7 ms·
The comparison to diabetes has one major flaw. You either have or don't have diabetes and the fact that you are tested for it does not change your diabetes stat
by inglor_cz 5y ago
The comparison to diabetes has one major flaw. You either have or don't have diabetes and the fact that you are tested for it does not change your diabetes status. You can only measure it, but your measurement won't alter the situation.
But by constantly reminding people of their racial category, a feedback loop is created. The more are people defined by their race, the more important will they consider their racial category. They will also start viewing more interactions through the race angle, especially the negative ones. Not "the policeman was rude because he is an asshole", but "the policeman was rude because I am of a different race from him".
I cannot imagine a scenario where constant race consciousness leads to people being less concerned about anything that can be construed as racially charged.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe goal is, indeed, to make people more concerned about things that can be construed as racially charged, because of the first step to addressing inequity is to identify it. There are very many people who see what are obvious instances of structural racism (including the police interaction example you highlighted) and will fight tooth and claw to assert that no racism was involved. The result is apathy, lack of improvement, and continued racially-charged interactions between police and citizens. Pretending they aren't racially charged doesn't make them go away. Before positive changes can be made, people need to recognize that do-nothing mindset is very common. On this, two days after Martin Luther King Jr Day, it may be value for us all to reflect on his words on the difference between the peace of the absence of tension and the peace of the presence of justice.
- nescioquid 5y agoIdentity is a wedge used to split class solidarity (but note the terrific solidarity of the elite class). The best improvements for everyone will come from policies which ignore identity and materially improve the lives of people. The Democratic party has held the belief that demographics will keep them in power without having to actually address economic and legal inequalities, that is, without having to do anything at all. But the middle and lower classes will never find solidarity amongst themselves so long as we are fixated on identity, and nothing will change (that's the point).
- Kye 5y agoFunny thing: the DNC agrees with you, at least right up until an identity has sufficient popular support. I already expounded way more than was worth the effort on here recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29981488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29981488 As someone on the boot-end of people who chant "no politics maaaaan, just vibin', peace and love with no ideology" to distract from the boot, I vehemently disagree.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Identity is a wedge used to split class solidarity (but note the terrific solidarity of the elite class). It's not, inherently, though it can be used that way, which is the essence of bourgeois identity politics, which is a distinct subset of identity politics. > The best improvements for everyone will come from policies which ignore identity and materially improve the lives of people. Identity is often intimately tied to distinct material circumstances; policies that “ignore identity and materially improves the loves of people”, without exception, ignore the distinct material circumstances of identifiable groups of people while improving the material circumstances of other groups of people, and invariably do so in ways which favor the groups most privileged by visibility in the status quo. > The Democratic party has held the belief that demographics will keep them in power without having to actually address economic and legal inequalities That's very much not true of either of the major factions of the Democratic Party. The dominant neoliberal centrist faction actively doesn't want to deal with the economic inequalities more than is necessary to smooth out social disruptions interfering with corporate capitalist profit making (though it does want to deal with legal inequalities that impede efficient exploitation of human potential by capital), to the point of being willing to have the party lose power rather than doing more than is necessary to that end, whereas the progressive populist wing actively wants to deal with the problems. And neither faction is so ignorant of the political realities of the US system to expect that the party is secure in it's (extremely narrow) federal legislative majority or control of the White House.
- nescioquid 5y ago> Identity is often intimately tied to distinct material circumstances Not so fast. Au courant are stories around data disaggregation, highlighting that Asian Americans in NYC have the highest poverty rate (also noted is the way this runs counter to popular perceptions). But rather than splitting up the populace in increasingly finer-grained ways, why don't we just do something to address the poverty in our society? To wit, yes we agree the DNC does want to do anything about poverty or economic inequalities in general. They are happy to stage photo ops while draped in kente cloth but they will never do anything to improve the material circumstances of the lower classes. > The Democratic party has held the belief that demographics will keep them in power without having to actually address economic and legal inequalities >> That's very much not true of either of the major factions of the Democratic Party. You mean the neoliberal and conservative wings of the Democratic party? I assume "the squad" knows how to use political power as well as Manchin, but the fact that they don't indicates they, too, simply use identity as a means to the ends of the donor class.
- pnutjam 5y agoI hardly think a once a decade census is "constantly reminding people of their racial catagory". From my experience, it would be the rascists doing the constant reminding, and not just the cross burning kinds. I've met all kinds of rascists. Every one of my very white looking kids has fielded questions about that dark hispanic guy hanging around, or knocking on the door to pick them up. They've also been privy to rascist discussion that they've later shared with me, since people don't see them as non-white. Heck, I didn't see myself as non-white until I moved to a rural school in the early 90's.