rights violations and misconduct by the state police. On other issues, I only receive unhelpful form letters, some of which don't even address the correct issue. Don't expect any real help from your representatives unless it somehow benefits them.
- rhizome 5y agoLaw enforcement is different.
- giantg2 5y agoHow so? I should be able to ask my representative's stance on justice reform and get a response. I did not ask them to get involved with a specific case.
- jrochkind1 5y agoOK, now you're talking about asking for a policy position, rather than what they call "constituent services". "Constituent services" is "I am personally having a problem with some aspect of government in my personal life and I am contacting you as my elected representative to help me." In every place I've lived, elected officials are good at constituent services, and that's how they get re-elected. I'm surprised to hear of elected reps just ignoring constituent services requests. I also sometimes contact my reps with lobbying/policy stuff -- what is your position on X? I urge you to vote No on Bill Whatever and would like to know if you will. Can you commit to supporting legislation to reform Y? Etc. And it can indeed often take months to get a form letter response that may not really respond to my query at all, or not get a response at all. It's true. If you want to go on to say that they shouldn't be different, or that the policy issues really do effect you personally so should be considered or treated the same... that's fine, you may be right, but it's not how the offices of elected officials usually operate. Also, while I'm surprised to hear of reps totally ignoring constituent services requests with no response... if your constituent services request was about police misconduct, and they aren't known as a far-left politician, I'm less surprised, because that's such a hot button "political" issue. (I'm not saying it's "ok" or I like it, just based on my understanding of how politicians operate i'm less surprised).
- ryanianian 5y ago100% this. I had an issue with the NJ DMV, and the senator's office was able to get my issue resolved like same-day and told the DMV to eat glass. I even got a formal apology letter from the DMV. Not all congresscritters will have the same effectiveness, but that is the first place to start if the trail to getting results turns to a dead-end.
- philistine 5y agoThe correct term would be a government ombudsman. And legislators totally fulfill that job for a significant part of their day.
- Loughla 5y agoDue to COVID, my representatives no longer take visitors, and no longer take phone calls to their office, nor do they provide a contact e-mail. They have a form you can fill out on their websites. That way you get a response (thank you for completing the form) and then zero way to track the communication. In my case, I have never received anything after that from any of my representatives. You can't call to check on it, because, again, they're no longer taking phone calls. And even if they did, you have no reference number. They took advantage of the pandemic to just completely cut ties with their constituents outside of THEIR approved avenues. Super cool. Very representative.
- vkou 5y agoIt sounds like their opponents should easily be able to trounce them in an election. If you don't like your current reps, you may want to tip the other campaign (or internal challengers in the primaries) on this. If you otherwise like your current reps, I'm sorry.
- smsm42 5y agoYou assume it's a place where there are competitive elections which compete on satisfying the voters. In many places, it's not the case - it's either uni-party location where whoever the party appoints wins, or a location where the competition is between different groups of special-interest players that couldn't care less about the voters that do not align with them. If you find yourself in that environment - nobody is trouncing anything, however incompetent the actual management of affairs becomes. People stay in their positions until they either die or decide to move on by their own volition.
- hn_version_0023 5y agoWithout representation, we simply shouldn’t pay taxes. Right?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> There is zero justification the government cannot respond via email, or give you a call back, other than ... ... that we collectively refuse to pay enough taxes to staff government agencies at sufficient levels to allow them to provide the service we believe we deserve.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoNot emailing back is a classic plausible deniability strategy. No one is asking for a response right now. Or even later today. Or even a week or even a month from now. But if the NJ government’s budget does not allow them to respond to a single email after multiple months, that is a sign of intentional negligence, or a failed state.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago... or a massively underfunded government, which is precisely what the policies of one of our two major political parties for the last 40 years (at least) have sought to create (they are quite open about this). But hey, maybe that fits under the "intentional negligence" category...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat would make sense on a federal level. But not in NJ which is solid Democrat, and definitely not with their among the highest in the nation taxes. Again, I am giving quite a bit of leeway. At 14 months with no response, that is not understaffing. That is deliberate sabotage by leaders to prevent people from getting benefits.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYou understand that even NJ taxes are low by comparsion with most western European nations, yes? And that even in those nations, people still find publically-facing government agencies frustrating to deal with? Still, I'm inclined to agree with you that some of what you describe in your 2nd para is likely happening too.
- joecool1029 5y agoI have a *fat* stack of false claims sent into my company in NJ, that the burden was left on me to dispute. Finally the state paid one of these fictitious claims out to someone I have never met in NYC. I contacted my legislators about the situation, tried to get investigators to work the case, contacted the courts who sympathized but were unable to provide assistance. it is impossible to get in contact with someone anywhere to combat fraud. I ended up having to rename the company and change the structure so I would not have to pay into unemployment in the future. Fast forward to COVID when we were requested to close for a few months and unemployment benefits were supposedly extended to freelancers, I filed for that time we were closed and it was stuck in pending status since April 2020. I am of the opinion that unemployment insurance as it is in my state is an outright scam and should be abolished (and replaced if need be). New York and Pennsylvania had some delays, but nothing like the shit NJ has been.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoThat sucks, I'm sorry to hear about that. For future reference, the best way to get a politician's attention is to get on FOX News and talk shit about their pet program. It's like how people post on HN when they can't get support from FAANG.
- joecool1029 5y agoI mean I threw the stack down in the my one assemblyman's office and spoke about it for over an hour to him in person, he was my neighbor in the same building I worked in. But being that he's of the party that's not in power in the state, there's very little he can do. I also requested that he co-sponsor one of the bills that greatly increases penalties for defrauding the system (it's currently pretty much a slap on the wrist). The vast majority of Americans are entirely unaware that most of the day-to-day laws and systems are implemented at state level (aside from griping about governor's office executive orders). There's one news network that reports on our state's government affairs and hardly anyone watches it. But everyone knows the second a federal politician does something.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y ago