7 ms·
Designing for a right to repair
- jaqalopes 5y agoAs an American I learned a lot from this article. The idea of encouraging product design that is specifically repairable with the same parts that went into it during the initial manufacturing seems like an obviously great idea, but I know enough about planned obsolescence to know why that isn't the world we live in. The examples here about irreversible disassembly (breaking things) was also eye opening. It makes perfect sense but I had never considered or really noticed this phenomenon. Of course it should be possible to take an electric toothbrush completely apart and recycle the components, but that's often so difficult that the entire thing gets thrown away, wasting all the components, recyclable or not. I am sensitive to environmental problems but hadn't ever really thought about it at the level of these products, thinking such waste was just an inevitable feature of Capitalism. I'm very heartened to learn that there is a legislative effort in the EU, however nascent, to try and change these patterns and create a better future through design. I will never think about "right to repair" the same way again.
- ajuc 5y agoI remember watching a video by industry insider taking apart Tesla and VW electric motors and comparing them. And he was constantly complaining that VW uses too many bolts and screws where they could make snap-in connections that are cheaper and less likely to vibrate loose. Like there wasn't even a thought in his mind that making it possible to disassemble and reassemble an engine is a good thing.
- lisper 5y agoI recently had the unfortunate experience of attempting to recycle a Sonicair toothbrush. The "disassembly" process to extract the (dead) battery did not work as advertised, and I had to attack the case with several additional implements of destruction besides a hammer. I was shocked at how difficult it was. There is absolutely no way that the average consumer is going to succeed in extracting the battery, and so all those toxic materials are going to end up in landfills. Unfortunately, I've also tried many other electric toothbrushes and none of them work as well as my Sonicair. So I'm left with the horrible choice of either polluting the environment or settling for substandard care for my teeth. :-( :-( :-(
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago> There is absolutely no way that the average consumer is going to succeed in extracting the battery, and so all those toxic materials are going to end up in landfills. Only if your country / region's waste processing sucks. There are separate hand-in points for things like electronics, and garbage should be sorted before yote into landfill to sort out recyclables and toxins. I believe that they can't just put chemical waste (e.g. batteries) into landfills in most countries.
- beerandt 5y agoEven the most basic municipal landfill is lined, capped, and waterproofed such that even hazardous materials that might end up there aren't "polluting the environment". There are reasons to sort out certain waste, usually as a precaution to chemical reactions, but not leeching, but its mistaken to assume only "toxic" waste is isolated from the environment, The reason they are called "sanitary" landfills is that they already safely contain concentrated sewage, and prevent it from infiltrating water supplies.
- vlovich123 5y agoFor electronic devices, this would also mean the ability to load on your own SW on any processor. That means the manufacturer needs to provide the toolchain, relevant specs, and source code (basically whatever they used for development) in escrow. Additionally, many updates are now cryptographically signed which means you'd need to put keys in escrow that get released when support from the manufacturer ends (which itself has serious security implications since the escrow holder, in addition to the manufacturer, now has root access to all devices). This is actually very hard to define. Ideally it would also include any code that's updateable including firmware, but then are you including things like CPU firmware?
- unglaublich 5y agoThey could transfer escrow to a trusted international org that can provide keys to users.
- marapuru 5y agoFor those who like to read more about designing for product EOL, I highly encourage Ends. by Joe MacLeod. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35857076-ends https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35857076-ends
- disruptiveink 5y agoMy issue with most repair jobs as a hobbyist who can do amateur level of soldering is, oddly enough, stripped screws. No matter what I'm trying to do and despite my best efforts, there's a very high chance of me stripping a screw, which is something that can happen in seconds and then either becomes very hard to recover or impossible. At some point, I either have leave it alone or destroy the casing altogether. They show a Playstation 3 controller in the article, which is actually easy to get into... if you don't strip the screws. Just a few seconds of using a PH0 bit instead of the required PH00 the other day lost me a controller that probably could have been saved. Is this a case of bad tools? I can definitely believe that when tackling rusty, big screws: larger and higher quality screwdrivers with good grips definitely made the difference for me in the past. But for precision jobs, I have no clue what I'm doing wrong. I was using an iFixit driver kit for this job. How do you avoid this? Do you absolutely have to know the exact bit to use for every screw beforehand? Is just guessing "eh, this looks about right" just asking for trouble? The much maligned in right-to-repair circles Torx and Apple pentalobe screws are actually great for me. Never in my life I ruined one of those, where sometimes I feel like I damage one out of five Philips or flat head screws I attempt to unscrew.
