15 ms·
Craig Wright suing developers to forcibly give him access to internet coins
- ddtaylor 5y ago"Faketoshi" as he's known in the community always finds a new way to NOT be able to prove he has access to the early mined coins. It's honestly comical at this point the different bullshit he comes up with. My favorite so far was finding an existing signature on the blockchain from Satoshi, modifying the data, then publishing the signature with different data in an attempt to claim to be the creator of Bitcoin. Everyone called him out on his bullshit and a few months later he came up with a new scam, which is exactly what he'll do after this attempt fails. Craig Wright will never sign a message with the original private keys or move the coins in a way that proves his involvement or ownership of the first mined coins. He is a fraud.
- me_me_me 5y agoI AM THE KING! Why does everyone keep ignoring me and my orders? What is sad is that anyone is even talking about this guy. From the beginning people pointed out he is lying and yet he is still somehow able to be talk about. Most obvious con-man that is still able to stay in public spotlight.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agohow does this con-man make money off his cons though?
- gerikson 5y agoHe's got a direct line to Calvin Ayre's money.
- Nextgrid 5y agoHe's a household name in the crypto world. Sure, not in a good way, but any publicity is good publicity right? He could offer his services to various blockchain-focused startups in which he'll fit right in considering said startups' objective is often to get money off clueless VCs by throwing the "blockchain" buzzword around (there are very little legitimate use-cases for a blockchain that can't be served by a traditional database, and a truly decentralized blockchain can't easily be monetized to the level a VC would want).
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoThe people in Bitcoin that don’t understand public/private key cryptography. That is who Faketoshi leads.
- nullc 5y agoHe has a bad habit of suing former business partners that don't do exactly what he wants. E.g. he's currently suing the second and third person from the left in this photo https://i.redd.it/ph8slk43st331.jpg https://i.redd.it/ph8slk43st331.jpg and the person on the right is the rube that is financing most of Wright's litigation.
- xyzzy123 5y agoHe's a temporarily embarrassed billionaire, he just needs some funds to access his rightful fortune. You don't even have to believe him - you'd just have to believe (or see viable risk/reward) that he has a shot at a successful legal attack.
- nullc 5y agoExactly. Wright claims to own around $50 billion dollars worth of cryptocurrency which he cannot access. Let's say he manages to convince you that he has 1% chance of success at obtaining these funds-- something you could believe even if you know he's a fraud, you just have to have a low opinion of the courts and misunderstand how Bitcoin works (which many people do, see this discussion!). If offers you a 10% stake in his victory, what would you pay for that? Well under the 1% assumption you might be willing to pay $25 million dollars (half the expected value). The buyers error is just in flawed reasoning about the odds of success, but people are notoriously bad at reasoning about fringe events and a lot of people don't understand Bitcoin. For Wright, the fact that his effort cannot be successful is actually a very good property: It means that he can safely sell more than 100% of his fictional fortune: He doesn't have to worry that he'll win and then have to pay out >100%. Instead, he'll lose and tell his investors "Sorry, gave it our best shot but you always knew this was a risky deal!". In that case his income from the scheme is only limited by how many suckers he can bring in... 100 people paying 25m for a '10%' stake would yield a 2.5 billion dollar windfall. And if you don't think there are at least 100 suckers out there with 25 million to blow you haven't been paying attention to all the defi/ico/nft noise the last couple years. Right now we know of one major self-claimed billionaire that Wright is exploiting, but there may be many others-- particularly in Asia where language barriers make it much easier for Wright to isolate victims from discrediting information.
- vintermann 5y agoThere are a lot of scams which start off with step 1: "Convince people that you have a lot of money".
- ASalazarMX 5y agoStrong "Norton I, Emperor of the United States and Protector of Mexico" vibes.
- tim333 5y agoHe's launched a lot of legal actions in recent times that make him hard to ignore.
- democracy 5y agoBecause noone in the real world know or cares about him. In the land of clowns...
