11 ms·
Dawkins' Stupid People
- tikums 15y agoEven being really good at [insert profession], doesn't make you non-stupid in areas outside of your expertise. It's not mutually exclusive. E.g., one can be a brilliant orthopedist, but can still be considered really stupid when it comes to forming a coherent general world-view.
- 0x12 15y agoI think Dawkins was hoping for a different world during his lifetime and is losing patience with those that oppose the change. He's an extremely smart man, compared to him most of us really are stupid but that's not a reason to be judgmental about it, if anything that will just make things worse, for everybody. For people to lose their religion is a very difficult mental process it ties in with the ego at a very basic level (it has to, that's exactly how it has been set up). I know some pretty smart people that are deeply religious too and I've always found enough common ground in the 'smart' bits to to overlook the bits in the religion department. I'm pretty sure they think the same way of me (well, maybe except for the smarts ;) )...
- robhu 15y agoYes, Professor Alister McGrath (Oxford) has come to similar conclusions. Dawkins et al had an expectation that religion would be swept away within their lifetime, and as this has not been achieved he has moved on to be much more direct and blunt as if to try to force it to happen. McGrath writes about this in his book 'Why God Won't Go Away: Is the New Atheism Running on Empty?' http://www.amazon.com/Why-God-Wont-Go-Away/dp/084994645X http://www.amazon.com/Why-God-Wont-Go-Away/dp/084994645X Here is a review of the book to give you a flavour of what conclusions he reaches http://mcdanell99reviews.blogspot.com/2011/08/why-god-wont-go-away-by-alister-mcgrath.html http://mcdanell99reviews.blogspot.com/2011/08/why-god-wont-g...
- 0x12 15y agoThat review completely weirds me out. Atheism does not have it's roots in the 9/11 attacks, nor is it 'new' by any definition. Sure, Dawkins wrote 'The God Delusion' chronologically after 9/11. But that doesn't mean his views were much different before then, he's been an outspoken atheist pretty much all his life. As for the blatant attempt to tie all atheists to Nazism that's a first-order Godwinning right there. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11332515 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11332515 Ahteists are no more violent than religious people, I think they're people just like all the others, you can expect something of everything. I hope the book is better than that that review lets on.
- robhu 15y agoI don't see any claim that atheism has it's roots in the 9/11 attacks. The reviewer states "[The rise of the New Atheists] to fame, McGrath suggests, begins with the attacks on 9/11 where radical Muslims turned commercial airplanes into missiles and managed to kill almost 3,000 people." He is referring to the 'rise to fame' of New Atheism. New Atheism and atheism are not synonyms of one another, the former is a member of the set of the latter. McGrath doesn't tie all atheists to Nazism (as the review might himself be implying), but deals with how the basic arguments of the form "Religion is bad, look at all these religious leaders who have killed people" doesn't work very well for quite a lot of reasons including how it could easily be turned around. In any case - I McGrath is a well respected intellectual in the UK (Oxford, along with Cambridge is our most prestigious university), and his writing is well worth considering.
- 0x12 15y agoRegarding 'new atheism' as a movement, this is a pretty good read: http://www.secularhumanism.org/index.php?section=library&page=flynn_30_3 http://www.secularhumanism.org/index.php?section=library&... I think that reviewer used the book to push his own viewpoints at the expense of the author, and does him a dis-service.
- princeverma 15y agowhat else would you call them? them : "who doesn't see presented/available evidence and just think that no matter what, their beliefs are true." edit: Forgot to mention that, sometime these are the people who govern us, make law, treat us and in process of doing these things they try to enforce their belief OR have strong opposition towards anything which contradicts their belief.
- Tichy 15y agospiritually challenged?
- 0x12 15y agoThe ability to see presented/available evidence depends to some extent on your frame of reference and how much time you've spent believing something and how deeply that belief is ingrained in your psyche. Lots of scientists go to their graves defending pet theories in spite of lots of available evidence to the contrary. This behavior has more to do with how much of the ego is invested in something than the ability to see or evaluate evidence as such.
- princeverma 15y agoIn reply, i will just leave this quote from Carl Sagan: "In science it often happens that scientists say, 'You know that's a really good argument; my position is mistaken,' and then they would actually change their minds and you never hear that old view from them again. They really do it. It doesn't happen as often as it should, because scientists are human and change is sometimes painful. But it happens every day. I cannot recall the last time someting like that happened in politics or religion."