- handsarebags 5y agoSecond the call for quality screwdrivers. You might be encountering thread locker too. You’ll notice a residue on the threads of screws. I’ve used a narrow tip on a hot air reflow gun to heat up fasteners I know have a thread locker on them. Do need to be aware of what is heat sensitive and how the hearts spreading. Is sometimes not an option.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoTorx are really good screws actually, I believe you can apply more torque to them without stripping them and they're a staple in any repair kit these days. Similarly I have screws (and adapters) in my toolkit that look a bit like torx, they inspire me with a lot more confidence than Philips heads. And my TV is mounted to the wall with 8cm deep screw-bolts. That one didn't come with any tools, but we have a set of ratchet bolt thingymajigs that did the job just fine. My drill bit just was a little too short and the hole was on the wonk so it still took far longer than I would like, but, lessons learned.
- asicsp 5y agoI think "Design for repair" (based on post link) is a better title than "The last design you'll ever make"
- titzer 5y agoI recently bought an antique chair, literally from the 1800s. It is a little thing, probably a child's chair. One of the legs broke. At first I was sad since it was a nice buy ($15?) and fit exactly into a little space I had for it. I mean, it survives a hundred years and then gets broken by my idiocy within weeks? Then I had a look. The thing is put together with no screws. It's literally a friction fit for every one of the 4 legs and cross braces. So fixing it is as easy as spinning up a wood lathe and making a new leg. And it turns out...it has been repaired already. This is why it has lasted 100 years.
- joncrocks 5y agoChair of Theseus... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus
- funkaster 5y agolike most GA planes. Eventually you'll replace _almost_ everything in them :)
- rhapsodic 5y ago>So fixing it is as easy as spinning up a wood lathe and making a new leg. Which, for 99.99% of humanity, equates to "not easy".
- titzer 5y agoThat's just if you want to match the actual leg style. A round stick of wood with a hole in the right spot would technically work :-) I don't have a lathe, but when I run across one, I'll give it a go, or ask a friend.
- jandrese 5y agoThe trick is hand carving the pegs exactly the right size to friction fit in the hole. Without a lathe that is tall ask. But also I wonder if they didn't include some glue to hold that chair together originally. Screws in furniture are mostly just there to keep the thing together while the glue cures.
- TrailMixRaisin 5y agoThe article links to the Billy disassembly instructions (https://rabbitholeprodorch001.blob.core.windows.net/plugins/disassembly_uk/Disassembly-Instructions_BILLY_uk.pdf https://rabbitholeprodorch001.blob.core.windows.net/plugins/...) I thought this a great idea until I have seen step 5. This step is exactly the reason why I opened the document as every other step is straight forward. "Just magically remove the 18 nails that you hammered into the back." If you have ever tried to do that you have noticed that this is hard to do without damaging yourself or your furniture. On the same level the instructions could tell me to remove the glue or unweld a seam. The disassembly instructions are not more than the assembly in descending order.
- anamexis 5y agoTo be fair, those are just little brads that just hold the backing on, which is a step above cardboard. I think it wouldn't be too hard to remove them with a nail puller while keeping the front unblemished.
- formerly_proven 5y agoJust use the backing as the nail puller, soft kick from inside the cabinet does it just fine.
- nemetroid 5y agoHaven’t done this with a Billy in particular, but in my experience flimsy backings give out before the nails do.
- jandrese 5y agoSlip a putty knife between the backing and the nails and use it to pry. If the backing fails then you can remove the nails using a pair of pliers but you'll need to find a new backing. This of course assumes the person who assembled the furniture originally didn't use glue on all of the joints like I do. I've found that if you glue all of the joints in a flat pack when building it the expected lifetime can be improved by an order of magnitude or more, especially if you're moving it around regularly. Seriously it is night and day between the wobbly one you only followed the directions on and completely solid one that's fully glued.