- jes 5y agoWhat if Craig Wright is suffering from mental health problems similar to those that affected Terry Davis, the author of Temple OS? I understand the Craig Wright is violating the norms of public behavior. I think it would be more charitable to not assume that he’s necessarily in his right mind.
- wand3r 5y agoUhhh, wut? Terry built templeOS and spent years working on the project. No one questioned the authenticity of that project and anyone familiar with him or his illness would likely not compare him to Craig Wright. This analogy really falls flat and makes no sense.
- nathias 5y agoDavis had schizophrenia, Wright is a pathological liar, very different diseases, both sadly incurable
- tata71 5y agoWhat if he knew the creator(s) of Bitcoin, and is upset that a dead person had more impact on the world than he believes he ever will?
- Moodles 5y agoHere’s a video of Craig Wright being called out by an actual expert and it’s hilarious https://youtu.be/0thnCDgRJfM https://youtu.be/0thnCDgRJfM. He clearly has no clue how ECDSA signatures work.
- m348e912 5y agoDoes anyone find the other guys claim more interesting? That you can derive private keys after just one transaction.
- aqme28 5y ago(edit: ignore me) Yeah that sounds like he mis-spoke. You can't get the private key from a signature, or the protocol is broken. Edit: I see. It's confusingly worded but that makes sense.
- drexlspivey 5y agoYou can recover a private key from two signatures if they reuse the same nonce. The nonce should be random and only used once as the name suggests
- marcan_42 5y agoAnd this is one of the reasons why ECDSA is a poor standard: it's too easy to accidentally screw it up, and it results in the worst possible kind of compromise (private key). There is a better way: make the nonce a hash of the message signature and the private key. That way you don't need any randomness, and the entire algorithm is deterministic. It is guaranteed (assuming the hash is good, but you need a good hash algorithm to sign things anyway) that no two messages will be signed with the same nonce, and that the nonce cannot be guessed without already having the private key. This is what EdDSA does.
- drexlspivey 5y agoMost modern wallets nowdays use deterministic nonces via RFC 6979. The newly introduced Schnorr signatures also do not have this weakness afaik.
- mellosouls 5y agoMy own preferred theory as a layman is that Wright is Satoshi and has lost the keys.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoOkay? I came up with a theory of ham sandwiches, but I’m no chef. (Thousand island dressing is an underrated addition to almost any sandwich.) There’s nothing to indicate he’s who he claims to be.
- ddtaylor 5y agoOkay, then why can't he login to any of the accounts that Satoshi used originally in 2009? Mailing list accounts, email accounts, etc.
- colejohnson66 5y agoIIRC, his supposed reason is forgotten passwords. Not a great excuse, but also one that could plausibly happen.
- lawn 5y agoOne of the addresses he claims to own has signed a message saying it's not his though...
- tim333 5y agoAnd when, presumably the real Satoshi, did so in 2014. (https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2014/03/06/bitcoin-creator-returns-to-internet-to-say-i-am-not-dorian-nakamoto/?sh=21df65a876bb https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2014/03/06/bitcoin-...)
- nullc 5y agoThen you haven't been paying attention. Wright is continually spouting literal gibberish and technobabble, he's technical inept to the point of hilarity. For example, when asked to explain some C code he claimed that the line declaring a double-type variable were doubling the values. Beyond his ineptitude, Wright has repeatedly claimed he would provide proof, but then when his 'proof' is exposed to expert analysis it turns out to be a provable forgery. Not just once, but over and over again. Forged emails, forged pgp keys, forged digital signatures, forged invoices, forged whitepaper drafts. Not merely falsifiable but actually falsified. It's certantly possible that Satoshi lost whatever keys he had-- but if so he isn't saying anything about it. The idea that Satoshi would lose keys and then make a clown out of himself is just not parsimonious. What is parsimonious is that we know for a fact that Wright has been selling his "fortune" to suckers for a number of years now-- the setup of a classic Nigerian scam: I am a prince in exile but with a small advance from you I can access a vast fortune which I will gladly share with you. At first his excuse was that he couldn't touch the coins without risking the AU government seizing them (due to stealing millions from AU with fraudulent rebates), then his excuse was that the coins were secured by a "bonded courier" (think of the end of Back to the Future 2) and wouldn't be delivered until Jan 2020, and most recently he claims that in Feb 2020 hackers entered his home and hid a 'wifi pineapple' to penetrate his network and steal his coins (of course, the coins haven't moved on the blockchain)...