- 0x12 15y agoYes, and that is the way it is supposed to go. But here is another quote to illustrate the counterpart: "Die Wahrheit triumphiert nie, ihre Gegner sterben nur aus." Rough translation: The truth never triumphs, its opponents simply die out. That's by Max Planck.
- hbrouwer 15y agoI still find it intriguing that Francis Collins, who in 1993 replaced James D. Watson as head of the National Center for Human Genome Research at the National Institutes of Health, is a religious person [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Collins_(geneticist)#Religious_views http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Collins_(geneticist)#Re...] I'm not judging anyone here, I'm just saying I find it striking, and slightly unimaginable.
- billybob 15y agoCollins has written a book called "The Language of God" (referring to DNA) in which he explains how he reconciles his beliefs with his scientific understanding. In it, he tells his own story and explains why he thinks Christians should accept evolution and why scientists should not be hostile to faith.
- cycojesus 15y agoWeither the people in question truly are stupid or misguided wasn't the point of the question. I like how he answers about why he cares instead of mincing words.
- scotty79 15y agoIn this quote I don't see anything about religion. He was just asked if he's bothered by stupid people and he stated that he's bothered by how stupid people influence children. And even if the religion was implied by the original context then sure, Michael Faraday maybe was not stupid but his father might have been to some point and due this stupidity wasting his sons time.
- 0x12 15y agoI've got a problem with that viewpoint. I'm not sure if I'm able to articulate it properly but consider that without Michael Faraday's fathers religion his son might not have been born at all, and if he was he might have followed a different path in life, becoming a carpenter or some other mundane profession. You don't get to play the same universe twice over with different pieces with a claim to knowing how that universe would unfold. All this stuff is inter-related and if you change one thing you may change more than you think you do. Science and religion are to some extent in competition, both strive to explain things, the one through the supernatural, the other through reasoning and rigorous experiments. I know which side my bread is buttered on but I'd never stake a claim on editing the past and saying that 'x or y not being religious' would have been good for science or the opposite. That's something that would be very hard to prove.
- scotty79 15y agoI have not stated that if Faradays father was not religious it would improve science, only that it could. His father could be killed or ostracized for being atheist and that would definitely harm science.
- demallien 15y agoYou're setting up a strawman there jgrahamc. Dawkins does not equate religious to stupid. Anyone that has listened to him much at all is fully aware that what he was getting at here is those people that continue to indoctrinate children with rubbish like Intelligent Design/Creationism when they have been presented, repeatedly, with hard evidence for the reality of evolution and the fact that it does not require a guiding force. That willful ignorance is what he is appalled at, and quite frankly I don't know what else you can call someone that is willfully ignorant, if not stupid.
- jgrahamc 15y agoRight before that question from the interviewer Dawkins quoted a statistic that 40% of Americans think that Genesis is a true story and went on to say that 'they probably believe' that Lot's wife was turned into a pillar of salt. You may be right that he's only talking about creationists directly but I still think name calling isn't the way to go. It's a bit like calling someone with a mental impairment 'retarded'. Doesn't help.
- demallien 15y ago"Right before that question from the interviewer Dawkins quoted a statistic that 40% of Americans think that Genesis is a true story" And did he then go on to say that he considers those 40% to be stupid? Or is it more likely that he considers those 40% to be the unfortunate childhood victims of the 'stupid' people? I think you're reading your own prejudices into his statement.
- jgrahamc 15y agoThe next question immediately after that was the one that brought up the word stupid (as posted on my blog). You may be correct that I am influenced by my own prejudices. It wouldn't be the first time.
- dgunn 15y agoShould we call them rationally impaired? For Dawkins to continue with the conversation, there had to be a way to refer to the collective and the interviewer already used the word, "stupid". Why stop the discussion just to reassign the group to a new word? In the context of the interview, those people are considered to be stupid and for clarity, they should be called stupid. They may be smart in other areas, but their willingness to not see evidence makes them stupid in this particular arena.
- tspiteri 15y agoDawkins' treatment of religion seems to me to a bit shallow. He seems to argue far too much about how true religious dogma is or isn't, but that can only give a superficial treatment of religion. It might seem, especially to a scientist, that a religion is based on its core beliefs. But it is easy, especially for trained theologians, to get to whatever conclusion they want from some dogmatic starting point. Religion is not mathematics, where starting from an axiom will inevitably lead to a particular conclusion. So arguing about the untruth of the religious axioms is missing the point.