- KronisLV 5y agoAside from all of the planned obsolescence that others are talking about in the comments (which rightfully deserves discussion), i can't help but to feel like this hardly works for information and communication technology devices - smartphones, tablets, laptops/netbooks, desktop computers, consoles etc. The industry as a whole has this odd desire to always push for better hardware and newer things, to the point where Windows 11 refused to support older AMD processors and whatnot. At the same time, Android 8.1 (the OS on one of my older phones) has been abandoned and thus makes the device not an entirely viable backup phone; unless i'm okay with running insecure software, or want to install custom ROMs that will break things, especially in the case of a non-mainstream vendor. To me, it feels like we should stop forcing progress before its time has come, which we currently do with better hardware that is used in suboptimal ways and tossing aside everything that can't keep up, as opposed to actually investing decades to write better software. Right now, my desktop PC has a 1st gen Ryzen 3 1200. If it were not for the OS, the browser and almost every piece of software and even game that i want to play becoming more bloated, i could safely use it for a decade with no issues, Wirth's law be damned. In my servers i have 200GEs that are similarly old and yet, are fully sufficient for my homelab needs, but eventually you won't be able to buy any old new stock for reasonable prices, because AMD will be off chasing whatever new skew or technology they need to remain competitive. Even Firefox, the browser that was supposed to be "the good one" (e.g. default in most Linux distros, less controversial than Chrome/Chromium) got noticeably worse sometime around the Quantum upgrade in regards to its RAM usage, even when you limit its content process count to just 1. Similarly, it feels like most IDEs nowadays are also somewhat heavyweight - why can't i have exceedingly boring looking software that has a lot of the smart autocomplete that i'd expect, yet doesn't slow the whole machine down when things need to be re-rendered because of a non-native UI toolkit? Just look at how snappy Lazarus is: https://www.lazarus-ide.org/ https://www.lazarus-ide.org/ And yet, i cannot feasibly do webdev or many projects with it, because no hype means no new tools, no ecosystem support and so on, so i'm essentially dragged along to use whatever the modern tech choices are, like JetBrains products which are admittedly otherwise great and allow me to work with almost every popular tech stack, yet still eat lots of RAM. I guess this is less of a rant and more of a question to the people here: how do you fight back against this supposed progress, that somehow manages to couple security updates and feature updates with otherwise unnecessary bells, whistles and unreasonable amount of browser tech and whitespace in most software? How do you fight back against your hand being forced to create e-waste? Do you use Alpine, Debian (LXDE, LXQt or even XFCE) or another lightweight Linux distro (or even something of the BSD variety) as a daily driver and live with the fact that some software and most of gaming will often be a no-go (about 30/120 games that i have on Steam are even supported on Linux)? Do you do complicated setups with Windows VMs and GPU passthrough and relative mouse movement modes or something? Maybe you try to cut down your Windows installs as much as possible, removing bloat regularly, attempting to match Microsoft's ability to put it in, in combination with dual booting? Or do you just have a dedicated machine or two that (hopefully) aren't connected to the network and run EOL software (i've personally seen folks doing that with Windows XP), thus freeing you from updates that do things that you don't want? Or is there a really nice solution that i'm not aware of?
- fps-hero 5y agoSometimes documentation can be redundant. Strip down an Anker USB cable and you'll find four coloured-coded wires: red, black, green and white. Presumably this helps during the assembly process, but it also makes repair work a breeze. UK and EU mains wiring is similarly colour coded. Software developers will joke about self-documenting code that's so clear it doesn't even need comments. Maybe this is the hardware equivalent? The only axiom that holds true is a cable’s wiring is only how it probes out, and whether that is correct or not is an exercise for the engineer to determine. - Top image search results for USB wiring show green and white flipped, and they are not wrong, because they often are. The standard is only between the connectors, the exact wiring doesn’t matter if it works. - Cheap cables won’t have a black wire, they reuse the cable shield as ground return. Funnily enough, cheap cables also use a cheap shield bread which isn’t flex appropriate, so 95% this will fail first. - Cheap products that come with their own appropriately cheap USB cable often take liberties with USB standards, such as actually using the connector shield as ground return and leave the ground pin disconnect, because they know their product does this internally. You will have a great day when you pull this cable out of your draw.
- SeanLuke 5y agoInteresting that he mentions the Dave Smith Instruments (now Sequential) Prophet 12. I have a Prophet P08, and have opened it up to repair it, and it is a work of design elegance. It contains five boards, each connected via an easily removed ribbon cable, attached to a metal body with just a few screws. You can trivially remove all the boards, and in fact I did exactly this to ship the boards to the company for a minor repair rather than shipping the entire unit. Another work of design beauty was the NeXTstation, NeXT's pizza-box shaped workstation. A solid magnesium case with an elegant molded heat sink on bottom, opens with a single screw in the back. Inside there's a fan (two screws), a power supply attached directly to the case over the heat sink (one screw), a mount for the floppy drive (one screw), a mount for the hard drive (one screw), and the motherboard (one or two screws). And that's it -- that's the entire thing! You can break down the entire machine in less than five minutes. Did I mention it's made of solid magnesium? How NeXT/Apple has fallen.