- sharperguy 5y agoMany media publications really helped him by posting articles about how he "admits" to being Satoshi and has a "very similar email address".
- nullc 5y agoMore recently Wright & co have been paying for a lot of coverage that essentially regurgitates his press releases. The effect is that the reporting is becoming worse. Two years ago it was common for articles to mention that Wright's supposed proof was completely discredited. Today it's common for articles to say that Wright's claims haven't been "conclusively proved yet". There is a big difference between saying that it isn't yet totally conclusive and saying that he tried to provide proof but it was proven to be a fraud! Unfortunately, Wright has shown that he's willing to use SLAPP lawsuits against parties that criticizes him, including journalists. So you have to have deep pockets and a huge tolerance for nonsense to risk publishing something truly critical -- at least if you have enough visibility that he'll care.
- smoyer 5y agoIt's time I finally admit my past to the world - I'm Satoshi Nakamoto. AMA.
- adenner 5y agoI am Spartacus, er Satoshi...
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoThe We Are All Satoshi movement is a real thing :).
- ASalazarMX 5y agoWe are all Satoshi (but without the bitcoins).
- antihero 5y agoHonestly I think it would be quite funny if he wins and developers have to rewrite part of the protocol to give a specific guy money. Would really highlight who's really in control.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoIt would be funny but it is physically impossible for all the reasons that make Bitcoin desirable.
- ASalazarMX 5y ago> physically impossible You mean ethically questionable? Because it is not impossible.
- nullc 5y agoIt's analogous to suing someone who makes gold jewelry to try to force them to get everyone else to start referring to lead as "gold" and paying gold prices for it.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoThat would be if he was asking for Bitcoin silver to take over Bitcoin. This is like someone asking the bank to give him someone else's massive but abandoned account, if more than half of its clients agree.
- nullc 5y ago> This is like someone asking the bank to give him someone else's massive but abandoned account, if more than half of its clients agree. That isn't how Bitcoin works, however. The protocol is enforced autonomously by each participant all on their own. The only voting like property in Bitcoin is the consensus used to decide the order of transactions in order to reject double-spends. Wright doesn't want to change the order of transactions-- the coins he's attempting to steal haven't moved since 2011. If someone creates a transactions that spends some coins without the required signantures it'll just be ignored by all participants. If some participants adopt backdoored software that allow bypassing the authentication they'll just be ignored by everyone else, it doesn't matter how many do-- all automatically. Even if everyone else adopts that backdoor your own computer will just ignore them and continue the Bitcoin network with other non-backdoored participants. So inherently what he seeks is to replace Bitcoin with an incompatible alternative. The only way that's possible is if people choose to adopt the alternative, call it bitcoin, trade it for bitcoin-prices, etc. He's attempted it already too, he created Bitcoin Satoshi Vision-- his fork that is distributed under a proprietary software license. His conspirators and their victims go around telling people that it's the real bitcoin and that Bitcoin is an imposter. This has been mostly unsuccessful.