- tspiteri 15y agoFurther to this, I've found this excerpt from Richard Feynman's "Is Electricity Fire?" in Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!: And then one day—I guess it was a Saturday—I want to go up in the elevator, and there's a guy standing near the elevator. The elevator comes, I go in, and he goes in with me. I say, "Which floor?" and my hand's ready to push one of the buttons. "No, no!" he says, "I'm supposed to push the buttons for you." "What?" "Yes! The boys here can't push the buttons on Saturday, so I have to do it for them. You see, I'm not Jewish, so it's all right for me to push the buttons. I stand near the elevator, and they tell me what floor, and I push the button for them." Well, this really bothered me, so I decided to trap the students in a logical discussion. I had been brought up in a Jewish home, so I knew the kind of nitpicking logic to use, and I thought, "Here's fun!" My plan went like this: I'd start off by asking, "Is the Jewish viewpoint a viewpoint that any man can have? Because if it is not, then it's certainly not something that is truly valuable for humanity... yak, yak, yak." And then they would have to say, "Yes, the Jewish viewpoint is good for any man." Then I would steer them around a little more by asking, "Is it ethical for a man to hire another man to do something which is unethical for him to do? Would you hire a man to rob for you, for instance?" And I keep working them into the channel, very slowly, and very carefully until I've got them—trapped! And do you know what happened? They're rabbinical students, right? They were ten times better than I was! As soon as they saw I could put them in a hole, they went twist, turn, twist—I can't remember how—and they were free! I thought I had come up with an original idea—phooey! It had been discussed in the Talmud for ages! So they cleaned me up just as easy as pie—they got right out.
- mckoss 15y agoWhat do you call someone who continues to believe a falsehood in the face of all evidence, reason and logic? "Stupid" seems pretty spot on to me.
- halostatue 15y agoWillfully ignorant. I understand both points here: JGC is correct that stupid is the wrong word for what Dawkins is talking about. Dawkins believes that there are a class of people who have shown themselves to be incorrigibly ignorant. Someone who is stupid would be incapable of learning the facts involved. They should not be treated with disdain; it's not their fault. Someone who is ignorant, doesn't know the facts involved. They should also not be treated with disdain; they don't know any better. Someone who, despite repeated exposure to factual, repeatable knowledge chooses to remain ignorant… that's who Dawkins is disdainful of, and I don't blame him. And while I happen to agree with his view on the willful ignorance of Creationists, it is important to note that those selfsame folks would consider him willfully ignorant of the glorious truth of their god. Ideally, Dawkins would leave out the name-calling altogether, but it's an awfully convenient shorthand to say that someone who is willfully and incorrigibly ignorant is, in fact, stupid. It just happens to be unnecessarily inflammatory and too much of a shortcut.
- etherael 15y agoThe part this article is criticising him for is a little out of context; I care that people are being misled by those stupid people, because I think children deserve to know what is true and wonderful about the world into which they have been born, and it really is a shame that they are denied that; by ignorant and stupid adults, as you've described them. The last part does hedge a little on if he would originally have actually chosen that definition. And still, it is certainly not an indefensible position to say that religious beliefs are quite stupid.
- getonit 15y agoHaving never questioned an indoctrination, religious or otherwise, is naive at best - stupid is a perfectly reasonable description, IMHO.
- shpoonj 15y agoThis is just further proof that any know it all can set up a blog, throw out logic, state a poorly formed opinion, and someone will jump on their band wagon.
- michael_dorfman 15y agoI'd add Knuth to the list of "very smart, and yet religious" people.
- hobbes 15y agoAdd also Larry Wall. "Perl [is] a biblical reference to the "pearl of great price" (Matthew 13:46)." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Wall#Accomplishments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Wall#Accomplishments
- jorangreef 15y agoAnd also Thomas Bayes. "an English mathematician and Presbyterian minister, known for having formulated a specific case of the theorem that bears his name: Bayes' theorem." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bayes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bayes
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoBayes lived in the 18th Century - pretty much everyone believed back then and it wasn't such an irrational view as the likes of DNA, cosmology, geology weren't as advanced.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sigzero 15y agoThere is a huge preponderance of "religious" people that have made great scientific discoveries. Dawkins' argument is the same as everyone else who doesn't believe in "God". So what? Dawkins is free to believe in what he wants as is everyone else.
- billybob 15y agoThis may be a bit of a tangent, but personally, I can't understand Dawkins' crusading attitude about religion. If I believed, as he does, that there is no God, that all wonder and amazement and desire and love are merely chemical reactions, and that all consciousness will die with the universe, I wouldn't bother trying to convince others of it. "You should believe this because it eliminates all meaning and purpose in life." Hey, great sell! I think I'd just eat, drink, and be merry before I died. Who cares what others believe? If you're a Christian (as I am), you believe you've got good news to tell others. If you're an atheist, what's good about your news, and what difference does it make to tell anyone?
