3 ms·
"Somehow" doesn't mean we should entertain options that are guaranteed to be futile. There are already better methods that have been devised an even tested at s
by jiggawatts 5y ago
"Somehow" doesn't mean we should entertain options that are guaranteed to be futile. There are already better methods that have been devised an even tested at small industrial scales.
This isn't a problem of scale, and the problem is that optimistic people just don't get this.
There is no way to make this work, ever. It's like the old joke: "Sure, we're selling every unit at a loss, but we'll make up for it with volume!"
You can't take a "business plan" that inherently loses money and try to scale it up to... what? Even greater losses?
(In this case, this is both a thermodynamic and a financial loss. You're burning both energy and cash!)
- hackeraccount 5y agoThat's like saying I lose money on lunch everyday. It's true - lunch never pays me, I don't make it up in volume and I won't even break even. My life is bigger then lunch though. Lunch enables me to do other things that do make money - so I take a loss on lunch with a view towards the other stuff.
- jiggawatts 5y agoA human being can never use their energy gained from their food to reduce all of their exhaled CO2 back to carbon, no matter what technique they use. It’s impossible, of the perpetual machine variety. This is precisely analogous to this gallium example! You can’t unburn something without losing more energy in the process than the burning produced. It’s always over 100% overhead. ALWAYS!! The details and the path taken through the world of chemistry or electrochemistry are totally irrelevant and can never alter this.