- 300bps 5y agoMy favorite was him posting the fake signing and then when he was called out on it he posted a "Goodbye to the world" style message on his blog after taking it down. May 2nd, 2016: https://web.archive.org/web/20160502071722/http://www.drcraigwright.net/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160502071722/http://www.drcrai... May 7th, 2016: https://web.archive.org/web/20160507165900/http://www.drcraigwright.net/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160507165900/http://www.drcrai... If he really were Satoshi, he could literally prove it in 4 seconds beyond any shadow of a doubt. Instead he obfuscates with things like Tulip Trusts that can't be touched until January 1, 2020 and then that date comes and goes (over 2 years ago now!) and nothing happens. https://coingeek.com/what-is-the-tulip-trust/ https://coingeek.com/what-is-the-tulip-trust/ Accused of forgery and perjury by at least one Judge: https://cointelegraph.com/news/judge-slams-craig-wright-for-forged-documents-and-perjured-testimony https://cointelegraph.com/news/judge-slams-craig-wright-for-... And then in 2017 he got the bright idea to start filing patent after patent on anything to do with Blockchain. Why did he wait 8 years after he "invented" it? https://patents.justia.com/inventor/craig-steven-wright https://patents.justia.com/inventor/craig-steven-wright There are like a hundred patents there from 2017 and after! And he has two doctorate degrees (one in Theology!) with two more on the way and a dozen other degrees and certifications. The man is a wonder!
- democracy 5y agoI remember there were records of his blog where he was "downloading java courses on security" at the time when bitcoin was being developed by Satoshi )))
- nathias 5y agoHe would be better off spending his millions on the psychological help he clearly needs.
- Nextgrid 5y agoDoes he have millions though? I'd assume someone who has millions could live a comfortable life away from the spotlight instead of trying to perpetuate an easily-debunked fraud.
- FireBeyond 5y agoIf he had millions, he wouldn't have lost a security order (where the judge believes that you don't have sufficient assets to cover the other side's legal costs if you lose, you have to give the court security over some assets/funds to hold in escrow).
- astoor 5y ago"They've all refused Wright's demands, though a firm called nChain Ltd is 'said to be working on a modification to the existing BSV client software, which would enable someone who owns but cannot access the BSV to regain control of them.'" Note that Craig Wright is the Chief Science Officer of nChain[0]. It seems cryptocurrency enthusiasts love irreversible transactions until they have one of their own transactions they want reversed, although if you're high enough up the pyramid you can get yourself sorted, e.g. by rewriting the client software (as in this case) or by forking the blockchain (as per Butlerin and The DAO[1]). [0] https://nchain.com/about/ https://nchain.com/about/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_DAO_(organization) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_DAO_(organization)
- sebzim4500 5y agoIn this case though the problem isn't irreversible transactions, it is that Craig Wright does not and has never owned the coins he claims to have owned.
- astoor 5y agoJust to clarify, the article is about the court case where he wants some transactions on the Bitcoin SV blockchain reversed. The question relating to whether he is Satoshi, and therefore owns Satoshi's 1.1M Bitcoins on the Bitcoin Core blockchain, is a separate court case.
- tylersmith 5y agoHe does not want transactions reverted, he wants Bitcoin Core to change the rules of who can spend coins to allow him to make new transactions that are currently not allowed. He is implementing this in his own Bitcoin fork, Bitcoin SV, to demonstrate that it can be done.
- uncletammy 5y agoA more realistic goal is probably to get the court's blessing to authorize nchain, who maintain the only BSV client (therefore the entire blockchain) , to send Satoshi's BSV coins to Craig. This seems much easier to achieve and allows him to steal coins from all BSV holders without taking from any one BSV holder in particular. Coins previously thought lost would be reintroduced, effectively inflating the coin's supply. That's a quick and easy ~ $83M based on today's BSV price and a conservative estimate of the number of coins held by satoshi.
- lbriner 5y agoWhat are the theories about why the real Satoshi doesn't just move all the coin to another wallet himself to prove that Craig Wright is just a scammer?
- me_me_me 5y agoThey are dead. They lost unbackuped drives. They found god and abandoned technology all together. Abducted by aliens, or taken by time travellers. Craig Wright is just a scammer, caught red handed lying so many times, why would you trouble yourself and your anonymity to prove water is wet?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fredoralive 5y agoPossibly that they're dead, such as with the Hal Finney as Satoshi theory. Otherwise they've could've lost the private keys, be in jail, became a hermit, or plenty of options like that. If Satoshi is multiple people, perhaps they can't agree on an action. Or maybe they could just like the chaos.
- tata71 5y agoOr believe the chaos is better than their perceived alternative.