- loumf 15y agoYour good news is that atheists are going to burn in hell for eternity. My beliefs don't eliminate all meaning and purpose in my life -- that's just silly to think about atheists. I am trying to make a difference with my life, not because I expect some reward in the afterlife, but because of personal drive to make the world better. When I see a person suffering, I don't think, "It's ok, because when they die, God will take care of them" -- I think: "Holy shit, we need to do something about this right now!"
- 3pt14159 15y agoBecause Atheism is not a lack of ethics. My dad is an atheist and I'm a Christian but we're both concerned with the truth. Many atheists grew up in homes where the parents enforced a very strick household so they are trying to end what they see as a form of oppression. Either way, I wish these types of discussions would stay off HN.
- MrScruff 15y agoIf you're a Christian (as I am), you believe you've got good news to tell others. If you're an atheist, what's good about your news, and what difference does it make to tell anyone? The reason you think that is because you're only capable of seeing the world from your own perspective (as with anyone). I'm not religious, and I've always found the universe a thing of great wonder. Nothing would interest me more than a better understanding of the nature of reality and conciousness. However, I find the answers given by religion unsatisfying and arbitrary - hardly good news. Also, it's very well established that the driving force behind wonder, amazement, desire, love and pain are merely chemical reactions. It's only the subjective experience of those sensations (conciousness itself) that is not well understood.
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoI share most of Dawkin's beliefs on religion but abhor the way he chooses to communicate them. I'm not sure if it's hit the US but in the UK we have a thing called the Alpha Course. It's a Christian run 10 week course that discussed the "meaning of life" with a slightly (but only very slightly) covert agenda of converting the attendees to Christianity. My experience (anecdotal) of Alpha is that it does a good job of bringing lapsed Christian's back into the fold - that is people who basically accepted it but weren't practising. For anyone else - those of other faiths, atheists and so on, it doesn't seem to do much. There will be exceptions but that seems to be the general pattern. I see Dawkins as generally the same for atheists. I doubt very much he has any sort of major influence on Christians (other than to annoy them), he just gives atheists and agnostics a cheer leader and helps them confirm what they're thinking. Nothing wrong with that of course but he's not engaging in any way that's going to bring about the death of religion which is what he'd seem to like.
- loumf 15y agoThis is absolutely right. For any movement, there are those that take an uncompromising extreme view. This is not to appeal to the other side, but to move the goal posts as far in their direction as possible. Think Stallman, Nader, Ron Paul. They serve a purpose to the movement -- providing arguments that can be crafted by those that seek to convert and making others seem less extreme by comparison. One attribute that they must have to perform this effectively is to never compromise, and instead to keep pushing the envelope.
- ugh 15y agoMeh. Dawkins is harmless and says very docile stuff all the time. I honestly don’t understand people who are offended by him. Really?!
- Tichy 15y agoI'd argue that religious people chose to not think things through but simply rely on other authorities, and that is stupid behavior. Also, does stupid mean "genetically hardwired to low intelligence", or can stupid people be made more intelligent somehow?
- jorangreef 15y agoThere's something rational about looking at historical events and asking if it's unlikely, likely, or strongly likely that they happened at all. For example, I have heard of a handful of Germans today who for one reason or another say the Holocaust never happened. In light of the thousands of eye witness accounts, is it sensible to say that? Another example, there are atheists today who for one reason or another say the Resurrection never happened, and not necessarily because they have ever looked into the historical primary and secondary sources. In light of the hundreds of people who died at Roman hands in the 1st century, refusing to recant that they had seen the risen Lord, is it sensible to label their testimony a delusion, or inherited from their parents, without any thorough investigation at all? As for those who had seen Christ themselves: "I passed on to you what was most important and what had also been passed on to me. Christ died for our sins, just as the Scriptures said. He was buried, and he was raised from the dead on the third day, just as the Scriptures said. He was seen by Peter and then by the Twelve. After that, he was seen by more than 500 of his followers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have died. Then he was seen by James and later by all the apostles. Last of all, as though I had been born at the wrong time, I also saw him. For I am the least of all the apostles. In fact, I'm not even worthy to be called an apostle after the way I persecuted God's church." "And if Christ has not been raised, our preaching is useless and so is your faith. More than that, we are then found to be false witnesses about God, for we have testified about God that he raised Christ from the dead." "But Christ has indeed been raised from the dead, the first-fruits of those who have fallen asleep." Are the New Testament sources primary, accurate, unbiased, trustworthy? When were they written? Have they been corrupted or do we read them as they wrote them? How many sources are there inside and outside of the New Testament? Are they independent? Are they coherent? Here are some people who have tried to address these questions: Paul Barnett, "Is the New Testament history?" (http://www.amazon.com/New-Testament-History-Paul-Barnett/dp/0892833815 http://www.amazon.com/New-Testament-History-Paul-Barnett/dp/...) FF Bruce, "New Testament Documents" (http://www.amazon.com/New-Testament-Documents-They-Reliable/dp/0802822193/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1316091359&sr=1-1 http://www.amazon.com/New-Testament-Documents-They-Reliable/...)
