3 ms·
> Wilson was not without faults, as I highlighted in the podcast I recorded with David Sloan Wilson and Charles C. Mann. Many scientists I know and respect have
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
> Wilson was not without faults, as I highlighted in the podcast I recorded with David Sloan Wilson and Charles C. Mann. Many scientists I know and respect have expressed skepticism and dismissal of some of Wilson’s enthusiasms. Great scientists of the past are not gods any more than great scientists still among us, but humans, with all the complexity that entails.
Well this is shocking, speaking ill of the dead like this.
It seems there's some secret list of things you're allowed to attack prominent dead scientists about.
Anyone got a copy of that list?
Can I also add that if one of your prominent motifs in your environmentalism is "certain people in specific areas of the globe should have less babies" then it's maybe not the great defence against charges of racism that you might think it is.
Hopefully that's something you are allowed to disagree with him on.
- ghusto 5y agoI know I shouldn't, but okay I'll bite. > It seems there's some secret list of things you're allowed to attack prominent dead scientists about. Highlighting certain views that I scientist held to be problematic because they focussed their work to prove those views (e.g. Nazis and eugenics) is indeed "allowed". Using someone's death and your own ignorance of basic science, to promote your own political views, is not.
- VictorPath 5y ago
- Turing_Machine 5y ago> In 1975 Wilson began publishing the white race is superior to the black race. Can you provide a verbatim quote from his published work where he said that?
- rwnspace 5y agoYet in 1981 he either had a total change of heart, or, you are - wittingly or unwittingly - spreading misinformation: https://www.nature.com/articles/289627b0.pdf https://www.nature.com/articles/289627b0.pdf
- topynate 5y agoThe open letter makes one central point: that the SA article is a nearly pure ad hominem, i.e. that Lemore attacks E.O. Wilson himself, not any particular thing which he actually did or said. She simply does not establish anything that could be on any list (secret or otherwise) of things for which one could attack Wilson. (Just to be clear, the open letter does not make the point you impute to it – that the article makes supportable claims, but that those claims shouldn't be made against Wilson because he's a "prominent dead scientist".) Given that, it's not as if there's any real charge of racism laid that would require a defence, and in fact the open letter does not use Wilson's environmentalism as a defence of this sort. Why then do you mention it in this connexion? Perhaps to introduce the 'motif' you mention, which despite being in quotation marks does not appear to be a direct quote. What then, seeing as you have raised it, was the ideological content of Wilson's views on ecology and overpopulation? That population growth drives overexploitation of nature, with disastrous ecological consequences. This is opposed by those who view industry, not people, as the prime cause of overexploitation. The debate is roughly between those who would set aside and protect part of the Earth and those who see the Earth as already unnatural. Or "Half-Earth" vs. "the Anthropocene", to use each side's slogans. To be sure, some of the side opposed to Wilson have been known to attempt to racialise the views of the set-asiders. For an eloquent defence of Half-Earth against these and other ideological attacks, see "Half the earth for people (or more)? Addressing ethical questions in conservation" by Helen Kopnina. (PDF: https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/access/item%3A2916196/view https://scholarlypublications.universiteitleiden.nl/access/i...) I suppose it took you five minutes or less to write your comment. That it took me half an hour to compose a sufficient reply is a fine demonstration of Brandolini's law, should any more such be needed. Just one more thing. E.O. Wilson's own words on whether population control should be imposed by anyone, on anyone: "Should nations have a population policy? Should religions have a population policy? It seems to me that one is scurrying on the edge of fascistic ideas if one tells people how many children they can have, altering the entire nature of the society." From his interview at http://churchandstate.org.uk/2019/09/e-o-wilson-runaway-population-growth-at-epicenter-of-environmental-problems/ http://churchandstate.org.uk/2019/09/e-o-wilson-runaway-popu...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThat PDF utterly fails to address any of the points raised and has a very ecofascist vibe. It actively lowers my opinion of E O Wilson if that's considered a defense of his ideas.