- throwaway473825 5y agoSatoshi couldn't care less about a scammer like Craig Wright, assuming Satoshi can move the coins.
- toopok4k3 5y agoBecause the real Satoshi might be dead and took the keys with him to grave. I, to this day don't understand why it's not obvious why Satoshi has not done anything public for over 10 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Kleiman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Kleiman Craig knew Dave, knows the coins are so close to his reach but he will never get to them.
- GBiT 5y agoFrom legal standpoint it is interesting case and it can bring precedent to crypto scene. We will know if person can lose coins and retrieve them back lawful way with court order. Even more interesting, that most miners are now located in USA jurisdiction. We know, that Google and others can adjust results based on courts orders. It's interesting if miners who invested hundred millions into mining operation could follow order and implement changes to mining software. It its a known secret, that right now, major miners do some changes and implementations, like for example blacklisting/watching big cold wallets of major exchanges for coins to be secure and not stolen by mistake.
- rrobukef 5y agoHell, it can bring precedent to OSS licenses. Bitcoin is MIT licensed : '[...] THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, [...]'. If you, as a creator, can hold co-authors responsible for losses.
- nullc 5y agoFWIW, in this legal action Wright expressly states that his claims of being Bitcoin's creator are irrelevant for the case. His claimed cause of action is that as a user he negligently handled his bitcoins and lost them to hackers, and that the some random subset of the authors (e.g. the ones best able to debunk his claims of being Bitcoin's creator) owe him a fiduciary duty to make him whole.
- emteycz 5y agoThis makes no sense to me. The court orders... who exactly, to return the coins? AFAIK a new Bitcoin fork would have to be made (by whom?) - and there's no guarantee the fork would be accepted by anyone.
- pczy 5y agoEven being non-American with my necessarily flawed understanding of the US constitution, the scenario you described strikes me as a clear violation of the first amendment. First, you would have to compel someone to write new code that changes the way bitcoin fundamentally works. Assuming you manage to do so, you would then have to compel "everyone" to recognise the hard-fork as the "true" chain, again something clearly at odds with the first amendment, and I suspect the laws in many other jurisdictions as well (for obvious reasons).
- yob22 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoAside from the obvious, can someone at least tell me how these claims are rationalized because they make no sense: 1) If the hackers copied and deleted the private keys from his computer 2) Why does Bitcoin SV need to be modified in order for the funds to be accessed Do people on HN even know why those statements are not reconcilable? Does TheRegister, does the judge? I don't care what Craig Wright knows or thinks, he is a troll regardless, but I'm not even sure if his incoherent claims are something slightly more coherent that everyone else messed up. Wait, is he saying that because he doesn't have the private keys, he wants the whole Bitcoin SV network modified to give him access to funds in a specific address? lol. okay. I feel like he could just rent some hashpower to force a confidence breaking change on the network but I guess he wants court approval.
- tylersmith 5y agoWhat you said at the end is correct. He is aiming to have the courts somehow force through a Bitcoin hard fork that moves Satoshi's coins to an address controlled by himself, and he is including his Bitcoin fork, BSV, so that his team can implement the fork and show the courts it's a viable remedy. Then he'll say to the courts "look the developers and miners for BSV made the change so it's possible; You need to go after the Bitcoin people and make them do the same."
- vmception 5y agoSo far I get the impression that judges are mildly amused by him, at least the one in Florida, otherwise they would commit him to an asylum or dismiss his cases outright
- drexlspivey 5y ago> I feel like he could just rent some hashpower to force a confidence breaking change on the network but I guess he wants court approval. Even with 100% hashpower you can’t steal coins from an address without the key
- jimmydorry 5y ago
- janaagaard 5y ago“I remember reading it… Probably, when I wrote it.” https://youtu.be/cKbPNFUHLYM https://youtu.be/cKbPNFUHLYM
- ddtaylor 5y agoHe just keeps giving and giving.