- mountain_peak 5y agoFunny, I have a DSI PolyEvolver, and when one voice decided to go on the fritz with an intermittent issue, I couldn't find a schematic anywhere (that's because DSI hasn't made a technical service manual available for years). Not that other synth manufacturers are more forthcoming with service manuals, but they are at least "available", which helps immensely when troubleshooting. DSI was very helpful, but in the end, the issue turned out to be a lead-free solder joint issue on one the DSP legs (early lead-free solder was prone to cracking under repeated heating and cooling cycles). Not sure what the article is implying by saying the Prophet has interesting silkscreen designs or instructions - that may help remove the right components to send back to DSI, but doesn't help someone diagnose and repair the board themselves. Oh, also, I have successfully replaced the battery in a Sonicare toothbrush without destroying it - still working to this day.
- SeanLuke 5y agoIf you get frustrated with your PolyEvolver, feel free to ship it directly to me :-) Seriously though, I build patch editors in my spare time (https://github.com/eclab/edisyn https://github.com/eclab/edisyn) and would really like to make an editor for the PolyEvolver.
- Taywee 5y agoI've been using some Leopold mechanical keyboards for 10 years now. I've had one dead keyswitch and one chattering one, and both were extremely easy replacements, needing just a little bit of soldering. I've been preaching this exact thing for a long time. Little annoys me more than a design that is not repairable. As an aside, Österreich has two R's, and "Österreich Post" isn't inflected correctly, and would more likely be something like "Österreichische Post" (depending on the context, but mixing languages makes inflection weird).
- _nalply 5y agoI ordered a Framework laptop and hope that this the laptop that will stay for decades with me till I die. https://frame.work https://frame.work
- nayuki 5y agoThe linked PDF about illegal build configurations in LEGO was an interesting read: http://casadebricks.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Stressing-The-Elements.pdf http://casadebricks.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Stressing...
- automotive_eng 5y agoAdding my experience (automotive components engineer for OEMs). There is currently no push to make parts repairable. What our cusomers (OEMs) care is: price, safety, reliability, quality, performance, compliance to standards, fast developmnent, fast introduction to production In my 20 year career I never ever got a request regarding making parts repairable. The target is that the part must not break down in the life of the product (10-15 years). After that nobody cares. We are more or less moving away from screwing parts together - instead of this welding/gluing/press fiting joints are used. This is just to save 0.1-0.2 € per part by removing few screws, using lower quality polymeric materials, etc. (the cost of complete assembly for OEM is in the range of 20-30€). As long as the part is cheap, meets performance, safety, life requirements the OEMs are happy. Until there will be no law that will require manufacturers to make parts repairable nothing will change. We as parts suppliers will strive to make parts as reliable as possible, but just enough to meet life requirements and not comprimise safety.
- teachrdan 5y agoIn terms of automotive manufacturing, I've heard it said: "Cars aren't designed to be easily repaired. They're designed to be easily assembled, once."
- wand3r 5y agoKind of an aside, but can anyone recommend an online (preferably free) product/industrial design class? I am interested in learning about making a physical product, something like furniture or small consumer goods. Just curious but havent found a good one on edx or the like yet...
- webmaven 5y agoNot a class or course per-se, but I've found the New Yankee Workshop TV show to be really helpful and informative: https://www.newyankee.com/watch/ https://www.newyankee.com/watch/
- userbinator 5y agoI think one of the better examples of design-for-repair is mid-century cars. They are spacious to work on, few special tools are necessary beyond the usual things you can find in a machine shop, and parts and documentation are plentiful. Of course it could be argued that they had to be, because they were designed for periodic maintenance rather than to last a "lifetime" without. Nobody does design for disassembly better than the Phillips Sonicare toothbrush, whose manual notes "this process is not reversible" before graphically wrapping the toothbrush in a cloth and smashing with a hammer to access the battery. I've seen ones where the bottom is screwed on and they supply the "wrench" as part of the base, although it is intended for "recycling": http://www.davidgunter.com/2021/01/25/braun-oral-b-electric-toothbrush-battery-replacement/ http://www.davidgunter.com/2021/01/25/braun-oral-b-electric-... Thinking about the design, it's clear that they actively designed against you replacing the batteries or attempting to repair --- instead of a simple threaded cap with an o-ring for sealing and spring contacts for the battery inside, like a flashlight or vape mod, they decided to solder the battery and make it harder to or even impossible to open non-destructively. In other words, they decided to make their own assembly process slightly harder as well.