4 ms·
> On one hand we have scientists that are probing the nature of reality and on the other we have politically opportune believers slash do-gooders, This false d
by acdha 5y ago
> On one hand we have scientists that are probing the nature of reality and on the other we have politically opportune believers slash do-gooders,
This false dichotomy is key to the false comparisons with Lysenkoism, etc. E. O. Wilson did not represent all scientists even during his working career and many of the people criticizing him are also scientists using their scientific expertise. The author of the Scientific American piece is “an associate professor in the Family Health Care Nursing Department and a clinician-scientist at Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health at the University of California, San Francisco.” — hardly a political apparatchik. Some of the most outspoken criticisms of his work came from Richard C. Lewontin (a population geneticist) and Stephen Jay Gould (a paleontologist).
Similarly, Razib Khan is someone who is at least comfortable using his expertise in forums which do not shy away from race politics — for example, he lost a contract writing for The New York Times when his regular contributions to Taki's Magazine, a very conservative venue which was at least neo-Nazi-adjacent (Richard Spencer was the managing editor). That doesn't mean that we should dismiss Khan's writing entirely but we should recognize that he's a human rather than the objective voice of science and his work also needs to be read with an understanding of how his political positions influence it.
- naasking 5y ago> The author of the Scientific American piece is “an associate professor in the Family Health Care Nursing Department and a clinician-scientist at Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health at the University of California, San Francisco.” — hardly a political apparatchik. Hardly Wilson's peer either, and the article shows this quite clearly. > Some of the most outspoken criticisms of his work came from Richard C. Lewontin (a population geneticist) and Stephen Jay Gould (a paleontologist). Yes, criticisms of the substance and inferences like any good scientist would focus on, not thinly veiled accusations of racism.
- acdha 5y ago> Hardly Wilson's peer either, and the article shows this quite clearly. Whether you find her politically correct isn’t relevant to the topic at hand: she’s clearly qualified to participate in a scientific discussion.
- naasking 5y agoMy point has nothing to do with political correctness. My point was that she does not in fact have the qualifications to critique Wilson's work.
- jmmcd 5y ago> she’s clearly qualified to participate in a scientific discussion No, her remarks about the normal distribution disqualified her from all scientific discussion.
- mbg721 5y agoNothing "disqualifies you from all scientific discussion"; ideas that are provably wrong get tossed out, and if you think she's going to be such a frequent source of provably wrong ideas as to derail the discussion, then say so.
- jmmcd 5y agoShe's not proposing a falsiable hypothesis here which can compete in the marketplace of ideas. We're talking about the normal distribution. If she doesn't know what it is, that casts doubt on her understanding of all the other basics she learned during her undergrad and PhD. If (more likely) she does and she's just being dishonest, that casts doubt on everything she says for a different reason.
- acdha 5y agoHow? Did you read the paper she linked to and understand why she referenced it? https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.675788/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.6757... (and, for that matter, did you notice the clever way in which Razib said it was nonsense but didn't directly address or show any signs of understanding the argument? He was hoping that you'd have a good sense of righteous indignation and roll right past that without pausing to ask whether things like human cognition might not be as simple as the length of a cucumber.)
- 5y ago
- VictorPath 5y ago> Hardly Wilson's peer either Wilson's peers were people who studied ants and other insects, or maybe people who write popular science. If he wants to jump into his views of the human brain, she is as much a peer as he is.