- aqme28 5y agoCraig Wright is such a fraud. The ALAB Podcast episode on him is hilarious. He's got some serious mental issues. My favorite part about the saga is that after he claimed to be Satoshi and have access to billions of dollars, everyone involved in lawsuits with him agreed. "Yeah, okay you've got billions of dollars. So that means you owe the plaintiff half of that, and the Australian tax authorities a chunk too."
- smcl 5y agoI particularly liked the bit about him thinking he was clever denying that a printout of an email was an email. Ohh or the forged signature. There’s so much to love in this case, I would not have known half of the stupidity surrounding it if I hadn’t listened that ALAB episode
- tata71 5y agoYour first three sentences are pretty fucked up, when read together.
- aqme28 5y agoYou're not wrong, but it's hard not to laugh when someone is the victim of their own hubris this often.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoHe must figure that his creditors will help him grab those 1.1 million coins, at which point he could lose 90% of them and still be wealthy... if he manages to sell them before its perceived value crashes.
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- Terry_Roll 5y agoDoes anyone know if there are any lock out mechanisms on accounts which stall access after x number of password attempts?
- ddtaylor 5y agoThat's not how wallets work. A wallet is the private key (some secret bytes) and as long as you have those bytes (or something that re-creates those bytes, such as a passphrase) you have the ability to sign a message that is published on the blockchain which moves/spends your coins.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoSo what you call a passphrase I would call a password, but its the secret bytes which have to be known in order for the blockchain to allow the move.
- ddtaylor 5y agoThat's where it gets a bit complex. There are both passwords and phrases, but usually for different purposes: Traditional passwords are used sometimes to encrypt the secret bytes (private key) similar to how an SSH key might be encrypted and unlocked. In this usage the actual bytes are encrypted and stored somewhere (like on disk) and if you lose that file or the password you used to encrypt it, you therefore lose the private key and can no longer sign messages or "spend" the coins. This is how Bitcoin functioned in the early years. Some people instead use what originally were called "brain wallets" and are mnemonic lists of words that then get used through a key derivation function (KDF) to turn those words into the secret bytes. In this kind of setup you don't have the secret bytes stored anywhere but rather you need to remember the phrase (list of words) which is in turn used to generate the secret bytes deterministically.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoYeah but ultimately I still need those bytes to move the coins. Doesnt matter what method I use to come up with those bytes, beit a password or a brain wallet, they are just algo's of various length and time to compute.
- whiskyant 5y agoHasn't he already been ordered to pay $100M in damages? https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2021/12/06/craig-wright-found-not-liable-for-kleiman-business-partnership/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2021/12/06/craig-wright-fou... Why is this guy still scamming? Did he not learn his lesson?
- uncletammy 5y agoIt's not his own money he's spending on these lawsuits. He is being bankrolled by a criminal billionaire gambling mogul. It's an investment being made in order to get access to all of Satoshi's coins on all the bitcoin chains. Those coins are valued very conservatively at no less than 32 billion usd.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoThe moment someone touches them their value will tank. Part of the bitcoin speculation is that massive wallets like this one are frozen and out of the market. When people "invest" by buying hundredths of bitcoin, someone reintroducing 1.1 million will make them wary. These wallets might as well be considered trip wired, some people monitor them constantly.
- nullc 5y agoReally old never before moved coins move from time to time, including ones from Wright's list of 1.1 million coins. It sometimes generates a little noise on twitter or a throwaway news article, sometimes it goes without being noticed in the public. Nothing much happens either way.