- coward_anon 15y ago"In light of the thousands of eye witness accounts, is it sensible to say that?" Well, this is funny, because here's the issue on which Dawkins fails completely to apply the principles he advocates we all should. Incidentally, so do you. You claim thousands of eye witness accounts. Well, how many of those have been independently verified? Furthermore, even the highly know and regarded ones are ridden with inconsistencies and outright lies (I'm thinking Elie Wiesel here). And even if they were there remains the point that no hard proof whatsoever has been produced to support the claim that the Holocaust as is told today ever happened. No documents exist that don't require a double interpretation to support such claim. No gas chambers that differ any bit from standard delousing chambers used at the time, even in the US, have ever been uncovered. This could go on. I'm not trying to advocate for one version or the other. That's not the point. The point is, that this issue is NEVER applied the same principles that are applied to a rational inquiry or scientific endeavour or even a case being judged in a court of law. If you don't believe me, well, go and check by yourself. But don't just limit yourself to the Yad Vashem because that's the same as reading the Bible and saying it proves itself (although there are plenty of inconsistencies in the Yad Vashem data curiously). I admire Dawkins and his work, but the truth is, in the issue of the Holocaust he's as stupid as the people he accuses of being stupid. Even worse, I bet he would viciously defend his stupidity against anyone who would challenge him otherwise.
- MrScruff 15y agoIgnoring Dawkins for a moment, I think those here naming Christian scientists as examples of how science and religion are compatible are missing the point. Science isn't about the people who practice it and it's not about beliefs. It's about the scientific method - theory tested by and derived from repeatable experimentation. And there are no Christian scientists who apply the scientific method to their own religious beliefs, for obvious reasons.
- robhu 15y agoTrue, but surely the reason is not that there are no religious believers who have applied rational processes to the question of whether there is a God (or gods) and have concluded that there is - but rather that the scientific method is a method that is only suitable in certain domains. It's easy to equate 'the scientific method' with any sort of 'rational' evidence based approach, but the term has a specific meaning. We don't apply the scientific method to solve murder investigations for instance, or to solve math equations. Similarly historians don't use the scientific method to determine what happened in history. It's not that the choices are the scientific method or ignorance -- it's that the scientific method is not applicable in many of the domains that intellectual religious people have mined to conclude that theism is more likely than atheism. Many Christians point to the historical evidence for Jesus for instance, see (former Prof) Richard Bauchman's 'Jesus and the eyewitnesses' http://www.amazon.com/Jesus-Eyewitnesses-Gospels-Eyewitness-Testimony/dp/0802831621 http://www.amazon.com/Jesus-Eyewitnesses-Gospels-Eyewitness-... or Prof Licona's http://www.amazon.com/Resurrection-Jesus-New-Historiographical-Approach/dp/0830827196 http://www.amazon.com/Resurrection-Jesus-New-Historiographic... 'The resurrection of Jesus - a new historiographical approach' or they have considered philosophical arguments (see what Alvin Plantinga has written for example). This is not to argue that science and religion are Non-Overlapping MagesteriA (NOMA) as Gould argued, clearly there are overlaps (whether the first humans came in to existence along with the universe 6,000 years ago is a pretty clear example of overlap), but many of the arguments intellectual theists give for thinking theism is more likely are rational, just not scientific.
- brlewis 15y agoMeta comment: This post must be getting flagged a lot. 114. Dawkins' Stupid People (jgc.org) 34 points by jgrahamc 3 hours ago | flag | 76 comments I also note that the comments are full of civil and intelligent discussion. I wonder to what extent the flagging helped it stay that way by keeping it off the front page.