2 ms·
> Arguing that an idea is wrong because it "lends support to scientific racism" is unscientific. Since racism is itself not a scientific concept, arguments abo
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> Arguing that an idea is wrong because it "lends support to scientific racism" is unscientific.
Since racism is itself not a scientific concept, arguments about this sort of thing are inherently never going to be scientific, but rather always political/philosophical. There's absolutely nothing wrong with Gould, Lewontin (or Wilson) engaging in such debates, which are as at least as important (and possibly more directly impactful) than the scientific ones.
Political/philosophical debates do not involve questions of demonstrable "right" or "wrong", but rather are a stage for beliefs about the world and different notions of utility. You don't settle them by "demonstrating why it's wrong", or by "offering a better idea".
- slibhb 5y agoI agree with you. But if this isn't a scientific debate, why would it matter that Gould et al are "distinguished scientists at Harvard"? Shouldn't they separate their political-philosophical-religious views from their work as scientists? It isn't fruitful when one side is arguing science and the other is arguing politics.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoBeing able to state with some level of authority that current science does or does not support some claim can be useful even in the context of a non-scientific debate.