- segfaultbuserr 5y agoI'm seriously curious about Craig Wright as a character and his mentality. At one point I did some digging and found his early pre-2015 blog. As you can see here, he described himself as a "GSE-Compliance and GSE-Malware" [0]. You can also see he was working on his PhD research project in a university, and also doing some system administration at the university's HPC center [1][2]. Scrolling through the blog, the published articles included Windows commandline, Process Explorer, how shellcode works, etc. There are all basic things, not some extraordinarily creative or original works. Thus, he was basically a regular IT security DevOps with a business, and also studies in an university for some regular research projects. I can easily imagine that the things he did was what an average user of Hacker News does. So, what really happened in the meanwhile? What made him to metamorphose from a regular security geek into a persistent scammer who claims he's Satoshi Nakamoto? I think this is the real question to ask. There must have been some external forces come into play that made him do that. A rumor I've heard is that Wright's business was running into debt, so somehow he made a deal with Calvin Ayre. Calvin Ayre became his financial backer, and as the condition of this transaction, Craig Wright must claim he is Satoshi Nakamoto and acts as if it's real. This is probably what happened. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20111123102230/http://gse-compliance.blogspot.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20111123102230/http://gse-compli... [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20151123012430/http://gse-compliance.blogspot.com/2014/10/for-today.html https://web.archive.org/web/20151123012430/http://gse-compli... [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20150121024725/http://gse-compliance.blogspot.com/2014/11/interest-and-research-call.html https://web.archive.org/web/20150121024725/http://gse-compli...
- nullc 5y ago> So, what really happened in the meanwhile? What made him to metamorphose from a regular security geek into a persistent scammer who claims he's Satoshi Nakamoto? I think this is the real question to ask. There must have been some external forces come into play that made him do that. Wright's been a low grade crook for a long time. He was sentenced to 30 days in prison in 2004 for contempt after he forged documents to try to escape some non-compete he violated. The proximal cause of his Satoshi related cosplay is a massive tax fraud. AU has a refundable tax credit for qualifying R&D where they'll pay out around 30% of the money you spent on research. Wright spun up a bunch of companies that did nothing but claim these credits-- with an intention of claiming around 65 million dollars worth. AU paid out the first round but the next year audited him. Their first question to cut through his obfuscation was "Where did the millions you claim to have spent on research come from?". Bitcoin had just become a big thing in the news and Wright started claiming to be an early miner, pointed to coins from a bitcoin rich list and said they were his, and claimed to have received loans secured by those coins to pay for the research. [There is also a whole separate branch of fraudulent sales tax rebates that he applied for when the R&D credits started souring on him-- but most of the docs on that haven't been made public yet] Wright created a huge number of forgeries to support his claims and kept expanding the scope until he was claiming to be Satoshi, but the AU tax office wasn't fooled, ruled against him, and demanded he return the money he took. He'd already spent much of the money, so he basically just took the faked documents that the tax office was too smart to fall for and sought out other suckers to fall for them. Effectively the classic Nigerian prince scam, offering people a share of his fortune if they could just help him overcome his short term cashflow problems. There is some indication that he'd been engaging in this R&D credit fraud for up to a decade before the enormous applications that got him caught-- he's recently published R&D credit applications for fake projects (basically just applying for R&D funding for concepts he saw posted on tech mailing lists) going back to 2002-ish. So either these applications are recent forgeries or he's been funding himself through fraud for at least the last 20 years. The relatively uncertainty about the earlier possible fraud there is that for the big 2013+ tax fraud much of the tax office documentation has been made public as a result of a civil lawsuit against Wright, so for that we can be pretty sure what happened... but for things other than that we just have Wright's statements to go on, and Wright is a fantasist and pathological liar that constantly makes stuff up even when its not to any advantage to him.
- twox2 5y agoCraig Wright is a patent troll, a narcissist, and a sociopath. It's amazing how far he has been able to take this grift. Part of it is that he has been able to adopt this unwavering character and not break it for years.... something a normal person just isn't wired to do.
- tata71 5y agoSo why aren't we asking what's happened to him, instead of presuming malice? (Genuinely)
- twox2 5y agoI think it's pretty clear that it is malice. But to your question - I suppose I agree. I don't think society usually tries to help malignant people whether or not it stems from mental health issues or not. We tend to focus more on punitive measures than rehabilitation if someone does something out of line.
