2 ms·
I was focused on responding to what I perceived to be the core of your argument, and that got lost by the wayside. To me, the core of the argument continues wit
by mindslight 5y ago
I was focused on responding to what I perceived to be the core of your argument, and that got lost by the wayside. To me, the core of the argument continues with my Condorcet point.
Specifically about this point, I disagree. You're greatly exaggerating the intrinsic difficulty of change - witness any "emergency" bill that gets passed after a few months with very little debate. I agree there are bureaucratic difficulties in general, but when discussing how well representatives represent the will of the voters, the inefficiency due to those difficulties are still quite relevant! The argument you're making basically lets you write off any outside metrics that aren't the ballot box - deferring to the opaque paternalism of "that's just how the system works" and shutting down any criticism of the representative bureaucracy itself.
Furthermore on the topic of marijuana deillegalization, most of those bureaucratic difficulties simply do not exist. No legal regime needs to be pondered and crafted, rather the laws that criminalized it in the first place simply need to be repealed - strike them by number and name. That we're likely to end up with more complex legislation rather than a straightforward repeal is entirely due to the corruption of the system where all of these incumbent moneyed interests get their says before the will of the voters can become law. That corruption is exactly what you're defending by rejecting basic objective critiques of the system's effectiveness.
- TameAntelope 5y ago“Why don't you just” has plagued the software industry for decades, and now you try to use it on legislation. It’s funny, how misdeeds can transcend profession. If you can’t accept that passing national legislation is an incredibly complex, subtle, and nuanced activity that requires delicacy and care, then I simply cannot help you.