- janandonly 5y agoIt's interesting that Jack Dorsey (of Twitter fame) and others are now paying for the lawyer bills of all the developers who might be sued by this fraudster [1]. Bitcoin and LN legal defense fund: Jack Dorsey, Alex Morcos, and Martin White posted to the Bitcoin-Dev mailing list the announcement of a legal defense fund for developers working on Bitcoin, LN, and related technology. The fund “is a nonprofit entity that aims to minimize legal headaches that discourage software developers from actively developing Bitcoin and related projects”. [1] https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2022-January/019741.html https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2022...
- nullc 5y agoThe 'coins' are really not the important part of the story here. Bitcoin is open source cryptographic software developed by volunteers under the MIT license. Wright-- via a web of shady shell corporations-- has sued a dozen current and former Bitcoin contributors (including myself) demanding that they introduce a backdoor to allow him to bypass the authentication and take possession of coins without providing a digital signature, or-- if that fails to work-- pay him around $6 billion dollars in damages. The assets he's seeking to obtain are very obviously not his (though he argues we lack standing to challenge his assertion), but that isn't the most important consideration: More critically, the remedy he seeks is simply not possible. The defendants have no more power than anyone else, including Wright, to publish an incompatible version of Bitcoin-- but any such incompatible version will just form a separate currency, and no one-- not any developer, not any court, not any human power-- can force other people to adopt this alternative version or consider it to be "bitcoin". Wright has already created one such alternative version "BSV", which essentially no one uses and it trades for less than 0.004% of bitcoin's value. Wright is well aware that the remedy he seeks is an impossibility and that he has no real prospect of success. Given that he can't be successful, you may wonder what goals are (1) Profit: He's been selling these "inaccessible" coins at a deep discount to at least one mark, it doesn't matter that his case will be unsuccessful so long as he can find people who think it might be successful willing to buy a share in the winnings. (2) Wright is attempting to intimidate and disqualify the worlds foremost experts in Bitcoin technology from providing evidence another lawsuit about his fradulent claims of being Satoshi. (3) Wright intends to use the legal fees to financially ruin parties who have refused to aid his fraudulent schemes, particularly because the UK uses a loser-pays where the loser of each motion pays the other sides legal costs and Wright racks up astronomical costs. Wright has already bankrupted a journalist that discussed his fraudulent claims of being Satoshi with a defamation lawsuit, even though Wright hasn't won against him (the case is ongoing). Wright effectively argues that anyone who has ever built software using bitcoin is a fiduciary which owes him a duty of care which extends even as far as compensating him at their own expenses for losses created as a result of his own negligence. His position is that this is even the case even though they offered the software under a license stipulating "IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.", even though their work was uncompensated, and even though they had no relationship with him or his entities. He also contends that the liability continues forever and, in fact, I stopped working on Bitcoin completely several years ago long before his supposed loss occurred. (Several other defendants also stopped working on Bitcoin years ago) Wright is attempting to improve his odds in the case by making a proxy entity which he created "Bitcoin Association for BSV" the primary defendant, already it's attempting to undermine our effort to challenge the jurisdiction of the UK courts by agreeing to the jurisdiction (normally one defendant agreeing is enough to settle the matter). Wright has used the trick of suing his sockpuppet to get a bespoke civil judgement in the past. This lawsuit has implications far outside the realm of Bitcoin or cryptocurrency: The case highlights apparent flaws in our legal system where a well funded party with no prospect of actually winning their case can submit flagrant lies and forgeries with near impunity and cause finical ruin for their targets with an obviously meritless case. This is particularly stark for volunteer free software developers, where even modest legal costs easily overwhelm the indirect gains of publishing free code and related pro-social activities. Obviously free software more or less can't exist if the clear text of the license is ignored and volunteer developers are going to be hit with massive liability (or massive legal fees) for software they created without direct compensation. The case also has substantial civil rights implications-- Wright asks governments to use their power over the defendants to compel both labor on his behalf and speech: He seeks to force us to develop backdoor code to bypass Bitcoin's transaction authentication and he seeks to force us to publish it (and presumably endorse it). He also seeks to suppress speech: he is asking the government force the defendants to remove and refrain from future publication of non-backdoored source code.